Guys i think we might be spending too much time arguing about fringe opinions on reddit that i don’t think are shared by many people here…?

It’s one of those weird reverse funnels, because YouTube clearly has the biggest level of exposure, but (devs teams aside) least depth of discussion and interaction with the devs, just look at how some videos from, says Tim’s Variety can get ~30k views in a day
Reddit sit in the middle, I know @lolman03 linked a thread about the perception of the implementation of BeNeLux on one of the subreddits that had a poll with 500 votes, looking back it seems it was a post from CaID it appears
And here is the opposite end of the spectrum, aided by the ability to format comments and better include documentation, but in terms of user exposure some topics may only have 200 individuals tops
Also a small added caveat there that many people on Reddit dont play the game anymore and sometimes, haven’t for some time. They stay active on a subreddit for the community aspect or because their opinion may feel shared.
Whereas all 200 of those forum users in your comparison are active current players.
As for why that part got clipped, it doesn’t change the meaning of the previous sentence, imo. What you wrote underneath is essentially a call to arms to go to the forums and complain about how BeNeLux was implemented (with, from what I’ve gathered, the goal being to restrict it to only the most unique or gap-filling vehicles and nothing else). I didn’t think that was particularly relevant to the point being discussed as the reason why.
And if you’re suggesting that we’re victimising ourselves, keep in mind that everything I’ve mentioned comes from actual discussions I’ve had with French mains. I could easily post 20+ examples of French mains victimising themselves in exactly the same way. I’ve even seen French mains victimising themselves over something as minor as not getting a new decal for Bastille Day, claiming it was proof that Gaijin didn’t care about them iirc.
But anyways, I don’t hate French mains. I’m just a little agitated that this discussion has flared up again (especially on Reddit, although that’s pretty much a hive of complaints and anger, and little else), with people essentially advocating that BeNeLux should be limited to an extremely small pool of vehicles because they supposedly don’t deserve the rest or aren’t worthy of them. I’d just like to see us get more than, like, two French air and ground vehicles next year. And now that the French naval tree has finally caught up, I can actually see that happening.
Also worth noting that the “users” figure on a topic is not all people that contribute. For example here’s the figures for my subtree rework suggestion:
Lists 96 users, however far more actually interacted and shared their opinion through likes and votes. Assuming every player that interacted in other ways also voted, this is already 932 players. For other topics, especially those without a centralized poll, this can be much harder to identify.
"28 links" is also funny
Goodmorning Smin, off topic but I’ve just posted a bug report about an esa radar tracking issue that’s been in the game for a few months now, I think it’ll have a pretty low chance of being seen and fixed so I just wanted to ask if you could give it a little nudge to the devs if possible, best regards :) Community Bug Reporting System
At first I thought this was a Dev Blog for the next update and I was confused, hahahah.
Not like we will need to wait long, this period of the year is cramped! But I know it will take at least two weeks since the release of Eagle’s Shadow for that.
Hey Smin, I’ll stop with my little tirade after this post, as I don’t think this discussion i’ve made has been particularly productive.
That said, could you possibly clarify whether the relatively large amount of naval content France has been receiving could be one of the reasons why its ground and air departments have been somewhat lacking in comparison?
A lot of people have been blaming BeNeLux for France’s recent domestic content drought (which probably does play at least some part in it), but I was wondering whether the naval side of things might also be a factor. France has received quite a substantial number of naval vessels compared to other nations over the atleat the last 1.5 years, and now that its naval tree has more or less caught up, I’m curious whether that could potentially free up some room for more domestic french ground and air additions in future updates, as i assume development budget gets allocated per nation, so having more naval vehicles will lower the amount in the other of vehicles in the other two modes.
I think he’s already said that it’s because French naval is the most recent, so it was getting more content to meet the minimum levels the other trees are at
Will try to fish that back up
Here: Next Major Update - "Eagle's Shadow" Rumour Roundup & Discussion (Part 2) - #6239
yeah, which is stupid, because gaijin doesnt look at polls that are not created by them.
We need to have more official polls
Yeah, I know, I was the one who asked XD. But technically, he only explained why France has been receiving more naval vehicles. What I’m specifically wondering is how that larger number of naval additions might have affected the ground and air trees. I’d assume that development resources and content allocation are shared between modes for each nation so perhaps that when prioritising naval additions has meant fewer resources being available for ground and air vehicles, That’s really what I’m trying to get at.
Do they really even look at the ones they make?
I’m not saying everyone needs to make polls, but I just meant that the users figure of a topic doesn’t include everyone that contributes. There is more ways to share your opinion than just writing, you can also support things others write by liking them or vote in polls.
So those “200 users” could very well be much more, like how in the Subtree Rework topic (at least) nearly 10x as many people actually voiced their opinions compared to the 96 that did it in writing specifically.
yeah, as we’ve seen with the APHE reworks and better rewards when losing a game.
A very good point, this is the only space that guarantees relatively active contributors
Though I will say the forum limits have been a bit restrictive from time to time
My GPU died a while back and in the ~3-4 weeks it took to replace it I’m pretty sure I was locked out on here by the end
Thanks for linking the original too, this might be helpful later
thanks for making it, its a wonderful addition to my collection


