Shenyang J-11, J-16, J-15, History, Performance & Discussion

Are you sure? As far as I know, they are respectively produced by Komsomolsk on Amur Aviation Plant named after Yuri Gagarin and Irkutsk Aviation Plant

knappo also makes su-30mk and mk2

They are not the same company, and they have independently modified the design based on SU27

wasn’t MIG swallowed up by Sukhoi?

I checked and even after being annexed, the MiG Design Bureau still has its own aircraft manufacturing plant

Pretty sure they came under one leadership. But yeah different respective plants and plans etc.

I don’t recommend viewing a large state-owned enterprise like AVIC through the lens of a typical company, especially considering that the 611 Institute (aka CAC) was originally established in Sichuan as a result of the 601 Institute (aka SAC) relocating its operations there in preparation for a potential nuclear war.

3 Likes

Poorly worded on my part sorry,
I dont necessarily see them as separate companies but just different branches under the same governance

I mean CAC and SAC share the majority of their core technologies. Their avionics, fire control systems, and other critical subsystems are supplied by the same third-party research institutes and feature identical bus configurations. Consequently, their aircraft maintain full weapon compatibility, with the exception of specific, deliberately omitted capabilities like the CAS functionality on the J-11B.

5 Likes

That is to say, their relationship is not further apart from the relationship between Komsomolsk on Amur Aviation Plant and Irkutsk Aviation Plant. It is unreasonable for you to say that the equipment universality of SU-27SM/30/35 is better than J-10/20/11/15/16

pft15 for pl15 and pl12ae(j10ce)

2 Likes

KNAAPO (single P, double A). It produces Non-canard versions of Su-30 (MKK, MK2, M2), Su-35S and its export version, and did upgrade program for Su-27 (both SM and SM3). IAPO (not named like this anymore, but i use it for convenience) in Irkutsk produces canarded versions of Su-30 (MKI, MKA, MKM, SM and SM2). And then there is NAPO in Novosibirsk that produces Su-34 and its derivatives.

Nowadays better abbreviations would be KNAAZ, IAZ and NAZ respectively

1 Like

Sorry to burst your bubble but

4 Likes

bah i hate this technical compatibility bs.
What’s next, j-11a using ramjet r-77-pd (ramjet r-77) because it’s technically compatible?
Technically compatible is a dumb slippery slope

7 Likes

I’m not a fan either, I’m the one he’s responding to there.

1 Like

There is no bubble to burst? I know how the system works i just expressed that I dont agree with it.

is that a pl12 or pl15 ?

1 Like

It’s an Adder most likely, given that’s an MKK. Front-end matches up well enough.

MKK can carry PL-12… And iirc PL-12 and R-77 have very simillar front part.

1 Like

I know that yeah, it’s just I’ve never personally seen any pictures of an MKK with them, just Adders. And PL12 has some raised bits we would see from this angle, so my bet is currently on that and not the Adze.

Not saying there aren’t any pictures of an MKK with Adze I’ve just never seen them myself haha, I know the folks who got them on the plane in game found some documentation for it iirc, if there are pics I’d love to see them!