General Japanese & JASDF General Discussion

Even more fake because it’s creating wasn’t started…

2 Likes

Only because the engine never arrived, it was planned from the start to switch to a jet engine when they came which never happened.

In his own words, Kiyohara wrote, “At the ‘Shinden’ Prototype plan requirements in 5th of June 1944. Air Technical Arsenal’s engine department instructed, ‘Proceed with the design taking into consideration the use of a gas turbine engine.’”

Kunitake Kiyohara transelated words “I thought the Tomoe War era was finally coming to an end. Considering the engine arrangement of the Shinden, it didn’t seem that difficult to replace it with a jet engine. I remember feeling excited that it would be something I wanted to make happen as soon as possible. In the end, this did not come to fruition, but Kyushu Aircraft also prototyped the twin-engine jet attack aircraft, the Kikka, designed by Nakajima Aircraft, and the war ended when the first unit was almost complete.”

The only thing shooting it down as a suggestion is that it was not designed yet despite being 80% complete and tested with a propeller engine, it is a way more realistic plane than the R2Y2.

2 Likes

There wasn’t any starts of changing engine and the fact that it was taken into consideration during creating prop variant means nothing in equation of creating plane
So talks about 80% complete is wrong

I don’t say it is not true but once I will see at least the name of source

2 Likes
  1. ^ Quoted from Kunitake Kiyohara, " Kyushu Aircraft’s Fast Forward-winged Fighter 18 Experimental Local Fighter “Shinden”," appendix, Naval Air Headquarters “Excerpt from the Experimental “Shinden” Plan Requirements” (Torikai Tsuruo, editor, Unknown Military Aircraft Development, Vol. 1 (Kantosha, 1999) ISBN 4-87357-049-2 p51, first published in Kantosha’s Aviation Information, February 1955 issue).
  2. ^ Takanori Maema, “The Man Obsessed with Jet Engines”

Because they did not assemble a single engine, not even the Ki-201 the engines was marked for did not even get them, the rare mineral shortage made mass-production unfeasable.

I am a 100% sure that if they had gotten a 100+ engines in time both aircrafts would maybe have flown tough the Ki-201 was in a even less complete state but it was designed and approved so…

2 Likes

just like the Ostwind II and Zerstorer 45 being entirely fictional → Replaced the Koelian 341 (which a mockup was made but apparently the tank isnt real)

T-80U and T-80B having no thermals as standard, However a SINGLE T-80U prototype got thermals = gaijin must give all 80U and B thermals

despite thermals only becoming a thing when T-80UK and BVM became standard

Begleitpanzer 57 having incompatible FCS to fire the HE/VT round yet still gets it

1 Like

Ki-201 prototype remains were discovered last year

Engine Cowel’s for the Ki-201 Karyu

9 Likes

I know this but it doesn’t change that R2Y2 is part of fictional vehicle which wasn’t even planned to be armed with cannons.

Some T-80U had thermals on serial vehicles so not.
Story about single T-80 is about T-80B where single tank had thermal. But it is not similar to R2Y2

In game tank can shoot any round if it was able to be used at gun. Similar why Type 16 got DM23 missing in Japan or Type 74C with HEAT instead of M735 despite Type 74C could shoot only with HEAT.

It is one of official ingame exclusions

2 Likes

What do you mean? There is no Type 74C with M735.

Type 74C could use only APDS, APFSDS and HESH if I don’t mistake.
Here isn’t HEAT round at Type 74C FCS

2 Likes

Was the R2Y2 designed with the provision to carry bombs?

According to Tester’s information only torpedo was suggested. Mostly with torpedo it would get bombs but at the end of war, the status of planning stopped at torpedo only.

3 Likes

Was there a suggestion or bug report regarding detachable flare/chaff pod for T-2?

T-2 pod can use only chaff. And yes it was reported

2 Likes

ha.
image
The Only F-2 We Will Get For A While

5 Likes

That Hurts GIFs | Tenor

8 Likes

6 Likes

GojT315XMAA4rfL

1 Like

1 Like

rambo-3-sylvester-stallone

1 Like

Exactly they used a book that was more fiction than truth to design the R2Y2, no design is not right copy paste is more like it…

Still tough at the very least if the devs choose to implement the J7W2 we know where every part should go, behind the pilot is the fuel then engine behind that there is no doubts. Approx top speed would go from 750 to 780 so gameplay wise not much would change?

Nah doubt it, it was recon plane tough some say a jet version was planned but nobody shows me the proofs so I dunno…