You should not be able to see other peoples “skill”. The amount of times people send me my statshark as a response to my rarely happening good opinion is nuts.
3 Likes
Stat shark just makes it easier the same can be done by looking at your statistics in warthunder itself, so statshark didnt really change anything
17 Likes
way easier to type in the name in google than to boot up the game
1 Like
sounds like skill issue if you get called out that much
25 Likes
yeah i suck ass. But i dont think my opinion of the is2 1944 being way too high in battle rating shouldn’t be invalidated by the fact that am ass at the game
Think of the warthunder forum like a preschool, it makes the things people say make more sense
everyone goes after the low hanging fruit
Half the time im on the forum I have the game open anyway
Actually, yes, it should invalidate it, if you’re bad with the vehicle.
That’s like if I went and said the M1128 WP should be 9.3 but I have less than a 0.5K/D in it.
People are more likely to listen to others with actual high K/Ds when it comes to BRs because you know this person is coming from a viewpoint of being really good
Also, even if Statshark was a misstake, neither you nor Gaijin owns it
13 Likes
I dont even have the is2. I just think its super easy to fight against and it also looks like a doo doo vehicle over all
Then that’s another reason, I mean less so than if you said it should go up, but people usually look for when the person actually has experience with the vehicle they’re talking about.
Just because I think the Tiger Ii P should go down cause it’s really easy to kill, doesn’t mean people will listen
sayin something should go down because its easy to kill is pretty questionable because it might be easy to kill with what youre playing but very hard to kill in another vehicle or techtree
3 Likes
They also act like you must have the vehicle to form opinions on it. Bmp3 should not be 9.0 but I cant speak on it because I don’t have it which is bs.
If you are ass at the game, that means you’re probably struggling with the is2 because of skill issue, and probably not because its overtired.
Also
7 Likes
(Btw I’m not trying to invalidate your points or anything, just explaining these things)
With a lot of vehicles tho, you kinda have to have it to know if it actually deserves the change.
Does the T26E5 really have to go up in BR because it’s strong, or is it just hard to fight against?
1 Like
Because you do? personal example here, I used to think the is3 was OP until I actually played it
I thought it shouldn’t be as well, but then, guess what, I actually played it to find that the ATGM reload was awful, the reverse is mid and the mobility is OK at best, and it has typical russian gun handling. I’d say its pretty balanced at 9.0
2 Likes
Its not an entirely invalid argument because you really should know both sides of the argument. But its also not like your opinion would be entirely discounted in this case, generally the response from people here is to shutdown people who call things OP asap because most people dont care as 95% of things people complain about are indeed skill issues or just not reall issues. The most important thing is to find the people who agree with you and form coherent arguments bringing comparison to other vehicles in the game, not just saying something should go up because it kills you a lot which happens very frequently
Like i said I dont have the is2 plus Literaly every good player I know says its overtiered.
1 Like
The IS-2 '44 also being overtiered won’t help either.
1 Like
Well yeah, its absolute balls to play. But it also can’t go down in BR so there’s not really any solution except decompression
2 Likes
I mean bmp3 does have a really good missile+themals+middle of the road gun (subpar for ifv standard) but its also really mobile and you get to fight paper armored nato tanks not the mention the 8.0 downtiers
It is overtiered. Btw I recommend looking up the player who starts with statshark because chances are they’ll also be pretty bad :p Not a lot of good players in this game
2 Likes