Testing Nuclear Escalation in Simulator Battles!

Get. Rid. Of. “Useful. Actions.”
I swear to God I’m losing my mind.

2 Likes

Played the Nuke-Thunder SIM mode. I loved it!!! there is one issue however that needs to be addressed:

Players using planes that technically belong to the apposing team are exploiting the mode pretending to be on the ‘other’ team. For example the Mig-21 or Su-22 GER plane flying on the blue side. They either get Tk’d or fool enemy players into thinking they are friendly when they are not. I chased a known ger Su-22 only to lose sight and acquire a friendly Su-22 and promptly shot my teammate down.

This imo flys in the face of the SIM mode in general, and is much more acute in flight than in ground battles. Please look into this issue and hopefully find a solution - maybe have players using planes from the other side to actually spawn on the other side, yet continue to get SL and RP for their respective trees.

thanks for making the MODE i Love it… will be running it in VR from now on.

4 Likes

Strange. I have thousands of hours in high tier sim and never found this to be an issue.

The vulcan carves its own gun trough, working as intended. You get a free new housing when you return home. /s

1 Like

Depends on the aircraft.

use to be a major issue for the Tonkas for example, but I succesfully managed to bug report it. Before, it would noticably pitch down, like a LOT, if you took your hand of the stick.

The Report

1 Like

just played 2 matches with my buddy

  1. the team balancing is terrible
    in our fist match, we went for italy 11.0, mid game there was only me and him on our team, and enemy team had 15 players or so still in game

  2. the AA balancing is terrible
    m163 could intercept 2 bombs or even a close range kh29L! nice. i think putting terminator behind the gun in every m163 was a good pr move.

  3. economy is bad
    in my first game, i died 7 times, if i didnt had a premium account, i would have went -100k SL for that match. thats because SIM EC economy is based on you getting 600 points or so and staying alive for the next 15 minutes, but this mode was made for RB economy, where getting as much targets as possible was the main goal.

  4. ground spotting
    how come if my ground units are engaging enemy units, the enemy units dont even show up on the minimap?

  5. map rotation
    why is the small map the only option in this test? are we serious?
    every sim main for the past however long time, went around and said “we need bigger maps” and “we need more maps in sim” and you give us this? its like a spit in the face. allow the test to use the other map atleast. i flew 11.0 for the duration of both flights, and i flew the su-22, mig21 and a10 and i could not even begin to imagine to fly something like f-16v in this mode in simulator on this map, there is just not enough information given to the player.

  6. nations
    why does it say in the event tab, thats its china and russia vs everybody else, and yet when i was flying a hungarian su-22 and i saw a enemy hungarian mig23 being shot down? are we just lying now? and do you actually realise how bad it is for iff in sim? so what if i have a aim-9l if i need to get close enough to see the nametag to make sure its not an enemy german su-22m4 and not a ally german su-22m4, atlast in normal sim, you can see the roundel and go “yeah thats german, so its ours” and not shoot it.

here is my opinion on the mode
you cannot just change gamemode from “rb” to “sb” and expect great results, without even trying to rebalance it for sim. But i get it, thats what this test is for, and thats why i decided to share my experience with the mode. so you can take the points into consideration.

6 Likes

First game feedback, I tried to focus on testing the naval aspect of the mode since its the newest strike content and i was on Southeastern City:

  1. You NEED to add a proper keybind to allow a TGP to snap to a radar lock. None of the radars in-game have NCTR for ships, and ship carcasses among other things often pop up on TWS SEA mode, making it extremely difficult to know what you’re locking and shooting at. I had multiple AShM volley hit open water because I had locked a ship I had previously sunk and it showed up on radar again. Some jets like the F-2A ADTW have this function via deactivating a target point while holding a radar lock slaving the TGP to the lock, but an actual keybind for it has to be added, as being unable to ID your target before firing makes using your radar for surface attack extremely difficult for no good reason.

  2. Score rewards for naval kills need to be revamped if the “Useful Action” system is here to stay. I (unlike many) actually like useful action, but it relies on the amount of mission score a player can make in a predetermined amount of time. Ships generally take much more to take out than a ground vehicle, and yet, provide almost no score at all, with a naval kill (not counting the carriers) only giving something in the double digits worth of score. This is going to make players avoid doing anti-shipping work in the long run.

  3. Team number balance needs to be more strictly enforced. This isnt like regular air SB, where the number of ground objectives is relatively limited, and a team with half the players can still somewhat compete. There are active AI units that push the battle forwards on their own, and there are more AI surface targets than any amount of players could kill on their own, so player count imbalances matter a whole lot more. Lock it to a team being unable to have any more than 2 players over the enemy team. If that increases queue time for BLUFOR players, sucks to suck, play another nation. The mode will fail in sim if REDFOR players always have an 8 player deficit, as even less players will want to play REDFOR over time.

Overall was a fun first game in the mode, it definitely needs some work, but I’m very much looking forward to doing some more testing!

4 Likes

Its not, I got to play Tropical Coast, but i joined with 100 tickets left. NE as a whole seems to prioritize Southeastern City though, which I thoroughly dislike. I wonder if its being done because Tropical Coast is a higher server load, being a map thats 4x the size?

…which in itself is something that is completely unrealistic and very annoying.

That whole SAS system in WT is three different systems mixed into one, that have little to nothing to do with each other, and are implemented in a very peculiar, non authentic way:

  • SAS is a system that increases flight stability by correcting unwanted effects affecting flight path. It has nothing to do with trimming and should by default be on, but have the possibility to be overridden in emergencies.

  • Trim is a fundamental part of flight controls, and something that needs to be adjusted constantly: You go faster, you got more lift, your nose goes up, you need to trim nose heavy to fly level,…

  • Altitude hold is a function of the autopilot, and overrides trim, but it’s not even working correctly in WT.

