High Tier - Top Tier SPAA Mega List

Machinery of War Discussion
,
111

Update #21

Part 1 Additions

  • M458 Eagle (US)

Part 2 Additions

  • RBS 70 VLM (Sweden)
  • ATILGAN PMSS (Turkey)
  • Vuran SUNGUR (Turkey)
  • Arlan 4x4 PMI (Kazakhstan)
  • MT-LB IMLS (Kazakhstan)
2 Likes
112

the ranges are switched around and calibres for both are 165mm

2 Likes
113

Thank you and corrected.

1 Like
114

Update #22

Part 1 Additions

  • T249 Vigilante (US)
  • General Electric’s DIVAD Proposal (US)
  • Sperry’s DIVAD Proposal (US)
  • Piranha Blazer (UK)
  • FMC M2 Bradley ICV (UK)

Part 2 Additions

  • VBR MPCV (France)
  • MOWAG Trinity (Switzerland)
  • MOWAG Crotale (Switzerland)
  • Nile-23 (Egypt)
2 Likes
115

Update #23

  • Updated formatting to show sub-categories in nation headers
  • Compacted Misc nations to spoiler drop down
  • Added some additional links for some vehicles

Part 1 Additions

  • RDF-LT 4 (US)

Part 2 Additions

  • LSPZRA Stalagmit (Poland)
  • VFlab Lpz 51 (Switzerland)
3 Likes
116

I have been linked?

117

Do you have relevant links for information about SPAAs that I haven’t seen?

118

You linked his response in Cactus SAHV instead of the suggestion itself.

119

oops. Didn’t even notice.

120

Update #24

Part 1 Additions

  • Vulcan Excalibur (US)
  • Defender 2 HMMWV (US)
  • IRIS-T SLS Mk.3 (Germany)
  • Sky Dragon 12 (China)

Part 2 Additions

  • AMX 10 RAA (France)
  • Berliet GBD Roland 2C (France)
  • M987 FVS Crotale NG (France)
  • PZA Loara (Poland)
3 Likes
121

INPjV2q

Bit more info on it.

7 Likes
122

Also, this could be added for USA as well:

D-kJugOWkAE9rA2
D-kJugOWkAE9rA21256×2048 376 KB

D-kJz5bW4AA7aZK
D-kJz5bW4AA7aZK1388×1308 390 KB

D-kMIqjW4AAePP_
D-kMIqjW4AAePP_2688×1565 365 KB

D-kMRTKXkAIc4Jy
D-kMRTKXkAIc4Jy1110×978 234 KB

edit: the 11rpm claim in the first image is 100% a typo

3 Likes
123

Update #25

Part 1 Additions

  • M6A3 Bradley M-SHORAD (US)
  • Mobile C-RAM Centurion (US)
  • XM701 GLAADS (US)
  • Rapira-3 (Russia)
  • FLAADS-L (UK)
2 Likes
124

Update #26

Part 2 Additions

TRIDON Mk.1 (Sweden)
ItPsv SU-57-2M - Ps 462 (Sweden - Finland)
PZA SA-35 (Poland)

3 Likes
125

K-31 Cheonma uses missiles that domestic developed by LIG Nexone, not VT1. If you look at pictures or videos of the Crotale and Cheonma missiles, it is easy to see that they have different shapes.

Crotale

K-31 Cheonma



Specifications from academic paper

Specifications from official Youtube channel of ROK Ministry of National Defense




3 Likes
126

Do you know from when the academic paper is? Im asking, because SAHV is listed as 128kg with 6km ceiling and 1998 introduction date. That data is weird.

127

The Chinese Crotale systems have very different missiles though, definitely not VT-1s though I agree.

128

Update #27

Part 2 Additions

I-Dome SAM (Israel)
M-1985 (North Korea)
Added K-31 Cheonma Missile to K-31 (South Korea)

1 Like
129

The specs for the other two non-Cheonma systems are not reliable; we only need to look at the column for Cheonma in this table.

If I remember correctly, this paper was probably around 1997-1998 (yes, that is really old paper), and since this is an academic paper and not an internal military report for a serious performance review, so the paper’s authors relied heavily on what was readily available: Janes.

130

Ok, thanks.
Well, even if the Janes were used, then the only thing that would make sense is 6km ceiling.