Mode: Ground Realistic Battles
Aircraft: Ariete
Change: 9.3 → 9.0
Reasoning: The Ariete is an exceptionally manoeuvrable and capable dogfighter. However, this strength is already reflected in its 9.3 Air RB battle rating. This proposal is not asking for any reduction in Air RB, but for its extremely limited usefulness in Ground RB to be properly recognised.
In Ground RB, the Ariete is exclusively a CAP aircraft. It has no bombs, rockets, air-to-ground weapons or air-to-air missiles. It also has no countermeasures, no RWR and no defensive electronics. Its entire armament consists of two 30 mm cannons with only 240 rounds and a maximum penetration of 39 mm at point-blank range, falling to 24 mm at 500 metres. They are useful against aircraft, exposed SPAAs and light vehicles, but they provide no meaningful CAS capability against normal ground targets.
The obvious response will be that the Ariete is extremely manoeuvrable. That is true, but manoeuvrability is primarily an Air RB advantage, and this is exactly why the Ariete is rated at 9.3 in Air RB. If manoeuvrability alone were sufficient to determine the Ground RB rating, there would be little purpose in having separate Air and Ground battle ratings.
The proposed changes make the inconsistency particularly clear. The MiG-21 SPS-K is rated higher than the Ariete in Air RB at 9.7, yet it is being reduced from 9.3 to 9.0 in Ground RB. In addition to its supersonic performance, it has radar, RWR, an optional countermeasure pod, R-60, R-13M1 and radar-guided R-3R air-to-air missiles, as well as bombs and rockets. The Ariete possesses none of these capabilities.
The Yak-38 is also being reduced from 9.3 to 9.0 in Ground RB despite having R-60 air-to-air missiles, bombs, several types of rockets, the Kh-23M guided air-to-ground missile, RWR and a ballistic computer. Its flight performance is clearly inferior to the Ariete’s, but that difference is already represented by their Air RB performance. In Ground RB, the Yak-38 offers a complete selection of weapons for both CAS and air defence, while the Ariete can only perform CAP with its cannons.
Therefore, the Ariete can reasonably remain at 9.3 in Air RB, where its manoeuvrability makes it a highly capable fighter, while being reduced to 9.0 in Ground RB, where it has no CAS capability, no missiles and no defensive electronics.
Keeping it at 9.3 in Ground RB solely because it is manoeuvrable, while aircraft with higher Air RB ratings and vastly superior weapon systems are moved to 9.0, would be inconsistent with the entire purpose of separate Ground RB battle ratings.