BTW…i would AGREE with a change that made the gun more effective…or at least more reliable…the vehicle is playable but surely not dominant…
If it is a realistic change so much the better…
(I didn’t see the reply above…not sure what was the intent)
I can’t help but think if it recieved overpressure like normal HE it would be perfectly fine, or just absolutely nuke everything (228mm HE pen would be hilarious). But you consistently see a HE round with 7ish KG of TNT consistently 1 shotting things, why shouldnt a round with 21.7kg onetap?
Most glass canons are not consistent…that is part of my point…FV4005 is not worse than almost all russian TDs (as an example) that have slow reloads and inconsistent shells…
Every week i get a shot with a great gun absorbed by an optics module or hit a unarmored vehicle for minimal effect…not limited to Fv4005…
Most russian TDs have effective armour (at least frontally), and won’t die to a .50 cal round if you somehow only manage to track or barrel the enemy…
They have other issues…and in the end this is a matter of defining the correct BR for the gun and specific issues of each vehicle…
The issue of inconsistent gun is more GENERAL IMHO…it happens in all vehicles in the game and it is more annoying in glass canons as they are very vulnerable to return fire…
Not specially worse in FV4005
AGAIN…if HESH should be stronger…i admit i don’t know…but bear in mind that if made (much) stronger it may actually INCREASE the BR(s)…beware what you wish for…
EDIT:
I would be fine with a FV4005 with a stronger gun at same BR…“gut feeling” i dont’t see an issue…but you have to “sell” this to devs…not me :)
So here is the truth, you don’t know….
If you don’t know something kindly refrain from commenting.
There are many out there I name @Caernarvon02 who has done much research into the HESH round.
its not even that bad bro chill goofy British mains, I bring my centurion mk.5 avrd or whatever to top tier and its soooo good it gets me 100000 nukes.
^ how “op” gaijin thinks uk tanks are
3 Likes
The topic is NOT about HESH…that would be here (for instance):
My comments are that Fv4005 is playable as many other glass canons and that i can have an opinion on.
Also suggested that making a point may be better with less hyperbole. Bear in mind THERE ARE lots of posts on this topic that seem to me to be accurate…
It is not a playable tank. It is used more as a meme tank than as a tank of any significant value in a battle…
It is armed with a naval artillery cannon that fired a round that was designed to take out fortifications.
The 76mm HESH on the scorpion light tank was enough to throw foot long scabs off a several inch thick plate. These scabs would have been moving through the tank at near Mach 1.
I think this topic is any HESH, FV4005 only really has one option for its tank killing (the whole goal of the game)
something like FV4005 would be about 7.3 with an accurate shell true, don’t think the AVRE will go up much if at all considering the range on the demolition charge. Id be fine with this as it would be facing (and able to easily kill) its intended targets.
war thunder is consistently inconsistent even with the most reliable ordinance, HESH is by far the least reliable In game to the point of it being next to useless.
I have my 4005 and AVRE relegated to getting a hitmaker on spawncampers that are inside our spawn duties only nowadays
2 Likes
You say you are not an expert, but call people trolls. I find this extremely unserious.
3 Likes
I only wish the AVRE has range finder so I can do indirect fire to troll the enemies lol this thing is not something easy to master, hitting targets above 600m requires you to have zero margin for error, just 50m off in the sight setting you can completely miss the target.
2 Likes
Thats why I only ever use it in urban maps where I’m essentially at ramming range no matter
This post was flagged by the community and is temporarily hidden.
This post was flagged by the community and is temporarily hidden.
This post was flagged by the community and is temporarily hidden.
What? its renowned across almost everywhere in WT that the FV4005 is a meme tank due to how unreliable HESH is, no ones asking for it to be turned into a super weapon at all.
You are being extremely childish with your interactions
1 Like
I find great success with it.
I agree it could be improved , however I wont complain about it’s characteristics.
It’s no MBT and do not expect such.
I expect a fkin massive tank destroyer that is easy to kill with a large silhouette and a long reload time with bad mobility… That is what I get.
In return I 1 shot the vast majority of whatever I fire my gun at - should I get into position.
Hesh leaves A LOT to be desired, agreed, but complaining about other characteristics is just silly imo.
1 Like
If your KD is negative with it then you are not having great success.
Theres a difference between you find it fun to it being good.
So ill respond here in relation as well to what you said above…
no one said they want anything else changed BAR making hesh more effective, the tank is a huge 183mm cannon mounted in a fking shed, on a cent hull.
There is nothing in the world that would make it faster, and as you accurately say its a box, nothing will change that.
And no one is asking for that, they’re saying with how laughably bad hesh is especially on the 183mm gun, that it needs lowered in BR or for the hesh to be remodelled.
Personally i dont use it as ive never found the hesh reliable for a 30 second reload.
However i have used it and the hesh is ridiculously incosistent
Can slam a btr80 with it and turn the crew yellow.
Then whiff a shot and demolish an IS4 , it needs some form of consistency brought to it.
Thats all
2 Likes