Hey, so now that you are more comfortable sharing some vehicles between tree's, like the skink

Yah think we could maybe get the A33/1 Excelsior as a Techtree version of the Excelsior?

It had slightly Different armor, better and worse in places than the Excelsior we have in game, and a VERY late mark of 57mm 6 pounder in place of the 75mm on the other prototype, WHICH was capable of firing the APDS rounds developed for the 6 pounder mid way through the war.

It was the Excelsior specifically sent over seas by the British for American testing as well. Meaning it could be in both the American, and British tree.

Id say 5.0-5.3 would be a fair BR. a Kinda speedier Jumbo, with worse armor, and possibly the first vehicle to get the 57mm APDS.

4 Likes

The A33/1 Also is odd because instead of the christie type suspension used on the prototype that stayed home in Britian, it was fitted with American Sherman style VSS suspension. So it has a GOOD bit of uniqueness compared to current rare event vehicle.

5.0 while the premium excelsior is 4.0? It has worse armor and APDS while good is only 57 mm and wont have good post pen damage. That would be 4.0

It would probably be an american or british premium event vehcile, or a battle pass vehicle.

i feel like the Excelsior in game is under tiered, and i say that AS a British main.

The 6 pounder even without the APDS, has MORE penetration, and a faster reload than the 75mm. And if it goes to the Americans and the Brits, it can be given the American 57mm APHE. Which its self is MEAN as hell. See the chaos a Boarhound can cause.

The APDS would just be for killing harder targets, as it SHOULD be able to punch through a Panthers UFP pretty easily. i mean the most famous use of the 6 pounder APDS is it being used to frontally KO a Jagdpanther when even a 17pounder couldn’t punch a hole with its APCBC.

the skink should never have gone to America.

2 Likes

but why? it was a Canadian Development, for the US army, on a Sherman Hull, using American Made 20mm guns.

blatantly incorrect

Designed for the canadian army, on a grizzly hull, using POLISH DESIGNED BRITISH BUILT polsten 20mm guns, the same guns that appear on many other British AA vehicles and was planned to be the machine gun on centurion.

It was used by the 21st army group which was britsh and British Canadian troops, zero relation to the US beyond the American produced parts for the skink hull, everything else was Canadian.

Canada isn’t the united states nor are they joint owned by Britain and the US so copying it over to the americans was stupid

2 Likes

Canada isn’t British either. And the 21st army group had American forces as well.

you do realize the grizzly hull is just a M4A1 licensed copy with minor modifications

2 Likes

its engine is american made too

odd looking flag there. That flag totally doesn’t mean that the people under it were British citizens or anything, or that Canada and the UK share a monarch still
image

by war thunders standards that makes it more unique than most addtions

1 Like

kinda would be cool to add the grizzly to britain or america it be another good medium option

still very american would be better if it had colts instead of what ever those are belt fed is so much better

yea nah im not claiming the shot gimel or soviet matilda for Britain because its mostly British built stuff (actually far more of it than there’s American parts on skink)

a licenced production vehicle to another country doesn’t mean it should just be thrown into the American tree either, Canada is British at the time and still very not a 51st state.

it was planned to have hispano 20mms but because of the need to put hispanos into fighters they went for the polsten as it was the next best available thing

3 Likes

i agree but america had hand in making it so id say its not most out of box thing like russia asking for T26-e5

1 Like

such a claim is not the way to go mate. trust me that would get very messy and not in favour of the US at all.

no its more like Britain demanding a CV90 or bradley because BAE systems, a British company makes them.

or something more stupid germans demanding the British version of the Eurofighter for PIRATE.

1 Like

id love a replacement to be added it be nice skink is kinda bad

i must admit if any british vehicle was to be stolen and put into the US tree it would be skink because its really really crap, the polstens magazine size and velocity just is not good enough for 5.3, if it was 4.7 it would have been ok, but British tax means it must be overtiered into irrelevancy

Americans were British citizens…

Doesn’t matter. The monarchy has been defunct in both nations for a long time, even more so in Canada. Canada has its own constitution.

Also, fun fact, this is the state flag of Hawaii:
image

until 1716 yes. All members of the British Empire was considered British citizens, people in British overseas territories still are to this day.

not true

a written constitution =/= republic, just because the UK has no written constitution doesn’t mean that’s the rule to what is a kingdom.
literally the first thing after the preliminary of the constitution act is that the constitution is a declaration under the crown.
image
the crown is also in the same position as it is in the UK, the head of parliament.
image

The union flag was chosen by the natives of Hawaii to honour the British, the only time the union flag appearing doesn’t mean its a colony/dominion/dependancy

2 Likes