In game though, people rarely meet their top speed, acceleration is usually the biggest factor, since you can get to flanks quicker
How would they have no chance of fighting planes?
Have you ever played the Sidam? Or the zsu-23-4? Both are terrible spaa.
Meanwhile the xm246, Gepard, itpsv, falcon, type 87, whatever the Chinese thing is, and lastly the ZA-35 are all monstrously good spaa in both tank and air hunting.
Mainly because they have exceptionally good radars, and cannons that hit like a truck.
There is two solutions, uptier, or remove full APHE / APDS belts.
Their primary role to be an spaa correct? Not a tank hunter?
from everything i said you only keep the Drogoon that also should go to lower br??
Not my point. Have you played it or not?
And it terms of some others, yes, some other can go down. But answer my question.
The M1296 is only reaching that 100km/h top speed if you drop it out of an aircraft mid flight lol.
1 Like
Wood has a modifier of 0.05, that 100mm of wood is like 5mm of steel, That’s barely a difference.
The track links on the Tigris do more than that, And the only reason that one is 6.0 is because it doesn’t have the big “shoot me here” cupola the H’s get.
1 Like
i have test drive it, and you still haven’t answer my question why the PUMA shouldn’t go to 10.0 while 10.0 tanks are better
nearly all brits at 7,7 have a stab. The conquerer is good at 7,7 but not GOAT or OP so why move it? Its armor is situatinal and only worls on long distance. The addonarmor often fails to stop heat and the hull is one big weekspot with a good UFP combined with slow speed and slow reload 7,7 is totaly fine.
Id the KT 105 would have recived the same engin nerf it could have went back to 6,7. You trade little more pen for 1,5x reload time. The slightly larger mantle makes you aim for the 150mm viewport even more, additinaly the rangefinder are a weekspot too where anything with HE filler will obliberate your turret crew.
I got more often pen on the tiger 1 east wooden blocks by heat than i survived ap/aphe that should have killed me. They are optical and no way an improvement justifing putting it at same BR as tiger E
1 Like
one, i have played the sidam and zsu 23, both are good for their intended role of close anti air support, aka you only go for targets that are under 1.5km, the sidams problem is simply the fact its far to high of a br for what it brings to the table, it should be 7.7
two, theyre good AT THEIR BR, but youre talking about uptiering them to 9.0 and above where they already struggle, in a 10.0 game they physically cant fight planes besides the chinese pgz09, which already sits at 9.0… because it gets ahead… ya its kinda clear you didnt really think this through and instead just got irrationally angry at spaa doing better than they should be and wanted them nerf, i mean its much better than that guy who just really sucks at cas and wants every handicap given to them.
and finally, you dont need to remove aphe, nor their apds, after all these vehicles always had these rounds and was never a problem like this(besides the DCA and falcon, their apds main belts was a problem), instead we need to fix what caused the problem in the first place, in this case its gaijin hot fix solution when they broke HE, by drastically increase the amount of fragments each round produced.
I can think the same way you do:
The 2s38 is the most powerful “light” vehicle at BR 10.7, and many players have even used it in battle at BR 12, demonstrating that the vehicle still functions as intended, which suggests its BR should be increased to at least BR 11.3.
I like your way of thinking, and it’s a solution to the problem… but there’s a small problem: Gaijin will never do it…
nahh let the 2s38 at the 10.7 lineup just get the otomatic at 11.0
The Gepards would be far more balanced facing 10.7 aircraft than facing 8.3 aircraft.
Missing CV9035 for 9.7
1 Like
squadron, i didn’t count any non TT one, also who ever says that the puma is better than the BMD-4s ?? and they are 9.7 just move the PUMA to 10.0 no one will get hurt
BMDs are like the fastest light tank, they easily sit on flanks spots behind the enemy within the first minute or two of the match.
Yeah the BMD could go up
1 Like
nahh its good at 9.7 but not broken, the same with the PUMA in 10.0 will be good not broken
See your wrong where these vehicles have “never been a problem” they’re the biggest problem.
People get nukes in them and first spawn them all the time to kill tanks because it’s so easy.
1 Like
I bring my Bt-7 into 9.7 all the time, does that mean a Bt-7 should be 9.7? No.
Only way the BMDs would go up is if they got APFSDS.
They’re quick but that’s one of their biggest pros.
They get 4 slow ATGMs, that reload quick, but you only get 4 of them, also the keybinds suck to use the weapons on it.
Then, add in the fact you literally cannot take any hit… yeah, I still think it’s fine where it is.
Beglit is better in pretty much every regard, bar the size.