Is Top Tier Sim Finally Dead?

Every thread he is in becomes one

Every discussion he is in becomes one. Dude could be going to his grandma’s funeral and turn the eulogy into a discussion about how her passing is almost as sad as flying the Harrier in War Thunder.

9 Likes

0a4

5 Likes

Then it’s no longer sim… its air realistic…

1 Like

Mr.President…anktber post has hit the sub reddit.

1 Like

No… it’s Air realistic where the match doesn’t end in 10 minutes, it’s not just 32 planes mashing into each other, ground targets and objectives actually matter, nobody gets names over their heads, and you get the depth of a sim battle with Air realistic controls (the controls that turn most people off air sim).

Controls that are probably over-inflated and over-hyped in how difficult they actually are. They take a few hours of conscious practice to learn, yes. And they do take watching a short youtube instructional video for the basic flight principles (slip, skid, coordinated flight, left-turning tendencies) to handle. And there is a lot of depth/skill ceiling, yes. However after achieving baseline competence they’re… not that hard. People like to over-inflate their challenge/difficulty the same way people love to over-inflate the difficulty of DCS or Il2:GB (we had a guy saying taking off a 109 in Il2:GB is incredibly difficult and high effort when… all it takes is being gentle on the throttle…)

If someone is able to say, pick up a random metroidvania and learn its controls they can learn sim controls too.

The default controls warthunder gives you do suck terribly however and create a false first impression. Additionally, SAS being off by default for modern jets also creates a false impression of how hard just flying is. The mousejoy default is also atrocious and creates seriously false expectations.

There’s youtube tutorials for that though to minimize barrier to enter.

Yes. I love the air sim controls. I wouldn’t change them for air sim. There was, however, an earlier post I was replying to that said they wanted ARB controls in Air Sim. My suggestion is just to make ARB more interesting and use similar game rules to Air Sim (except for the controls) on a shorter timer. That way you can get the air sim depth without the controls.

I enjoy both third-person flying and first person air sim. I would continue to play both. I don’t like ARB game design though. ARB at 8.0+ is basically arcade as far as I’m concerned. Objectives matter only one in every 50 matches. Otherwise they’re just there for farming.

You are not asking for sim. You are asking for RB EC.

You mean actually flying the plane? You don’t fly the plane in arcade/realistic. You do in sim. This is also the main differentiating feature from RB to sim.

Where do I play this RB EC? We don’t have it in game today that I know of.

For some of us, the main differentiator is being able to play more stealthy and have objectives actually determine the outcome of a match. Controls might matter to some, but not to others. I don’t play Air Sim because of the controls.

They’ve trialed it in the past but never want to add it

might as well play top tier arb instead.

more fun and because the matches are shorter there’s less of a chance of the game crashing within a match

plus q times for arb are only like 5 secs - 2 min while for sim you can either play denmark or wait 20 minutes for a good map to never pop

I guess

You must have been unlucky, all the games were full, right? There are lobbies too, I think.

This is probably from when the bracket reset around half an hour ago. When the bracket changes it will only show games of current bracket and it takes some time for people to create games.

2 Likes

A few other people in the thread touched on the economy. I’ll chime in and say that the implementation of the so called “Useful Actions” rollout really gutted the economy and my desire to play air-SB ever since. I’m sure some of the other issues mentioned in this thread have had an effect, but for my part, the economy is the biggest for me.

Personally, I think the game really needs some serious rebalancing for jets from 11.7 and above. I think that reconsidering and moving some planes up and down would do wonders for the game. About op tier specifically, my problem with it and the reason I dont play it much, is that it quickly gets too confusing and chaotic. Maps are too small, and player count too high. Spawn kill is also a big issue. The lack of a proper tutorial/single player mission on how to evade fox 3 is also a big issue.

Gotta love players complaining about iron dome meta at top tier yet participate in said iron dome meta anyways
Screenshot 2026-02-22 155729
image
image
if you want change you can’t just add to the problem imo

Many such cases.

Iron dome is bad when it shoots down my missiles. It’s good when I shoot down your missiles.

4 Likes