Just had a battle on flanders where 1 crotale and 1 iris t managed to shoot down every single spike nlos salvo (even dud spam). So only kill I got in 10 mins was this kamov.
Not even pantsir or fk2000, just crotale and iris managed to deal with “no counterplay” atgms.
And then I spawned aim9x aa, sent aim9x salvos at both heli and shot down nuke f16 that wasnt even on my radar. I wonder how much counterplay he had considering he didnt even know aim9x was somehow coming.
Spike nlos are just dogshit, probably one of worst atgms I ever used.
13 second rearm. What the hell are you even talking about. You want to waste enemy SPAA missiles? dump a lot of the MITL missiles and guide last.
comparable to infinite rearm, definitely.
On my Mi28NM i can bring 8 LMURs. If i want an SPAA dead or waste its missiles i just chuck 6 and guide last one with 2 in reserve. Also im spawning on closest Helipad so that the time to intercept is as low as possible.
And this is going off of the assumption that theres just a single helicopter doing this which, idk if youve played 13.7-14.0 but on average during a match theres anywhere between 3-6 helis up.
This is such a dumb thing to say. No shit sherlock, its not meant to be a 100% counter, but right now SPAA has 0 ability to counter a dude thats hovering 11 meters above the helipad. It simply just turns into a war of attrition and even thats assuming its one of the 3 SPAAs that can reliably intercept your missiles everytime. (S1. SMSV, FK2K)
This makes 0 sense. Can an SPAA clear out the battlefield the same way an SM2 can clear it out with Kh38s? Or F15EX with 53s? No.
SPAAs especially multi-vehicle ones are only purpose made to target planes and helicopters. Guess what they cant do against someone hiding behind a hill.
Limited amount extremely dependent on system and ofc the nation using it.
They really are not lmao. Radar, LWS, RWR, MAWs and the ability to freely move around the map not bound to a small box. What are you even trying to peddle here lmao.
literally luck based. Ive occasionally survived stuff i shouldnt have in SLM or pantsir, or type 03 or NASAMS same way ive taken SLMs to the face in apache or NM and was able to land and repair.
No it isnt with MITL.
It really isnt tho, like the only map that comes into mind where that would be true is 38th parallel which is not available atm or Pradesh which still offers perfect cover from SPAAs to lock nearby mountain in order to chuck a MITL missile at anything that annoys you without an issue.
And wouldnt you look at it, apart from Z10ME you didnt. Majestic.
I mean, if youre in non-direct line of sight, you are BY DEFINITION immune to ground based vehicles. Because even stuff with GNSS like for example SLM, requires a LOS in order to be able to fire the missiles. So idk what youre talking about here. Genuinely the only semi-viable strategy a ground based vehicle can do is be a light tank and try to hit the heli with recon drone to make it crash. Hit or miss strategy and if they are low to the ground over the helipad it might just end up getting repaired.
Given that this is a thread talking about MITL and every MITL helicopter is 13.7, yea who would have guessed that every top tier helicopter has access to LWR, MAWS and RWRs…
I said, finite time in a match. What is so difficult to understand? 13 seconds is the absolute minimum time for rearm once the heli is on the ground. Not at all the practical time between engagement availability.
Also, you know that SPAA players can simply choose to not fire at blindly spammed missiles? They have the exact range info, can sort the radar contacts list by it, and furthermore, all top tier SPAA have NCTR. Use common sense, and don’t apply your logic unequally.
Equivalency: Helicopter dumps a lot of the MITL missiles, guide last → SPAA ignores extra missiles, intercepts last.
Accordingly, 3-6 SPAA systems can exist too, so what’s your point? I should also remind you that the spawn cost of helicopters is ~10x that of SPAA at top tier. You can spawn 2 tanks, die without accomplishing anything at all, and still spawn SPAA. For spawning a helicopter, you’ll need a few kills or other actions. In fact, you will practically never be able to spawn helicopter with a equivalent amount of kills and deaths. You need to be an above-average player to even do so in the first place.
