Testing Nuclear Escalation in Simulator Battles!

Sadly not unique.

For ages we had imaging seekers and TGP pods in Sim point somewhere completely random instead of straight ahead per default, which was fixed, then occurred again, then finally fixed again after a long time. Or for a while target POI marking and map moving didn’t work in sim.

Some issues are also VR specific (which I guess is a tad more common in Sim, like the very new action point mechanic not having full control in VR, not possible to click and move action points etc.,…

And of course the whole plethora of issues limited to sim because of systems not implemented (correctly) in the 3D-cockpit, which are implemented in AB and RB via GUI overlays (like CCRP symbolism missing in many aircraft like Phantoms, Thunderchief, Skyhawks,…).

1 Like

I think a lot of players dont realize that VR players get shafted a lot more than any advantage they get in WT. Between the massive amount of VR specific bugs to just very poor game design decisions (such as monitor players getting a pseudo HMD with radar and RWR overlay at all times, but VR players having to turn those overlays off since they are static objects that impede vision), VR is something you do entirely for fun, and absolutely not for meta imo.

That being said, I have my fun in VR regardless :p

Can’t say I like or dislike it. Am at a comfortable place anyway in the game regarding SL, and not grinding towards anything, having reached all I want and got funds to spare, so I can’t claim I speak for everybody, being in a very privileged position myself…

But I can understand that this frustrates people, that to end up with a negative balance at the end of each game, or barely making positive.

Premium time and premium vehicles help a lot there of course, but understandably not everyone can or wants to invest like this.

Example from myself from my short trial in NESB yesterday, Premium account with premium Hawk 209, 4 sorties, 3 deaths, 3 air kills, 2 vehicle kills: 60k SL net gain. So with no premium time and vehicle I’d have made a loss - but then I’m a bloody beginner in NE, so not effective at all yet…

1 Like

Hmmm, not quite sure I can agree to that.

Yes, there are VR specific issues in air, but they are few and not game breaking, just a tad annoying, easily outweighed by the advantages in situational awareness and of course immersion, which at least for me is a key aspect.

It looks very different in tanks, where the way they implemented aiming/alignment really makes VR unplayable still.

1 Like

The way I see it, UA incentivizes survival, which imo is a good thing. It feels pretty stupid when someone dives you in a situation/location where you should be safe, and places themselves in a certain death scenario, and the punishment is a little bit of SL, especially in a mode like NE where for example, if they dive your runway as you spawn in and kill you on the ground, you’re now crewlocked in that sector before your wheels ever left the tarmac.

Airfield crew locks in NE were added to punish players for just diving into certain death over and over and trying to overrun a sector through sheer volume of players, and now that cant be done because if you die within ~10min of your first takeoff from that AF, you have to wait out the crew lock or go somewhere else. UA on the other hand means that suicide rushing an AF to drop a nuke might net you some match advantage, but its otherwise largely pointless in terms of RP/SL, so less people will want to just dive an AF with a nuke and come out of it as a net positive both for their team and their grind despite dying.

Between both AF crewlocks and UA, a thoughtless death means you cant act in that sector for a bit, and you dont get much rewards regardless of your actions either, so unless you accomplished nuking an AF, you are setting both your team and yourself behind.

Made the mistake of playing GFSB in VR a single time lol, never again

Did it a few time, it’s amazing fun, but the alignment of the view with the hull is atm still too gamebraking.

1 Like

These are just my thoughts or maybe opinions…

Problem one is that the AI in AIr Sim are already terminators as it is, and we have doubled if not tripled the amount of terminators on the map. The biggest problem here being that the pilot has no idea where they are and by the time you locate one it is already shooting at you with precision accuracy(I had this same problem in the Sead Event last week using the helicopter). How to fix it, I can not say as I am not a developer and we have taken “User controlled ground assets” and put AI behind the wheel which lacks the human failure rate that gives you a fighting chance.

Problem two is that we lack a Missile Approach Warning System(MAWS) or at least one that is appropriate to the game we are playing. Surely we can all agree that War Thunder tries to land in the middle of Arcade/Realism and though this is not Ace Combat it is also not DCS. With that being said, I feel that we should allow the devs some grace to create something on our hud that tells us it is an incoming IR/SARH missile with a rectangle showing the direction to notch. I personally feel like this is something that would help a lot in every mode and assist new people as they climb through the ranks. It should not need explaining that Air/Ground Sim is not Realistic Battles where there is 3rd person view, colorful icons, dimonds for the missiles, a clear vision of the smoke trails coming at us, and a instructor to keep you in level flight while you stare at a map, infact we most of the time can not even see behind us. So anything added that gives us more intel is a good thing(in my opinion).

I assume the economy is currently based on useful actions due to this being a test and not having to recreate the wheel, which is okay…for now. However, should this become permanent that really needs to be reviewed. Without Premium time I would have been in the poor house after two matches.

