WG 3 to me, count as one because they’re just that bad. They use HP bars for the entire vehicle, and it’s unrealistic, no matter if the individual vehicle components here have HP, they’re not displayed and they’re not in the same realm as the click shooters that WG produce.
Click shooters that don’t even account for how tough a vehicle is supposed to be.
Tanks and warships aren’t supposed to go down in one shot, aircraft are far more fragile but some - like the A-10 and some old prop planes such as the Boeing B-17 and B-29, the A-1 Skyraider and etcetera, can take a beating and still remain in the air, completely controllable.
Hell, the B-17 was well-known for its’ abilities to take damage and keep flying, Holes in its’ wings, tail ripped to shreds, even losing half its’ vertical stabilizer! It still kept going!
In Vietnam and Korea, the Skyraider was able to take flak hits, missile impacts and still keep going.
In the modern era, the A-10 has even survived direct impacts from man-portable air defense systems (MANPADS) and SAMs and made it back to base alive! An F-15 Eagle once made it back to base with an entire wing gone!
And these are not isolated incidents either.
WG respects that planes, tanks and warships are tougher than they look, and not super-fragile.
Meanwhile in this game, you take a few bullets, or a single main gun shell and your wings fall off or your ammo rack explodes. Those are some highly unrealistic damage models, pal!
Sure the HP bar is unrealistic in WG’s games and in AW, but all vehicular click shooters are just as if not more unrealistic for how utterly fragile all the vehicles are!
You’re a glass cannon in WT, no matter what vehicle you’re playing. In WG’s games, a tank is actually tanky, any warship can take a few hits, and a plane can withstand more than just a couple of shots.
Add into this the fact that there is no spawncamping in WG’s games and the closest thing you can get to unsportsmanlike conduct is a few cases of foul-mouthed chat creatures, and the evidence is clear:
WG’s games AND AW are directly and infinitely superior.