Literally shooting down every missile == 0 ability to counter? What is going on inside your mind?
The rest of your response is a joke with no coherent argument whatsoever, so I won’t even bother responding to it in detail. You’re just saying “nuh uh” and then not even addressing my statement. Funniest thing is you trying to say I haven’t played MITL helis, and then upon the evidence proving you wrong, shifting the goalposts and saying I played only one of them. I don’t know why you would include such pointless things in your response.
ok and? and i said that the rearm is 13 seconds which is an amount of time in 25 minutes that is negligible to be able to restart firing. Do you understand how time works.
Unless the SPAA player has grown a 7th sense and is capable of becoming clairvoyant to which missiles are duds and which ones are live in general he will be intercepting all of them. Also another funny thing, even if he intercepts the last one itll just switch to the missile fired before it so lol, lmao.
So your “Equivalency: Helicopter dumps a lot of the MITL missiles, guide last → SPAA ignores extra missiles, intercepts last.” doesnt even work. I would again suggest using the MITL mechanic first before deciding to talk about it.
So nuance, something you dont understand.
If you have 3-6 SPAA players on your team, that cant even kill a helicopter and are forced to only intercept missiles, therefore fghting a war of attrition against a system with infinite rearms, thats 3-6 players that are not playing MBTs AND even if they would somehow through the power of god and anime managed to kill the helicopters SPAAs cant do much against tanks. (Apart form SMSV).
So thats basically wasted.
Additionally something you seem to not understand at all is that even with 3-6 people interception is not guaranteed and extremely dependent on the SPAAs they play, eventually a missile will get through. SLM for example against LMURs from close helipad has ludicrously shit time intercepting them.
In the video that i literally posted above in my post i played a BMPT, only damaged barrels on leopards until i had enough SP and then just drove forward into them to die and spawn heli. It is not hard to make the SP necessary for a helicopter, even less so when you play a light tank with scouting.
if youre having issues spawning a heli i feel extremely sorry for you.
Is it a counter? The helicopter will just fire as many missiles as it takes for you to run out of ammo and then what lmao. Youre not countering shit, at most youre delaying it. And infinite rearms on a capture point requires your team to hold a point in the first place and makes your SPAA be pretty vulnerable as people will be looking at caps or driving to them lol. As an SPAA you dont just fight against the helis alone, you are also fighting against people in tanks on the ground map.
i was literally quoting you. If quoting what you wrote there and writing a counter argument to it is not addressing statement, then youre as dumb as a rock.
point to where i said MITL, i pointed to the fact that out of the aforementioned “powerful on paper helis” you only have one. Youve played Z10ME, and are shit in it. But hey, dont worry, you seem to be the perfect specimen for whom MITL has been created…
The game is just not designed for this type of weaponry, GRB needs serious changes to its core gameplay to even entertain the possibility of having these weapons in the game.
The most obvious and quickest change is to increase the cost to 1000 SP and to disable ammo replenishment in the forward helipad, this is by far the most broken aspect of MITL, in no way shape or form should a weapon of this type have unlimited replenishment.
They also need to increase the BR to 15.0, it’s just not high enough, I played a few 13.0 games and all of them were full uptiers filled with MITL helicopters.
That mechanic cannot be “rebalanced” would it make it any less effective for example if the sp went up to be on the same level as jets? No, it would still give the heli player an insane advantage unless the heli is exposed enough for anti-air to be able to lock it cus otherwise there’s no counter player so just straight up remove it, it wasn’t needed in the first place and you’ll do just fine without I mean helis are already a pain in the butt with their fire and forget missiles.
I literally saw them firing the missiles while planting their ass on the ground, only jets could get them, or I try to find a teleport cheat to teleport my tank there so I have 20 seconds to kill them.
