New nation - India! (with Pakistan subtree)

Machinery of War Discussion
10

If idea is accepted those vehicles would be added to theoretical tt at the same time as they would be added to the countries that actually made them. Look I just don’t want any more copy paste vehicles. Original Indian designs are fine as they are in the British tt imo. There aren’t too many, and the devs won’t want to bother with another tech tree

9 Likes
11

the copy paste argument is null and void.
simply because you dont like seeing them is no reason for hesitation nor reluctance.
if a separate TT is added with CP vehicles, you have no obligation to play it.
and those who will play it (because they want to) wont complain.
we know the limitations of the TT (at least for the pk and bd one) and we wont be asking for imaginary vehicles to fill our BRs

4 Likes
12

also…
the modifications made to each so called CP vehicle make them distinctly different in terms of in game implementable capability.
the pakistani F-7’s are waay more powerful than the in game ones as are the mirages with the ROSE program modifications

3 Likes
13

It would be fine as a Chinese subtree as you said most of their vehicles are Chinese. Maybe pakistan f16c as a USA event vehicle in the future?

14

too many distinct vehicles to do so, and the US doesnt need another F-16

15

There’s a lot of problems with this idea. The first is that India and Pakistan are enemies and have been in on and off conflict since their founding. Adding India to Pakistan would be equivalent to adding Iran to Israel.

Second, this tree will have nearly nothing unique to it. The ground tree would consist of a Vickers Mk. VI, M3, M4, Centurion, T-54, T-55, AMX 13, PT-76, BMP-2, BMD-2, T-72, T-90, Arjun, and Tank EX. Congratulations, you’ve just made the Israeli tree again but with a few extra Soviet vehicles and even less of a top tier, especially because India can’t get the Vijayanta or T-90S Bhishma because those already exist in the British tree.

When it comes to their air force, they have practically nothing of subtsance below rank 5 aside from a few miscellaneous light attackers and some bits and pieces of the British air force.

This means that the air force barely exists, the ground tree also barely exists and the lineups are all but nonexistent, CAS does’t exist in any meaningful capacity until rank 5, and the ground tree has no room for expansion into top tier after the Tank EX which is a tech demonstrator.

11 Likes
16

It wouldnt really bring anything vs American f16c as is would just be cool vehicle with cool skin.

17

We will probably get mirages in French tt with equivalent capabilities in upcoming updates. Also the f-7 since it’s so great would be a good top tier vehicle for China, no? Or as a Chinese event vehicle.

18

agreed lol

not so much agreed but not compltely disagreed either.
besides, this is an easy way for gaijin to attract more players into the game

wait for it

like the merkavas in the american TT they will be transferred over in case of this TT being implemented

well there are enough, obscure that they are.

can be adjusted with modifications based on years

also for ground top tier, we dont really need to always have updates and new vehicles, getting up to modern times will grant us enough

1 Like
19

There’s no reason to add another tech tree. All vehicles listed will most likely be added to the countries that their design was from, or in places like the British tt. Not enough original designs to warrant this.

2 Likes
20

the mirage ROSE is a pakistan specific program which AFAIK france had no dealing with hence would be strange to have those in france.
as for the F-7’s those were also specifically made for the nations they were exported to (adjusted for the nations requirements so china can only have the original prototype or the base export version).

21

idk maybe…
attract a handful of players from the market of over 1.5 billion?

2 Likes
22

So like Chinese tree but even worse

1 Like
23

You gotta do some catching up. They have a bit of history lol

3 Likes
24

lmao if anything

DO IT FOR THE MEMES!!!

5 Likes
25

not exactly, itll be more versatile

26

Taiwan and China already in game.

27

They could just add the Indian vehicles to Britain lol. Like they have been doing since Indian tanks added. Only original designs at top tier or high tier where it can be premium.

29

Yeah I never liked that. Should not have American aircraft in their enemies tech tree

1 Like
30

thats… not exactly comparable, china and taiwan are one people… india and pakistan are not

2 Likes