Ground-Air RB: what if everyone in a ground battle could afford a CAS spawn from the start?

TL;DR: I’d like to hear what people think about this idea: Ground-Air RB, a new ground mode where every player starts with enough SP for one guided-weapon CAS spawn, you can respawn while you have SP, and SP prices do all the balancing. Basically Squadron Battles style air/ground play, but in random battles. Tell me what’s wrong with it.

Would you play Ground-Air RB?
  • Yes, I’d queue for it regularly
  • Maybe, I’d try it
  • No, I prefer Ground RB as it is
0 voters

The problem as I see it

Every CAS nerf follows the same loop: CAS gets more expensive, fewer planes spawn, SPAA has nothing to do, nobody brings SPAA, the few planes that do get up go unopposed, and the forum asks for another nerf. What changes is who gets to fly, not how much CAS there is.

Right now the SP cost of aircraft works more like a gate than a balance tool:

  • Getting into the air depends on how well you do on the ground, not how good you are in the air. A good pilot stuck in a mediocre tank may never see their plane, while the player in the current meta MBT is flying by minute four. The vehicle that’s already winning gets CAS as a bonus.
  • Capping and farming assists is the fastest way into a plane. The players actually trading kills are the furthest from their aircraft.
  • SPAA is a wasted spawn in most matches. If a match only sees one or two aircraft, bringing a Gepard is a bad trade.
  • Air mains mostly skip Ground. Lots of trees have great strike aircraft sitting behind ground vehicles that most players can’t reliably go 3–5 kills in.
  • A team being spawn camped has no way out. Air is the tool that should break a camp, and it’s mostly the camping team that has it.

War Thunder is the only game that puts planes, helicopters, tanks and SPAA on one battlefield, and outside Squadron Battles there isn’t really a mode where all of them matter at once.


The idea

Ground-Air RB is a new mode next to Ground RB, which stays exactly as it is.

1. Everyone starts with the same budget. It’s enough for one guided-weapon CAS spawn, the most expensive standard air spawn at that BR. Every spawn, including your first, is paid from it.

  • Open in CAS: you’ve spent most of your budget on one sortie, so it had better count.
  • Open on the ground: you have plenty of respawns.

2. Respawns work like Nuclear Thunder or Air Simulator Battles. You can respawn a vehicle again as long as you have the SP, using a respawn system the game already has, like the one in Nuclear Thunder or Air Sim. Otherwise a player with only one or two tanks would sit on a big budget they can’t spend.

3. Prices do the balancing, with no aircraft caps. Ground vehicles keep roughly their current costs (SPAA ~90, light ~100, medium ~120, heavy ~130). Air costs get tuned for this mode from real pick rates and win rates. If half the lobby opens with CAS, it’s too cheap. If nobody touches it, it’s too expensive. And since the starting budget is tied to the CAS price, making CAS more expensive automatically gives everyone more ground respawns to counter it with.

Two extras I think would help (open to opinions):

4. See your teammates’ picks on the spawn screen. Just a tank / SPAA / fighter / CAS / heli icon next to each name. If four people are going air, someone grabs SPAA.

5. Kill SP scales with what you destroyed. For example, a share of the target’s spawn cost instead of a flat amount. An SPAA that shoots down a guided CAS gets paid enough for several respawns, killing cheap targets pays little, and the same logic for damage/assists would stop high rate of fire vehicles from earning SP just by spraying hits.


How it should play

ground_air_rb_diagram

  • CAS beats tanks.
  • SPAA is cheap and beats CAS. Shooting down a guided CAS wipes out most of that player’s budget.
  • Tanks beat SPAA, which usually can’t take a hit.
  • Fighters beat CAS and helis but aren’t much of a threat to tanks.

So a team that opens all air gets shredded by a few cheap SPAA, an all-SPAA team gets run over by tanks, an all-tank team gets bombed, and the team that brings a mix and adapts wins. Bad team compositions punish themselves, so there’s no need for caps.


Why I think it’d be good for the game

  • More vehicles get used. Strike aircraft and helicopters that never see ground battles get a reason to be in a ground lineup.
  • SPAA finally has a job every match, instead of being skipped.
  • Players stay in the match longer. A guaranteed sortie plus being able to respawn gives fewer reasons to leave after the first death.
  • Low risk. As a separate mode, the pricing can be tested on real match data without touching Ground RB.

What I’d like your opinion on

  1. Would you queue for this, or does Ground RB already give you what you want?
  2. Is “budget = one guided CAS spawn” the right starting point, or should it be higher or lower?
  3. Is the teammate pick preview a good idea, or would it just lead to arguments in the spawn screen?
  4. Is scaling kill SP by target value fair, or does it have a problem I’m not seeing?
  5. Where does it break? Leaving the match early, helis, top tier ARH SAMs, uptiers?

Criticism is welcome. I’d rather find the holes here than have them found in game.

AFAIK ground sim already does allow CAS as first spawn and everyone hates it lol.

So you want grond SIM, where you get insta smoked by LMURS and KH-38s.

Unless grinding ground events, then it makes the event super easy for an air main :P

Sounds like a recipe for even more ODLing when people either use all their SP on CAS and die or get killed by CAS and just leave.
1st spawn CAS is also the reason I refuse to play sim, I tried once at top tier (at the time) and before we even got out of the spawn half our team was dead to PARS spam, never played SIM since. And there is a lot of far worse things then PARS in the game now. If that system is ported into GRB I will likely just uninstall the game.