Explanation regarding vehicle textures

First of all, we want to make it clear that the use of generative AI for in-game vehicle textures is not authorized by Gaijin and is prohibited under our contracts with outsourcing partners. During our investigation, we found that one of the outsourcing teams that assists us with vehicle models and textures used GenAI while preparing some materials. This was done without our approval, and unfortunately the issue was not detected by our internal quality control process in time.

We are now reviewing all work delivered by this team and reassessing our future cooperation with them. We are also improving our quality control procedures to reduce the risk of similar cases happening again.

At the same time, the reports we received include several different cases, and they should not all be treated in the same way.

M60

In gallery above you can see different layers with textures. The Gemini logo is only on small auxiliary tiled texture.

In the case of the M60 camouflage, GenAI was used by an outsourcing team to generate a placeholder tiled camouflage texture. Temporary service textures are commonly used at an early stage of production to check how a model looks and works before the final texture is created, but normally procedural tiles or other placeholder materials are used for this purpose. However, in this particular case, the placeholder texture was AI-generated and moved further along the production pipeline unnoticed. This should not have happened, and we will take additional measures to prevent similar issues in the future.

Challenger 2 OES (Senrai Maidens)

“The pre-final reference image (contains an incorrect British flag on the turret’s cheeks that was later corrected before the model was implemented in-game)”

As for the anime-themed Emily tank (Challenger 2), the vehicle design itself was created by artists without the use of generative AI, and there are no Gemini-like logos in the tank’s actual design materials. Some players may see a similarity between the Gemini logo and elements on the black flag mounted at the rear of the turret, but this is simply a design element created by humans. Multiple versions of this flag were explored during development, including variants with several stars and a version with a single star positioned at the end of the white line.

On the other hand, the Gemini watermark that appeared on the vinyl record artwork in materials related to the Emily tank originated during the processing of manually created reference materials by the same outsourcing team. This was not authorized by Gaijin and should not have passed quality control.

We sincerely apologize for the oversights in these cases. We also want to thank the players who noticed these issues and reported them to us. Their attention helped us identify a problem in the production pipeline, and we are taking steps to address it.

Yak-130

In the case of the Yak-130, the element that some players associated with the Gemini logo comes from real-world reference photos. Similar symbols and markings can be seen on many real Yak-130 aircraft (link to photo on Wikipedia), as well as on other Russian military aircraft. This part of the texture was therefore based on actual reference material, not on AI-generated imagery.

Fuel pictogram

30 Likes

Thank you for being open on this. I still think it’s funny how the Fuel stencil looks like the same logo as Gemini uses.

F-40 also looks very similar:

image

13 Likes

So, Gaijin never used AI generated content in this game?

11 Likes

Outsource team did and they are prob in huge trouble. QA team as well.

6 Likes

Whoever you outsourced texture work to scamming gaijin by using AI is one thing. very scummy of them, dont work with them again as they made it clear that they are not worth their salt.

The lack of proper QC for AI slop textures to get through to the public test server, and almost onto the live server, shows once again that there is serious quality control issues in-house too. Take this as a wake-up call to do better across the board.

23 Likes

I mean, look at your pfp, should answer that

20 Likes

real

I was sure I saw it somewhere earlier. It’s visible next to fuel intakes on some in game aircraft (for example Su-30SM).

And what about the several AI generated profile pictures and backgrounds like the current D-Day one?

Gaijin needs to hire more QA guys and pay them more. The fact that this wasn’t detected means they weren’t given enough time to go over it or nobody went over it because someone pushed very hard to get this £60 C+V weeb thunder vehicle into the game.

(And the mods wonder why people say not to buy these premiums.)

20 Likes

Are profile pictures and decals in a seperate case and that’s why gaijin has heavily been using genai for them? And even touched up old real human artworks with ai ?
If its not wanted on vehicles, why is it wanted for profiles and decals?

7 Likes

https://www.artstation.com/artwork/5W0xZ8

Snegoruchka (Snow Maiden) is actually not AI-generated, it was made by an actual artist which I assume also outsourced by Gaijin. It’s actually the current profile picture are more questionable, since last time he uploaded something is around 8 months ago.

6 Likes

The incredibly low-quality Australia Day PFP comes to mind. US style uniform with an AUZ flag sloppily photoshopped on.
image

if the D-Day decal isnt AI (probably is), then it was very lazily sketched. The Union flag is upside down compared to the other flags and the Star Spangled Banner stars shouldn’t be golden in colour
image

8 Likes

why put in public if it’s not ready??
i don’t understand why mr snail add unfinished product in game / public ??
like the Tu-95m still unfinished flight model and buggy / not fixed and still got added -_-?

1 Like

Simple remarks but an easy way to prevent these kind of things would be to credit the artists (as well as their socials) in de devblogs or packs description and reinforce that damn quality control. Transparency would be the best way to get through that.

Well this one comes directly from the players who don’t know about this stuff lol.
Same markings can be seen on many nato aircrafts

Same symbols on a vautour for example

wava-47
wava-78 (1)

4 Likes

It was not yet added to the game (it’s on the dev server).
Still, thanks to the fact, that you have noticed the issue, we will be able to fix it before the tank goes live (that’s the main purpose of dev server - collect and fix bugs before update goes live).

1 Like

the dev server is pretty much an open beta before the update goes live. Things are only half baked on there as gaijin is giving a playable preview while also outsourcing bug hunting to the players that will find issues quicker because of the volume of people.

Its not meant to be complete there

2 Likes

leave that there, everything we need to know

3 Likes

Yep that’s what we often forget about the dev server (since now it got so mediatized). But I agree with the fact that things shouldn’t be added to the dev server if they are not finished. Dev server should only serve to bug reporting on finished things imo, It shouldn’t be filled with reports concerning how half-baked some things are sometimes.

lets also not talk about nearly 7 months later, the F/A-18E/F flight model is still massively overperforming, and the majority of dev server reports for the E are still out-standing

the Normandy decal is actauly correct
image
image

11 Likes