Bomber buff; the direction was right, the execution wasn't, the knock ons have been far reaching

I’ll say up front this is a vent, and I know it’ll draw flak — but a bomber buff was needed. The problem is how it’s been done, because it doesn’t hold up in A, R or S. The buff is simply too strong and needs dialling back, particularly the defensive gunners’ accuracy (and the convoy and shipping AAA while we’re at it).

I get the counter-argument: most losses were mission failures, not shootdowns, so the survivability problem was real. But a 50+% attrition rate, read against the research and analysis done at the time, suggests the current situation is over-egged.

The knock-on effects are what concern me most. Since the buff, pilots around my skill level — below average — have moved almost entirely onto buffed bomber airframes. That’s removed bomber hunting as an option for me, even in dedicated interceptors like the J7W1, AI bombers and a lot of attackers included. It’s also thinned out the fighter population: the ones left are either raw beginners or aces I’ve got no hope against.

So my practical options have narrowed to fast attackers or fighters that can take a base. CAS doesn’t click for me for some reason, and anti-shipping is low reward and high risk. Honestly, this buff has borderline killed my enjoyment of sim.

3 Likes

Imo, any airframe durability should be based entirely upon gameplay. We love to pull up propaganda photos of a B17 with a million holes still flying, or a B17 missing a wing from a flak hit, but at the end of the day, realistic scenarios are impossible to create in this game.

Any plane should be able to destroy the other one in a 1v1 situation. This is the case in fighter vs fighter gameplay, where 1 good burst usually takes out opponents. This is not the case in fighter vs bomber, where the effort the fighter player has to put in to destroy the bomber is vastly greater.

Failure to kill fighters is usually met with “know your plane better” and “get good”. Failure to kill bombers is now met with “Ignore them because your plane literally cannot do it” or “set up a perfect opportunity to get a full perfect accuracy burst in the most vulnerable part of the bomber while they just have to sit there holding the trigger on you”

2 Likes

The defensive gunners. Is either a player or a skill set. It has nothing to do with the bomber buff.

1 Like

B-17. Not B17.
A B-17->


A B17 is
image

A lot of people won’t bother, but that - is the underdog in properly designating an aircraft.

2 Likes

I knew someone would say this the second I posted lol

3 Likes

They do make a big impact.

In Il2:Great Battles, I can spend more time on target because:

  1. A.I gunners aren’t going to be shooting me from 500 meters with any accuracy. Might shoot warning shots but unlikely to hit.
  2. High angular velucity means I’m basically immune (egress is safe)
  3. Players must shoot from first person view that doesn’t automatically adjust for the plane.

And that is before this:

People praise Il2:GB for being more realistic.

Meanwhile Warthunder:

4 Likes

Which still has nothing to do with the bomber’s buff. That’s been a gunner issue since crew skill was added.

Bombers should have no business being this survivable. I’ve seen Ju 288s extinguishing 5 fires (after spending all of my ammo on each one) in a row and still making it back to base, as well as Pe-8s tanking X-4 missiles from the Fw 190 F-8 and 37mm ammo from the Ki-108. Sometimes the only viable option is to ram them.

Considering to buff their damage models was the right choice, but the execution is bad, probably unrealistic.

3 Likes

It makes it worse though, and contributes to why it ruins sim so hard.

1 Like

The buff was good but indeed, the execution was bad only bc War Thunder doesn’t have a damage physics that goes well when you shoot a burst of 20mm/30mm in a wing or tail of a bomber, so what end up happen is what we have now, bombers who only can be shot down if you have enough incendiary bullets or if you shoot to the cockpit, i mean, is this accurate of what could happen in real life? This is a game but now is just ridiculous

1 Like

All they should have done is make it harder for tails to fall off.

I can understand something like this being dumb in terms of bomber damage and a slight buff would’ve made sense (mainly just fixing tails falling apart). What they did now though is inexcusable and really just leads to braindead gameplay. Wing roots are suddenly indestructible? Fires don’t do anything? Bombers tanking direct missile/rocket impacts? It’s already terrible to see in ARB but I can’t imagine facing 3rd person gunnery in Air SB coupled with overbuffed damage models. I put a solid half second burst into a PB4Y yesterday with a 190 D-13 and it was on fire for 5 minutes and he still made it back to base.

2 Likes

bomber need more ammo belts

and they buffed P-61 now :D.

You know, the thing that’s roughly the size of a somewhat fatter P-38? That’s as manoeuvrable as…

A p-47D-25?

Imagine a P-47 with bomber damage models but with a 360 degree turret controlled by mouse aim in third person while you’re stuck using stick and rudder (whether emulated or real) to point your nose from cockpit.

1 Like

Unfortunately this is a common theme with Gaijin over the last year. From Nuclear escalation getting worse from the first week, to the free vehicles they give to stop one death leaving. Every time they have an idea which is actually good, the way they implement it is just horrible.

2 Likes

Even worse, they gave it to the Ju 87s, kingfishers, B7A2, and the helldiver.

Still no buff to the light bomber Birgand B.1 btw.

2 Likes

What! Stukas have the buff now?

Are you joking? I means at least it is an interceptor which can now interceot … But that’s gonna be terrible.

Only on the dev server, but according to the changelog, yes.

1 Like

The buffs to the B7A2 and the Helldiver are absolutely terrible. They can already dominate every other fighter in a match thanks to their air spawns. On top of that, they have decent maneuverability and powerful firepower; they’re even quite fast when diving from altitude.

2 Likes

Yes, it is quite crazy