Shouldn't we add the battleship Montana to compete with the battleship Yamato?

Montana-class battleship - Wikipedia

100% real trust

Spoiler

it not its a scale model

And you are yet to answer even one question

trees exist, it still qualifies!

I was thinking of Shinano not Taiho sorry. I got them mixed up

montanna still fails to meet any of the other criteria

Oh then be happy as BB Shinano is already suggested and passed along in the last suggestion report, I linked it a bit above.

Hmmmmm no.

It literally does since theres no single unique part of it that was built, that wasn’t reused on other ships

A-150, H-44, K-1000 and USS Ohio to name a few.

here is the suggestion that is passed of IJN Shinano in her Battleship configuration

1 Like

The Ohio concept is a fabrication by WG, it’s design does not even exist in the form they produced it as, its a weird mishmash of around 3 or so designs and tillman turrets.

The A-150 by comparison is as possible as Montana as there are images of the gun barrels for the A-150 project in a field after the war.

Should add that the barrels were scrapped and used for reconstruction efforts so I guess that makes them not unique as they ended up being used for civil works.

The gun barrels dont actually count as major parts (because they are literally useless on its own) unless the breeches were also made, but it looks like they weren’t, and the ship was never laid down. Suggestions specify that they have to be MAJOR parts.

Oh tnx to both you, and @Lolman345 , I remember Japan had a few planed BBs that where converted to carriers due to pre war treaties, or lack of resources and combat loss during the war, I just got confused as to which ones.

1 Like



Hey guys i found where the “unique” parts of the montana went

1 Like

yep, wait it has the iowa name on the rear? nice

And is that your quantification or the suggestion teams stance on the matter? Such sounds like a fantastic question to ask them since I’m pretty sure you do not know the answer to this.

Iowa and montana were to use the same guns and turrets

its up to interpretation but thats the likely response, if you wanna know the actual answer go ask a suggestion mod.

what doesnt use 5in guns lol

I already know the answer as I have dabbled in the situation myself, I would recommend you go and ask you are inferring the response.

Which one was the proposed variant with 18-inch guns?

These are longer barrelled 5 inch guns