Why do my suggestions keep on being deleted/declined

Title.

Made one for Jaguar and it wasn’t accepted even through i spend like an Hour on it just looking at others suggestions who got accepted to get an idea, writing it all down giving all the details and sources and wasn’t accepted but just recently another one for Jaguar was accepted, why was mine declined?

Yunpao also declined.

Now the one i made for PLZ-05 declined as well after a week and not even being told why, i wrote all down from general info/overview, history, in-game use, its technical stats (like mobility, engine, armaments etc), put several pictures in with imgur and gave available sources for all and still declined and orientated myself at other accepted suggestions and as said the suggestion someone else made for the Jaguar was accepted but mine not i made two-three months earlier

Staff want you to message them privately to discuss reasoning behind staff actions.

If there was a second suggestion then it may be because they do not want duplicates.

1 Like

They decided to flag a post I made on how a time based br system might look like After they locked it. They’re pieces of work if anything

Best bet is to ask a suggestion mod in a DM

https://forum.warthunder.com/u?group=Suggestion%20Mod.&order=topic_count

1 Like

I made one several months earlier and when it was declined even made a post on it in general discussions - it is good that someones else suggestion of it got accepted but i don’t know why my stuff keeps on being declined without being told why, having it pending for days to a week just to have it declined when one spend quite a lot of free time doing those

overall rly having a feel it is absolutely pointless to suggest, critize or whatever anything here - nothings ever done anyway, everythind declined or no response, maybe can talk with some people about it who might agree or disagree, maybe get a fruitful conversation or not - but at the end nothings ever coming out of it

They don’t tell you unless you ask. You also aren’t given a notification that it’s denied. It’s a very poor system.

Staff want you to message them privately to discuss reasoning behind staff actions.

Maybe they can just explain their actions instead of making people jump through hoops to get the information they should have been given in the first place.

1 Like

Suggestion moderators, as i have said before, want people to actually take care in the Suggestions they make, hence why you need to message them.

1 Like

So being one of the >1% of the Playerbase who uses the Forum and like 1% of those who spend over half an Hour to an Hour on writing a detailed suggestions with pictures+sources etc. for a Vehicle isn’t caring about the suggestions one makes?

You know, the suggestion moderators dont get paid for what they’re doing. You are not helping anything at all, message a suggestion mod and wait for them to respond, as i dont have the time to argue with a child.

yep they delete duplicates

tf wrong with you

1 Like

Makes sense if they delete duplicates - however none of the three i talked about were duplicates.

I got a suggestion for logs passed …

They can also just explain why something is being declined, the same issue is with bug reports, spend hours writing a report on a bug.

Not a bug.

Closed.

It’s insane to treat people like that when they go out of their way for you.

2 Likes

I do not disagree.

1 Like

The problem is… there are limitations on this forum… if you PM Suggestion Moderators they can explain and reason why something was rejected…

The other problem is, that Staff are VERY busy… so, it does take valuable time away from working on and investigating other suggestions… when they have to PM each and every single of the upto thousands of suggestions…

So, it is always best for Members to PM Staff and they can explain

2 Likes