Low Tier HEAT discussion - is this fair?

when u have 0 arguments against someone the only way to seem important and superior is to ask insulting questions, ur not impressing me, try harder and quit assuming trash about something that I never even spoke about buddy

@Topfbonsai cite where i said that “historical matchmaking needs to be a thing”

Every time you say cold war shouldnt face ww2?

1 Like

This implies that you don’t like playing with ww2 tanks against Cold War Tanks. Before you get the idea that separating those would be a good idea, I told you that this is a, proven, bad idea

yk this “historical mm” argument doesnt even make any sense right? Tiger 2 was being used in 1943, therefore it should only face shermans, where did i even say anything about any other vehicle but M50 and M56??

ok, prove why its bad (even tho i never even said anything R E M O T E L Y to what ur implying)

I quoted you bruv. There are a lot of threads here on the forums, you can look it up if you’re interested in that topic!

M50 did see combat with the USMC and this sounds like a matter of who sees who first if your long 88 fuses both the M50 and m56 are toast also how much ammo are you carrying

1 Like

no, explain urself

20 ammo

u all are trying to make it look like the poor tiger is at fault for being frontal plated by a cold war vehicle that is criminally undertiered for no relevant reason other than cut all of the fun from playing something that is supposed to have armor

also this isnt 2018, actually heat will instantly implode ur ammo even if it misses it

„ Putting matchmaking by historical intro dates wouldn’t “fix” anything. Warthunder is already severely altered from historical matchups by the rulesets and situations of the matches themselves for one thing. For another the actual war was not balanced.

Save “historical” balance for events, unless you want to give my P51 a mission starting at 30k feet, with the Me-262s on the runway being fueled, so I can shoot them before they take off.“

„Historical MM would never work. War is a game of one-upping the enemies’ vehicles. One country would be the most powerful country at one BR range and no one likes to always die or lose. Stop with the historical MM. Balance is needed for MMO games. The BR system needs work, yes. But it works for balance.“

„ Historical MM wouldn’t work, nor would it be fun. War isnt balanced, but a video game should be.“

Those are some quotes I quickly gathered by simply googling. If you are still interested you’ll find a lot of videos on YouTube discussing that topic. Can be very interesting, if you’re interested!

Didn’t need to read further :p

4 Likes

Yeah therefore is fair for my Tiger 2 to face, T10s…IS4Ms…HEAT-FS… yeah totally makes sense

But what if you would stop all 7.7 from being uptiered? Just put a line between them and call it a day.

No it wouldn’t be busted, the 7.7 tanks can and probably would play more at 7.3 and 7.7 rather than every match being a full donwtier and even if it is a full downtier, it would make more sense than having 7.7 vehicles fight with literally cold war ones, this is just an example that came to my mind right now, but it would be way better than whats happening right now and you can choose any BR for that matter, not necessarily 7.7., but I thought about Maus’ situation and thats that ig, but probably a better stop gap would be ~7.0

If you want to debate with me about this PM me, cuz I wont make a topic about M50/M56 into a discussion about MM

Worth for the funi though. Especially the video showing the M56 sneaking around xD

im not biased like how the other people came in and proceeded to insult me just because APDS “should be removed” - while nobody even said anything about APDS

yh dude its totally my fault because a cold war vehicle that happens to be very fast and also have inf penetration, killed me

Again, if he used his APHE round, which is 100% conventional and in line with other APHE from WW2 you would have been blown up in shot 1, not shot 2 lol. (btw M56 enjoyers out there, the APHE is baller, always worth carrying)

3 Likes

irrelevant, if that vehicle was anything but a M50 it wouldnt have stood a chance, but I should have noticed 2 pixels going 50km/h behind houses while the entire enemy team was hunting me… (including planes)