In WT you can either trim, or have a stabilized flight, but not both, which is very bad. Or have the “altitude hold” on, which doesn’t actually hold your altitude.

6 Likes

imagine trying to deal with the M163 in sim lol

War Thunder in a nutshell

1 Like

The M163 in itself is not a too big issue, I find. We know them (or SIDAM, respectively, which I find similar) from Sim EC.

The issue is that the density of targets, assets and air defense is so high on those small battlefields that you can’t really move without getting into range of one every few seconds.

…and their superhuman, Jedi-like accuracy and precision to use their non-stabilized Vulcans even when driving at high speed over bumpy roads, between trees and buildings…

1 Like

as a sim player this is an easy skip…sim gameplay is heavily reliant on you not dying and when southeastern city is that small spaa everywhere its just an sl trap…no hud symbology for harms in cockpit mode…no way to know if they are locked on until you point your nose fully esp for russian anti radiation weapons…my advice is don’t play it…till they remove useless action feature for this mode lower the amount of spaa…in sim altitude matters alot and when you cant gain even 30m of the ground from your airfield and an s300 has already shot at you…naaaah easy skip

1 Like

No!!!

Play it! Report and discuss the findings!

This is a test after all, which aims at not only finding and solving issues, but mainly also to see if the development of a Sim Nuclear Escalation is even worth the effort.

If people don’t play a TEST mode because it’s not finished yet, the whole exercise is not only futile, but may well result in the whole experiment be cancelled with the argument that too few people were interested in it…

2 Likes

Ight, so second round of feedback after having played a bit.

  1. ESM doesnt work properly in sim. The ESM appears to favour a single target in its search scope at a time, and no amount of selecting other targets to lock will make it change its mind. This, along with the fact there is no proper lock display for ARM’s in the HUD/HMD means you effectively need to just point in one direction and hope your missile locked the right thing (this is the case for Eastern jets atleast, I didnt check western ones)
    ESM wont stop locking the Tor despite me trying to lock the Roland:


    Yes, i know I had short range returns turned off on ESM, no turning it on didnt make a difference

  2. Stop cramming us into Southeastern City. 90% of my attempts to join a game have been tossed into SE City. Its already a bad NE map for RB, its atrocious for simulator, for multiple reasons:

  • Map is way too small when players already have reduced situational awareness due to the mode
  • Naval targets give functionally zero rewards (you get 10 score for killing a Lutjens, you’d need to kill 60 in 15 minutes to reach the 80% rewards threshold at 600 score. There arent 60 Lutjens on the map, nor could you ever kill 60 in 15mins in match conditions)
  1. The strike potential imbalance feels like an even bigger issue in NESB.

  2. I cannot stress enough how much we need a dedicated keybind to snap TGP to radar lock as I mentioned earlier. Between the lack of rewards and the difficulty of even striking a valid naval target, there is no reason to do naval strike, and in fact, you are incentivized not to do it.

That being said, NESB on Tropical Coast was incredibly fun for the single game I got to play on it. I had some massive issues with ARM’s and trying to do SEAD due to the issues with ESM, along with the fact that playing as REDFOR, i do not have access to any of the blatantly overpowered munitions BLUFOR gets (Spice 250/GBU-53/AGM-88G), but that hiccup aside, the match seemed to flow well, and didnt feel particularly overwhelming. If you know how to do frontline strike in NERB, you can do frontline strike in NESB the same way.


On the subject of OP munitions in NE, I actually have a suggestion and want other players input on it;

Add an SP cost to overperforming munitions. Things like Spice 250/GBU-53/AGM-88G, along with ramjet AShM’s, and JSOW’s, should all be locked behind SP costs. Something like:

  • 300 sp for GPS SDB’s and JSOW
  • 500 sp for AGM-88G/Kh-31’s/Ramjet AShM’s
  • 600 sp for every 8x Stormbreakers/Spice 250

This should help solve the issue of these munitions without outright removing them from playability or making other inferior ground strike PGM’s completely unusable. By adding an SP cost to them, the amount of players capable of fielding them simultaneously would drop, and the early game wouldn’t be skipped by people starting the match by clearing all long range SPAA and naval target in 10min (in NE as a whole, not specific to NESB).

These specific munitions all have strategic impacts that rival the nukes in the mode, and so they should be priced accordingly imo, but I wonder what others think.

1 Like

Could that be this issue here?
[Dev] ESM bugs in Sim mode // Gaijin.net // Issues

1 Like

its a sim mode gamemode of course no one is interested in it

the most obvious issue first and foremost the the economy in the game mode hell even in normal sim battles is the first deterrent…no one will play a gamemode you are stuck in the cockpit have a million rwr pings several launches airfields super close…and the map size of a map like southeastern city being that small…
ISSUES IN THIS GAMEMODE

  1. No hud or mfd symbology to pin point spaa postions or HARM locks
  2. Biggest issues by far is the economy (a very big issue in the normal sim battles as well)
  3. Small maps like south eastern city
  4. Alot of SPAA

this is actually how it was like irl on non-specialised sead aircraft like F-4G

Seems to be the case, too bad it hasnt been fixed yet. Not sure how they managed to have it work in one mode but not the other…

I know a bunch that are interested in it, and just cant play atm because its the middle of the week, and even then i havent seen full matches like this in sim in a long time (tho that might be because ppl dont get to create a bunch of small matches)

I actually like UA… I think its a much better system than regular battles personally, It does have its issues though, namely with any objectives (like ships) that dont give much rewards. I know thats an unpopular opinion though, but UA allows you to pretty reliably get pretty large rewards as long as you dont die constantly.