Top tier is just unplayable because as soon as an MI28 spawns with LMURs, you just die instantly in a tank with 0 warning or counterplay. Then you spawn in IRST. So far, it is miserable trying to hit the LMUR and other MITL rockets with IRST as they all miss once they get near the missle.
The FlakRakRad works but is very limited as reloads take a long time and its easy to get overwhelmed as you can only fire one missle at a time. So in the end, you spawn in SPAA just trying to defend yourself from getting destroyed by an invulnerable helicopter sitting 10m above helipad.
Definitely spawn points for helicopter must increase and there should be no reloads for MITL missles due to their counterplay. FnF was already annoying somewhat, but MITLs not even allowing SPAA to have a chance is just plain out unfun.
Wrong. Firstly, average match time is much shorter. For example, data from Aug 2025 shows an average GRB match time of 10 minutes, and there is good reason to believe that it is even lower currently. Secondly, average helicopter spawn occurs well after the match starts, cutting multiple minutes off that figure. Thirdly, many maps require significant flight time before being able to engage, even for MITL helicopters.
You have also completely ignored all practical limitations, instead nonsensically choosing to imply that a SPAA player will have their stocks depleted in just a few seconds. Nobody who has actually played MITL helicopters, or all CAS for that matter, can agree with you in good faith.
Are you even reading what I wrote? Distance information is available to all top-tier SPAA players, as well as the target course parameter. A skilled player will be able to discern between dangerous and non-dangerous munitions by that alone, not to mention common sense regarding the necessity of LOS for spamming of actually targeted missiles. Regarding your last sentence here, you have again ignored a basic fact, which is that most heli MITL munitions have incredibly narrow FOV, and the datalink switching to a missile further out is often practically useless as a result. Issue of LOS necessity also applies here.
Except your arguments in that section do not directly address anything I said? Anyways, OK, I will counter your arguments from before, if you insist.
My argument is that SP should scale with absolute power. You’re pretending that the nature of SPAA vs CAS makes CAS categorically more powerful; your argument is functionally reliant on that simple logic. Without considering the actual effectiveness of CAS or SPAA, you’re making an argument that doesn’t hold weight for real matches.
Separately: Again, note that you take the most extreme outlier (SM2, 15EX), and imply it is representative of the wider population. You’re not arguing in good faith, instead using insults and unscientific rants in a desperate attempt to “win” the argument.
The same limitations are true for CAS aircraft. This argument is deeply rooted in hypocrisy and selective presentation of information.
That’s exactly what I addressed already, if you cared to read what I said.
Yes, it is luck-based. I never disputed that fact. What I am saying is that your characterization of helicopters as very survivable is wrong. You haven’t addressed that argument, instead choosing to attack a strawman.
This is flat-out wrong, again. I don’t understand why you refuse to understand basic geometry.
This is also completely wrong.
Vast majority of helicopters can’t engage without LOS to target. As a reminder, the post in question said “Everyone already knew helicopters were broken in WT.”, and the post was clearly referring to all helicopters.
Again, you took my post completely out of context, and did not read what I was addressing.
Back to addressing your new response:
The helicopters are, too, players that are not playing MBTs. In fact, before MITL, helicopters had a lower kill rate than MBTs.
Your video only shows you playing helicopter. As such, your statements are completely unevidenced, and will be disregarded unless you post actual evidence for your statement. For all we know, you’re just lying.
Delaying == countering, because match time is finite. In many cases, the SPAA never run out of ammo, and you’ve effectively done nothing at all the entire match.
Your arguments are filled with emotionally loaded language, have obvious bias, consistently show selective presentation of information biased to fit your narrative, and are unscientific in nature. They can only fool people who refuse to look at reality, or simply align with your position due to their personal interests.
Correct, but for all practical purposes, the average is used, so here it is generally not the case. In addition, it should be noted that helicopters with self-guided munitions (such as IR-guided ATGMs) are significantly more expensive to spawn than helicopters in general, costing >700 SP. The multiplier for IR guided weapons was increased a few months ago too.