Why is Nuclear Escalation so unenjoyable?

Youre still trying to rage bait damn bro nothing else to do? All you do is argue against people so not worth the time anymore. i deeply apologise for caring about actual gameplay and not visual as clearly that fixes the constant issues with the game you dont play. I hope you have a good rest of your day as clearly its going very awful for you the last few weeks.

1 Like

get a room you two

says the guy who “doesn’t care” why do you still reply

AAA fundamentally does not offer the dynamic relation between player positioning and outcome that is offered by aircraft. AAA doesn’t move nearly as fast, and they can’t move in 3 dimensions. For skilled players, AAA damage is far less avoidable than damage from enemy fighters and strike aircraft.

With the more limited diversity in AAA positioning over the course of a battle and the more limited ability for a player to a avoid fire from AAA, when PvE difficulty is primarily provided by AAA, a game mode that must maintain a minimum level of difficulty ends up becoming uniformly difficult for careless players and skilled players alike. The focus on AAA in nuclear escalation makes consistent skill expression less relevant to battle outcome. To not affect the availability of progression for shallow players, the game mode is given a level of difficulty for casual players that is comparable to normal Air RB. With AAA not offering as much room for the relevance of consistent skill expression, the level of difficulty ordinarily limited to more careless players in Air RB ends up uniformly affecting players of all skill levels.

With the limited diversity in AAA positioning over the course of a battle, when PvE difficulty is predominantly provided by AAA, a skilled player cannot so much select for more vulnerable enemy targets or position to better take advantage of allied PvE support. The more limited diversity of AAA positions relative to a player means that being careless and choosing position poorly relative to friendly AAA is relatively less punishing.

They need to add AI controlled fodder aircraft in the form of fighters and ground attackers at low altitudes. The lower altitudes will ensure PvE aircraft remain relevant to PvE ground forces. The greater availability of relevant targets at low altitude would help to end the climb to win meta.

When aircraft are at comparable altitudes and energy states, combat outcomes embody a far tighter relation to consistent skill expression than what is embodied by combat against AAA.

In combat against aircraft, higher skill players can position themselves so they can retreat to friendly AI controlled fighters. On attack, they can position to attack enemy aircraft too far away from their allies to receive the same support.

With aircraft having weaponry that is still dependent on distance from the enemy, the greater level of movement and subsequent greater diversity of enemy positions relative to each other over time, aircraft can see greater changes to how vulnerable they are over the course of a battle.

A skilled player can then select targets or position to best take advantage of allies in a field that is far more dynamic. The greater diversity of enemy positions relative to another means that being careless and choosing position poorly relative to other aircraft can be far more punishing than when difficulty was determined by PvE AAA. For skilled players, selection of ideal positioning relative to other aircraft can allow said player to avoid risk in combat that would be lethal for a careless player.

AI controlled enemy aircraft can resemble fodder for skilled players while remaining lethal for careless players.

After adding AI controlled aircraft, the AAA could be toned way down without turning the game mode into a farming simulator. The game mode can provide full rewards without affecting the difficulty of ingame progression for careless players.

With aircraft offering a tighter relation between player skill expression and battle outcome, prior elimination of enemy strike aircraft in a given region would have a greater effect on subsequent attacks by allied ground forces. Prior elimination of enemy fighter aircraft would have a greater effect on subsequent attacks by allied ground attackers. The overall pattern is that the switch to AI controlled aircraft would yield a tighter relation between consistent skill expression and match outcome.

Nuclear Escalation AAA presents as overtuned because they are overtuned. The game mode seems unplayable because battle outcomes have little to do with how a player engages with the enemy.

With less focus on AAA, nuclear escalation can be extended to lower BRs since the difficulty would no longer be reliant on the presence of minimum AAA potency.

1 Like

That entire diatribe about AAA incredible and all but I’m struggling to see the skill expression when I get one good run with the J-10C, flatten some ItOs with ARMs, bomb a few tanks

and by the time I rearm all my teams S-300s are dead and there’s a horde of F-15EX’s in space

With there being PvE air targets to hunt and defend at lower altitudes, the greater availability of relevant targets will make climbing into space much more costly given the greater opportunity cost in fewer destroyed enemy aircraft and fewer destroyed enemy ground forces. Combat at lower altitudes will be more interesting by comparison.

Lower altitudes allow for quicker return to the airfield and less time between a rearm and further destruction of the enemy. In all that time spent climbing, the enemy can gain the upper hand.

If crew spotting of low altitude targets was made dramatically more difficult, that would also help to kill the climb to win meta. Spotting at lower altitudes would become more dependent on radar effectiveness and spotting by team PvE units.

Gaijin already showed that they can link radar capability to crew spotting. They did this with early warning radar in the recent update. They can do the same with aircraft radar as well.

The eventual inclusion of stealth and ECM will serve the same purpose, shortening aircraft engagement distance and reducing the relevance of altitude advantage.

All of this makes it more likely that flying at higher altitudes will cause the enemy to either avoid you or dogpile you, neutralizing the relevance of altitude advantages. This kills the climb to win meta.

Lower altitudes will offer shorter detection distances, allowing a more skilled player to better avoid enemy combat or to target isolated enemies.

Intercepting aircraft will have to give up their energy advantage to have a better chance of interception before being dogpiled or avoided. With an updated spotting system, the shift away from AAA can make strike aircraft playable.

Higher altitudes will become more suited to aircraft with better radar performance, so they can potentially detect the enemy first at higher altitudes where superior early positioning will matter more to to avoid getting dogpiled and successful intercept the enemy. Earlier radars and radar range finders can become relevant outside of simulator battles.

