Shenyang J-11, J-16, J-15, History, Performance & Discussion

for you it’s pointless, for me, it isnt

So, I’ll say what I have to say

speculation means making assumptions without concrete data, everything I said is concrete and based on data

Especially since I didn’t commit to the radar’s actual performance, I just said it’s more likely to be wrong than right

3 Likes

Ok show me concrete data on Chinese radars used in the J-15T J-16 J-10C or pretty much any aircraft in use.

everything you claim on these is speculation as there is literally no info available on them

If the radar is chinese, made in china, and they have developed superior aesa radar technology, how can it be said that there is no information about it?

How can one assume that it would be exactly the same as an export radar from the first generation of AESA radars?

3 Likes

Then can you show the “concrete data” showing higher antenna elements density and greater transmission power without resorting to showing some random AESA models put up for advertisement display?

Just because they hold a monopoly on the raw materials and refined materials doesn’t mean they necessarily have the best utilization of said materials.

So do provide some proof they’re somehow better than any other contemporaries

I’ve already listed the names of a few things above, you can also search for them on your own computer, Aerospace Global News, Grey Dynamics, …and many others I mentioned these because they have a decent reputation in the west

I don’t keep every article or document I read in my wallet, because I’m just a guy who enjoys this as a hobby, but I guarantee that if you take an hour to read you’ll easily reach the same conclusion as me

3 Likes

So… Speculation. Without concrete evidence on any of your claims

In fact, it doesnt necessarily mean that, but that is what happened in this case, the west wouldnt be trying to replicate this technology if it werent superior

that is something you are stating to convince yourself

Yap fest

forum activities are supposed to be about discussion

Unfortunately they don’t have decent reputation. I think the one that has the best reputation in the west might just be AviationWeek but that is a paywalled news organization.

Just to give you a heads-up, western organizations are notoriously inaccurate and unreliable when it comes to Chinese or Eastern equipment in general. I would say these organizations are also inaccurate and unreliable when it comes to US/NATO equipment even, making very wrong statements that deviate from primary sources.

For example there’s US third-party organizations that will say AIM-120C-8 has GNSS and is effectively the same as AIM-120D but for export, but the US government themselves said AIM-120C-8 does not have GNSS.

Ok then what do you want, more range more scan speed?

yeah, no matter how unreliable a news site might be, I read them all, not everything you read there is going to be waste of time, and some things actually have real value

that’s why I dont just read about the military sector, I also check technology in general, especially space programs, etc, since those are also good indicators, thats why I said, take an hour to specifically research this, and you’ll at least reach a conclusion similar to mine

I don’t want anything, I’m just saying the radar is fake, but as others have said, there’s no data specifically about the radar, all my statement means is that the day we know something publicly, it will probably be better than what we’re seeing in the game now, that’s all

I also read unreliable/inaccurate news sources too, I think we would be lying if we said we never did. But sometimes it can cause users some cognitive dissonance when the unreliable news sources they’ve read don’t line up with in-game performance of their favorite vehicles which means that those users never made careful to separate speculation from reality.

Problem is ideally I wouldn’t come to a conclusion except maybe to further look into it and see what sources they used, atleast not like how I used to be taking news organization for truth, especially stuff like Jane’s.

The only thing the J-16’s radar needs over the J-10’s radar is higher range. “power” as a variable in radar configs only affects how visible the radar is on RWR afaik and is practically useless. Other than that, the KJ-16 is configured just like every other AESA radar at top tier except for the fact that it has a significantly better ACM/HMD mode than anything else (26 km range)

2 Likes

Its sukhoi grampa

1 Like

But Chinese radars don’t have that full horizontal scan mode like the Rafale or Typhoon have (not the extra gimbal angle, I mean).Though that scan mode isn’t really used all that often anyway.

A shame we dont even have that to any noticable extent.
At the same time as some other 14.7 got its engines, radar and centerline weapons based entirely on
“Might”
“Could have”
“Potentially”
and “Possibly in the future” as if its nothing.

2 Likes