Sure, if they improve all tanks ingame ability to climb inclines to a realistic and historical standard. Just use more slippery slopes for out of bounds areas and it should be fine really.
1 Like
I don’t think it’s that the map is “bad”, not bad at all really. The thing is, when it was made, and several other older maps like Ash River and so on, “top tier” was about half what it is now in BR. Those maps were not made for higher BR’d, longer range vehicles at all. But Gaijin, using it’s “one size fits all” thing stuck BRs on there that in now way should have ever seen those maps. Later on they even made bigger maps and stuck BR ranges far too low on those as well.
Map sizes, spawn and cap point locations should vary a lot more than they do, this has always been a problem with map design and BR placement on some maps.
I mainly play Air AB and even there the problem is pretty evident. Nothing quite as much of a buzzkill and spawning on a map with your 4.7 prop line up only to realize . . .“this map is a jet map” . . . or trying to get ground kills in your 3.3 BR IL-2 on Rocky Canyon. . . . yeah . . . nah.
They get some of that sorted here and there, but it is still a persistent problem in almost every mode I play at times.
I don’t think there are many “bad” maps, but BR placement and the static locations of spawns & caps . . . just doesn’t work in many places
Something I personally would love to see being addressed at some point . . … Soon™
But we all like different things . … . this is the way
Afaik its out of rotation for now, few days (weeks?) back people noticed that there werent any matches played on this map since feb/march.
And i do not miss it one bit. Also no one said aral sea cant go to hell too.
Red desert is fine for BRs where most tanks have mobility.
will not be missed. By anyone.
I remember playing this map when I first started, lower BR’s it was utter chaos and fun
+1 we need
1 Like
I miss that map. People overstate how much mud there was, it was a minor annoyance.
3 Likes
For high tier I love red desert, rare map that validates flanking and sniping ranges
at lower BR it was REALLY funny
2 Likes
white rock was around long before they oiled every map
2 Likes
Aha. Okay, so yeah… naw. It was a wretched map at any level in the past, and would only be even more so today (because everything gets worse in general the higher you go).
Preach it, sister!
Can you define higher mobility?
Map played terribly BEFORE the great traction nerf few years back due to everpresent deep mud, and it only got worse after the act.
If you mean top tier tanks having better mobility, that was absolute clownshoes on its own.
Aral Sea my beloved.
Imo a perfect example of a map blending 3 different engagement ranges quite well. You can pick what you feel in the mood for.
1 Like
just no lmao. Urban was trash as it wasn’t actually close range ever, the shipwreck side was crossmap sniper BS hell and the ruins side was CAS alley
I am new enough that I have never played on White Rock Fortress, but from what I have seen, it looks like a good map, and I would like to try it out in battle. So yes, please bring it back Snail.
Tes desert is great in high tiers
good at top tier, however its so open its KH38 heaven now
yesss. I have found a perfect sniping spot on Aral Sea which is op
Yea well thats not the map problem its kh38 problem
1 Like