General Japanese Naval Forces Discussion HQ


It is very historical that Yamato has ‘firecracker’ ammo placement. 2/3 of shell is stored in barbette, 1/3 of shell is stored in hull near or above waterline.

Yamato is very ‘compact’ ship. 72,500 ton is huge number, but not enough number to make battleship with nine 18.1 gun, 410 mm of armor and 27.46 knot speed with traditional armor scheme and safe ammo storage.
So IJN choose ‘cheek’ armor scape which makes her more vulnerable when angled, and ‘firecracker’ ammo storage that most of shells were over waterline.

They weren’t though. Here is the waterline on the diagram posted above.

The only shells above the waterline are the turret no2/3 and secondary shell rooms which constitute a small amount of the total ammo. Think whatever you want about Yamato’s ammo stowage, but it’s objectively wrong as presented in game.

2 Likes

Didn’t I upload the picture from US navy ananlysis diagram of 18’’ turret and shell distribution system? Those shell rooms on your diagram exclude shell room on turret barbette. Game’s one is the most accurate.

Your image doesn’t give any reference for waterline. This is about where the waterline would sit.

The model in game puts full magazines above the waterline which isn’t correct.

1 Like

There are no waterline showed in that cdk and you create waterline! Great!

The horizontal grid plane is default in place of the waterline, so there is a waterline reference in the CDK.

2 Likes

Don’t worry, Yamato has 100 shells per gun. Even if you fire the gun once every 30 seconds, it will take 50 minutes to run out of shells. If you cut the shells in half, you’ll be fine… However, in SBEC, the battle time is long, so you may need more shells. (I’ve never been on a battleship.) Do you think it’s worth it to cut the ammunition if you’ve reached the top tier?

So if I understand the leak correctly all those are ammo? Thats barely below the deck thats funny.
image

If so then Yes indeed the shells were suposed to be a lot deeper.

And this is where powder magazines should be :

So lets just hope they fix those things before adding to the game.

2 Likes

Uh no.

Yes, for example, the magazines of the 1st turret should be located on the bottom, but on the screenshot that is shown in the game, they are somewhere almost under the deck

Spoiler



2 Likes

Lets also hope they model all those hundreds of compartments correctly and that the crew wont go out with slightest tilt as Yamato would be just fine even with 20° tilt.

1 Like

Yeah thats about right. Lets hope gaijin isnt nerfing Yamato like this intentionally. And that they give proper size maps at least 25-30 km spawns for the top battleships that are to come.

Imma be optimist and say they didnt expect leaks to go out so quickly and didnt really model the ammo where it should be yet.

2 Likes

I would expect the worst. More likely this is how it would look like going into the first dev.

She’s gunna be a beauty

Even in other books it is shown how the ammunition of the first main battery turret is located…
Meanwhile, what did the snail do…
image
image

2 Likes

The CDK leak is for sure a work in progress placeholder. The initial leak of USS Colorado on CDK was exactly like this as well: ammo racks were randomly placed around the turret just below the armour deck

6 Likes

Ships dont have genders. If something Yamato is masculine name.

1 Like

1 Like

Gaijins response

Then we hope for the best, and if everything remains as is, we will fix it)

4 Likes