[Balance Suggestion] BMPT / BMPT-72 Terminator Balance Adjustment Proposal

ello everyone, this is a balance proposal for the BMPT and BMPT-72 Terminator.
I appreciate the design concept of these tank support vehicles and agree with their intended role. However, at the current BR 12.0 their combined capability is overperforming. Many stock grind vehicles and other platforms in this bracket lack reliable counters, hurting match quality.
The changes suggested below are not intended to ruin the vehicle, only to remove its overmatching potential while keeping its unique support identity. Civil discussion is welcome, and you may vote in the poll.

BMPT and BMPT-72 are distinctive tank support combat vehicles. However, their overall performance at BR 12.0 is overpowered and limits the viability of other vehicles in the same bracket, especially stock grind vehicles. The goal of this proposal is to keep its intended role — engaging infantry and light armour — without removing its identity, while eliminating its overmatching capability against the front armour of modern MBTs. Details below:

  1. Adjustment for the 9M120-1 Ataka-T ATGM, only one option to be picked, not both:
    • Option A: Reduce tandem warhead penetration to 500–600 mm. It would still reliably engage sides and rears of top-tier MBTs, while losing consistent front penetration against modern main battle tanks.
    • Option B: Add a firing restriction: the ATGM may only be launched while the vehicle is stationary, removing the ability to guide missiles on the move. Its current on-the-move guidance grants excessive pressure and forgiving gameplay compared to other ATGM carriers.
  2. Separate Battle Rating increase (differentiated change instead of a flat change):
    • BMPT → BR 13.0
    • BMPT-72 → BR 12.7
      The base survivability and protection of BMPT is noticeably better than BMPT-72. At BR12.0, this vehicle is extremely frustrating for stock vehicles. It combines Kontakt-5 ERA, twin 2A42 30mm autocannons, high-tier thermals and multiple tandem ATGMs, capable against heavy armour, light vehicles and infantry all at once. Most vehicles in this BR lack consistent counters and the matchmaker ecosystem suffers as a result.
  3. Revise ammo rack damage model to match QN506 behaviour:
    Currently, hitting its ATGM and AGS ready ammo racks only disables the corresponding weapon modules without catastrophic detonation and crew loss, unlike its release state. On QN506, outer missile launchers and ready ammo can detonate and deliver overpressure to kill the crew. I ask for consistent rules: hits on BMPT/BMPT-72 external ready missiles and grenade ammo should have a chance to trigger detonation and overpressure crew damage, to give enemies a dependable weak point.
  4. Optional balance change for twin 2A42 autocannons:
    The long-range APDS accuracy and sustained burst spread are overly stable, giving excessive standoff suppression. A potential tweak is to introduce greater barrel heat drift during prolonged firing to reduce long-range APDS hit probability, while preserving its close-to-medium range capability against infantry and light vehicles.
  5. Fuel tank damage model adjustment:
    All fuel tanks are currently treated as external, and hits to them do not transfer overpressure or cause crew casualties inside the hull, adding extra survivability. It is suggested that fuel tank hits should be able to produce internal overpressure, fires and crew injuries to add another viable counterplay route.

Note: Poor reverse speed is an authentic historical trait of this platform and should remain unchanged.

Continuing the discussion from BMPT/72 BR Topic (Part 1) - #10472 by Panther2995.

Previous discussions:

3 Likes

??? 13.0 BMPT crazy

2 Likes

There is already a thread for the vehicle:

2 Likes

1- Prove that it should be 600mm.
800mm ATGMs is already sub-par for 12.0.
1a- Prove the vehicle has to fire when stationary. Refer to 1.
2- LOL! HAHAHAHAHA!
Neither of these vehicles have 125mm anti-tank guns for such BRs.
They have APDS auto-cannons, & TOW-2A equivalent ATGMs.
3- Prove that’s supposed to be the case.
4- This was already nerfed a while back.

Also, use the bug report site:
https://community.gaijin.net/issues/p/warthunder

It pens 800mm+ in real life, so no

Also able to be fired on the move in real life, so also no

1 Like

The most important part is that they remove the seperated belts between the turret and hull.
This “feature” should have never been implemented and shows what pathetic measures Gajin is taking for their russian bias.

4 Likes

This exactly
That separation is complete nonsense because no other belt in the entire game has something like this and having such a specific separation is completely impossible

2 Likes

Real-world performance is only a reference, not a balance shield.
Gaijin nerfs many vehicles against real specs all the time for gameplay.
So “it works like this irl” alone cannot rule out balance adjustments for BMPT.

Thank you for pointing out the existing megathread and sharing the link. I am aware of that long‑running discussion thread.

However, that thread is extremely lengthy and cluttered with many scattered, off‑topic comments. My post is a self‑contained, structured balance proposal with clear, grouped suggestions for BMPT and BMPT‑72. It would be very difficult for developers to locate this complete set of feedback buried inside hundreds of mixed replies in the old thread.

Would it be possible to keep this thread open? I will add that link to the old megathread inside my opening post, and people are welcome to cross‑discuss between both topics.

I understand the argument using real-world performance as a baseline, but historical data is not an absolute rule for War Thunder balance.
Gaijin has repeatedly adjusted vehicles away from real-life specs for balance reasons in the past.
Examples include reduced reverse speeds for many heavy tanks, adjusted APHE post-penetration effects, and tuned missile performance even when real-world penetration data exists.
The fact that the BMPT can fire on the move and its warhead can exceed 800mm penetration IRL does not automatically mean it is healthy for the 12.0 BR environment.
Real-world capability is good reference material, but it should not be treated as a hard veto against balance changes.
If we only follow real-world stats strictly, the entire BR system would collapse.

For soft properties like reload times and given ammo, not hard properties like penetration and firing on the move

No too less

any source say that?


Is every other ammo belt in the game proof enough when there is absolutely 0 real life evidence that the BMPT should work differently?

No, they have not changed armor values, penetration, etc for balance… ever.
All vehicles in War Thunder are modeled as accurately as possible with information on-hand, & a decision is made if that information has conflicts or it otherwise incomplete.

Reloads are different because men can reload a 120mm MBT round between 4 seconds & 20 seconds depending on willingness & round placement in the vehicle.

@H_ngma
That’s the older belt model system that’s slowly being phased out for the detailed belts.
Could be made faster, but 10+ vehicles aren’t all BMPT for being different than those 6.

If that was true then its apparently not a big priority considering that the AMV BMP3, BMP-3F and ZBD04 are all newer than the BMPT and yet do not have the “new” belt.

And especially the brand new BTR 90 which does indeed have a more detailed belt but for some reason is not magically separated for convenience. Weird.

I didn’t say the new belt model standard was used on all new additions.

I think it should, all vehicles should be updated rather than the >10 vehicles.

On an entirely other note, BMP3’s turret is also old to the game, & while the turrets aren’t copy-paste, the internal turret damage models would be initially copy-paste at the minimum if plausible to do so.

Well so far the “new belt” has been used for exactly one vehicle. So maybe its just not a new belt but straight up pampering bs especially considering that the BMPTs belt was not separated on the intial dev leading to terrible performance.

Please explain the BTR-90 then. Its not copy and paste and its newer. Yet it does not get a separated belt.