General Japanese Naval Forces Discussion HQ

This was the video in question. I’m not sure if it was filmed before or after the patch that fixed the 155mm ammo being fatal (which weirdly enough, they’re fixing again this update?). Regardless, you can see at the timestamp 5:55 that they only hit on and right under the barbette of turret no.2. You can also see the single fire pillar that’s characteristic of a shell room explosion. And you can see at the very end of the video that Yamato died to some mysterious “explosion” even with 0 shells in the main guns. But those should hopefully be fixed by the next update.

I have a replay of me detonating a Yamato using Mutsu with what seemed to be a non-pen, but I think it might be a bit late now to report it since we’re so close to the next update. We’ll have to see if that’s still an issue.

As for Soyuz’s SAP… Let’s just say that the Iowa’s 16in HE have a charge mass ratio of 8% and Soyuz’s SAPCBC is 7.9%. A 0.1% difference. Now of course the SAPCBC shell is heavier, and has a cap and base fuse (though the shell is also very long and gets very thin walls), but you’re telling me that that’s enough to give it 87% the performance of a true APCBC shell?

2 Likes

I’m not telling you that, unless you meant that as a rhetorical question. My whole point is that with all this tnt (equivalent) filler which is much higher than on all other ships and the propellant needed for all those shells (considering the max amount is more or less the same on the ships i checked in game: Bismarck, Yamato and Soyuz, all have ±600 main gun shells per turret/magazine in the front) why do most ships instantly blow up when their magazines go poof, but ive never seen a sojuz sink because of that WHILE holding shells with much higher tnt equivalent and in case of bismarck-sojuz comparison ~300 kg heavier shells with about the same muzzle velocity so also much more propellant? Are magazine explosions on russian ships just declared as “they dont happen” and “sojuz is not allowed to sink because of measly mag explosion” or what? If damage of ammo explosions is somewhat linked to explosive mass as they claim how does that make any sense?

2 Likes

Hiei has been given the No.5 APC shell


Low filler but high penetration at short range which drops off quickly