Higher altitudes become more suited to aircraft that can better get away with early detection. Aircraft with greater deterrence in the form of turrets and durability can better get away with the early detection fundaments to flying at higher altitudes.

With higher altitudes having greater downtime in the case of needing resupply, aircraft with a greater ammo supply can better get away with flying at higher altitude. Heavy fighters can better get away with flying at higher altitudes.

With more targets at lower altitudes and with less detection, flying at low altitude becomes the dominant strategy unless the aircraft more specifically caters to playing at higher altitude. With an updated spotting system, the shift away from AAA can kill the climb to win meta.

Heavy fighters and bombers can fly at higher altitudes with less risk of anyone bothering to intercept them. Gaijin can include AI controlled bombers and heavy fighters at higher altitudes without the risk of reintroducing the climb to win meta.

With plenty to do at higher altitudes with the shift away from AAA, the updated spotting system can make heavier aircraft and interceptors can become playable without reintroducing the climb to win meta.

The dominant pattern is that with an updated spotting system, the shift away from AAA can kill the climb to win meta while making the game playable for every type of aircraft.

With lower altitudes offering more to do, and with there being more room for player skill expression to decide an outcome, aircraft will avoid higher altitudes unless their aircraft is particularly suited to it or unless their aircraft cannot remain relevant at lower altitudes.

holy post well done and thought out we do need a possible way to allow safe climbing even jets like f15EX cant climb all the way to safety so ECM is a easy but a bit complex fix but works great AWACS might help but map is extremely small for them we could try decoy drones also but even militarys irl are still testing that so its a complex situation but can be fixed

1 Like

F-35 can be great the greatest really better than F-15EX even

F-35 might be decent it can VTOL mid flight stop for attacks rearm super great but f35A will likely be the best F-35

F-22 is out of question when it comes to ground attack

su57 close to f35A equal

J-20 bad but j20S good

so the future for this game could work if we get 5th gen and ECM all in one package I expect all that since its the big fish update there is not bigger fish this year than December update so it should have many balance and meta shifting content

also going deeper into support aircraft and drones would be helpful also KC-135 tankers if Gaijin can

since we cant do proper modern SEAD with ECM its kinda cooked

so really ECM is the big fish but biggest fish doesn’t mean uneatable or unchallenged 5th gen might be the better fish

To add something in by December, adding the F-35 will be significantly easier than adding ECM.

They already have stealth for the F-117.

In comparison to stealth, ECM will add far more inconsistency to radar detection. To make the impact on radar feel less like a bug in the game, it will be important to link Crew Spotting to radar. They already linked early warning radar to crew spotting in nuclear escalation. They can continue this system by linking radar detection to crew spotting and team spotting.

That way, when an aircraft has a change in their radar signature from the presence of ECM or when their radar profile changes from bomb bay doors opening, the player won’t have to care about any kind of explanation.

The potency of crew spotting will have to be curtailed to create a more meaningful relation between radar signature, ECM, and crew spotting.

The still remaining role of non radar spotting lends itself to more limited spotting at lower altitudes owed to aircraft having limited visibility beneath them and ground vehicles having limited visibility on targets beneath the horizon.

All of this continues the pattern of significantly curtailed crew spotting at lower altitudes and greater availability of spotting at higher altitudes. With crew visual spotting being massively reduced in prominence, the greater availability of higher altitude spotting can be extended by ground based early warning radar and the radar on team aircraft. ECM at higher BRs will ensure the relation between spotting and altitude remains consistent even as radar becomes more effective.

These kinds of broad changes will need to be iterated on over a longer period of time.

Submarine detection can work on a similar spotting system where sonar links to crew spotting. Submarines won’t be entirely ready by the time of December, so the timing fits.

Gaijin can iterate on the spotting changes into 2027. In March, they can release ECM aircraft, update old aircraft to include ECM, and fully implement submarines.

With the spotting changes, they can test nuclear escalation in April and May with an updated version that includes PvE aircraft at higher and lower altitudes without the excessive spotting at lower altitudes. This can happen while they reduce the potency of AAA.

The PvE aircraft will allow for matches with fewer players. There will be less of a disadvantage from joining late. They can introduce reduced team sizes and reduced penalties for leaving a match in progress. The matchmaker can more aggressively queue people to join matches in progress.

They can then introduce the F-22 in the June major update as they fully implement the new PvE aircraft version of nuclear escalation.

Later major updates can extend nuclear escalation into to lower BRs. Since nothing would have to dramatically change, they would no longer need as big of a content drop to avoid community backlash.

The new version of nuclear escalation and the updated spotting system provides a foundation for including versions for vehicle types other than aircraft.

The pattern can be extended into a naval exclusive version of nuclear escalation with PvE combat vessels, PvE aircraft, and PvE transports that unload ground forces at objectives. Costal guns would be replaced by AI controlled vessels. No close air support.

The same pattern can be extended into a ground forces exclusive version of nuclear escalation with PvE infantry transports that unload at objectives, PvE combat vehicles, and PvE aircraft. No close air support.

With nuclear escalation, the game can retain relevance when they have fewer remaining vehicles they can add to the game. The spotting system for ECM provides the foundation for keeping the game relevant beyond 2027.

1 Like

I love that they have been repeatedly asked to remove the crazy aim bot on SACLOS spaa and nothing is really being done for it it’s the same reason nobody really plays/played the helicopter specific mode

3 Likes

idk I’d play nuclear option before I ever try to play Nuclear escalation again and that game isnt exactly winning awards for looks.