2 Likes

@OrsonES / gaijin

I would like to request an extension of the test until after the weekend.

Many players will not be able to take advantage of the current test period, since it took place during the week.

This will help strengthen the test and give new players more time to get to know this mode, since they will have more time available during the day.

2 Likes

There is usually some mach tuck on all fast aircraft but FBW aircraft are completely wild in pitch if SAS is turned off as it makes the FBW operate in Direct Law (if we use Airbus terminology) and does nothing to stabilize pitch. And as they have the center of gravity behind the center of lift they behave like they behave. But still I always fly them without SAS and it doesn’t prevent multipathing IMO.

I’m actually getting more RP with the useful actions system, as the rewards in the regular RB NE were already low

Idk about rp since I researched all I need and just need sl to buy vehicles/gamba/respawn in ne. But sl wise I gain like half of what I could get in rb ne (150k vs 300k in around 45 min). And with booster I can pump that number even further (to 900k+ with 250% in 30 min) because rb ne has no cap for 15 min interval and doesnt require you to wait till you get that capped reward from interval.
Tested with av8b na.

1 Like

Imagine helicopters in SB NE… hell yeah that would be fun!

2 Likes

saying before getting touched by an ITO or 2S6 (not to mention S-300)

1 Like

What is even going on with NE servers today, constant lag spikes making me crash into the ground that you cant even take off sometimes as the plane does a backflip or nose dive on take off

Not disagreeing, never had much of an issue maintaining low alt in SB, if anything its easier because you arent dealing with the paralax of the camera angle you have in RB. but maintaining a consistant low level in some aircraft is defiently more of a chore than it is in others.

Played a few more games today, got lucky with a nearly start to finish game on Tropical Coast, the gamemode is incredibly fun in simulator, though I am somewhat struggling with converting my NERB knowhow to NESB, but that’ll come with time, which is unfortunately something we do not have with this short of a testing window. I’d love to have the test extended over the weekend for everyone to be able to get a better feel for the game mode.

Everyone I’ve seen chatting about it in match have said roughly the same thing “NESB is very hard, but extremely fun, and they really hope it becomes a permanent gamemode”.

2 Likes

Managed a second match yesterday, after my very first one a day before, and had good fun!

Was trying out anti ship warfare with the Buccaneer S.2B and had good success with the Sea Eagles, killing 5 ships and damaging a carrier before switching to another match to test something else.

Rewards were there but very low for killing the ships - but we know from Sim EC that this economy model does not reward killing ships nearly enough, and economy is one of the most complained about issues of NESB.

Tried then to get into a 8.7-9.7 match with Germany, wanted to see how the Hunter fares against the overtiered SPAAG’s and SAM’s there, but gave up queueing after a bit over 15 minutes.

Havent tried any matches above 11.0, as I don’t fancy the MCM warfare that high tier WT is, in any mode.

All in all I have formed a positive opinion on the game mode, but with the few often repeated points economy, density/battlefield size, overpowered AA.

What I think should also be adressed are the BR brackets: they make no sense and are very restrictive and unfair for a very big portion of the available aircraft. I see no fun in taking an F-5E with two rear-aspect Sidewinders against a Harrier II with AMRAAM’s…

So sumit all up, as I said in the sister-thread in the Sim section:

The mode per se works, but has the same issues as the RB version, with the added issue of very punishing economy.

But it’s definitivey fun, shows a lot of potential and would be a significant enrichment for Sim in WT, if it becomes a permanent thing.

Or - but that will be a longer essay - the whole thing could be just a testing ground for a mix of the current Sim EC with the addition of NE elements:

  • add more diverse targets of NE, but not as densely populated
  • add NE’s AA, but a) not as dense and overpowered, and b) matching the BR bracket’s tech.

Yes, I heard this too, but I also noticed quite a few players who seem to have been new to sim, judging from the aspects they were discussing.

So, if done right, this NESB could even motivate more people to join the Sim community…

1 Like

My finding is that there is no reason to play it. Like only new thing which it brings compared to original sim is suffering due to excesive AA. Point of NE should be bringing sim mechanics as EC, unlimited spawn and multiple objectives to RB. From my point of view Gaijin failed in this miserably and now that failure want bring to simulator which already have most of this in standard sim except excesive AA which ruin this gamemode. Like what is point of playing it when we have already much better simulator gamemode?

2 Likes

We don’t have that: Sim EC has been lacking development for literally years and is stagnant, and admittedly quite oversimplified.

In my personal view, taking over some aspects of NE to Sim EC would be the optimal way to go, but that will need quite a lot of work for Gaijin. Having NESB as alternative additional sub-gamemode I find a reasonable next step for the development.

It’s far from perfect, but absolutely brings new perspectives and a new wind.

What I fear most is that negative attitude of the sim community of the whole project will bring it down completely, because this would inevitably result in continued stagnation of the Sim game modes as a whole, on the basis of “well, we offered somethin else, you didn’t want it…”

2 Likes