Continuing the discussion from [Air RB] Response to the October 2024 Battle Rating Changes:
hi SO I want the battle rating of the AMX to be lowered to 10.0 and the battle rating of the AMX-A1 to br 10.3 or 10.7, because in the future the plane will be almost useless and in this br it will save the plane a lot and thus Italy will be more sought after when purchasing the AMX-A1.
Chill out, those are only planned, obviously Dev’s will take player’s opinion, example what happened with Strela-10M2, it was supposed to be moved to 10.0, but got moved to 10.3.
AMX has 2x Aim-9Ls which puts it on par with most other sub-sonics with 2x Aim-9Ls at 10.7. In fact, considering it has 120 countermeasures, it is actually ahead of several other 10.7 aircraft with 2x Aim-9Ls such as the Sea Harrier FRS1e which only has 60 CMs (and a heat sig that makes flaring anything extremely hard work)
The AMX is at the correct BR and 10.0 is just insane. There is no justification to be that BR.
AMX A-1A does have slightly better AAMs to Aim-9Ls and does maintain this 120 CM count. The tricky question is whether these 2 upgrades are enough to push the AMX A-1A up to 11.0 from 10.7. But in any respect. It should be no lower than 10.7 but definetly should go down to 11.0 at a minimum.
The Idea of making it 10.3 so that its Pay-to-Win is just a bad argument.
Posts like this also wont impact the actual thread, so you will need to actually post in said thread. I already have a suggestion for AMX A-1A to go down to 11.0:
My BR suggestion for AMX-a1a:
Arcade 11.0
Realistic 11.0, for ground 10.7
Simulator 10.7
I think this would be fair.
It doesn’t always happen, in fact I’d say it’s rare that moderators take into account what players say… and for some time now the community has been pointing out to them that the Re. 2000 of the Italians should have the same BR as the Swedish Re.2000 (J20)… but the Swedish J20 stands at BR 2.0 while the Italian Re.2000 is overBR at 2.3… and this simply doesn’t make sense… It is the same plane, but 2 different BRs depending on which nation plays it.
J-20 doesn’t get HEF/i/API belts.
Far worse armament.