An unfair Ground Simulator Battle featuring vehicles such as the Tiger II (H), Panther F, Panther G, Jagdpanther, and Ferdinand

In my opinion, it’s inevitable. It’s going to happen.

Because they betrayed their own word. They claimed they wouldn’t add “paper” vehicles [theoretical/blueprint-only designs], yet they went ahead and added all sorts of absurd ships and tanks to the game.

There might even be more of these “paper” vehicles; I haven’t really looked into it.

They havent from the start they clearly explained that tanks and aircrafts have different criterias than naval forces. Not to mention that neither the panther 2 and kt105 as they are in game would even fit the naval criteria

And this is why the reason they’ve removed R2Y2 and hori too.

I’ve been waiting for Staff to close it down. It’s not productive at all. But clearly they ignored it.

Yup. But, putt some politic. that’s help or talk about Bmpt

Frankly, you aren’t contributing anything to this topic.

You might be an artificial intelligence.

It was only ever installed on a Jagdtiger, the vehicle it was meant for. Installation in a Tiger II was suggested but never carried out, and would have required the manufacture of a modified engine deck, which never happened.

In this respect the Tiger II Sla is hilariously in the exact same situation as the Coelian. The two base vehicles (Panther and Tiger II) existed in metal. The proposed component (Gerät 341 and Sla engine) existed in metal but was meant for a different vehicle. The modification necessary to bridge those two (a new turret and a new engine deck) was never carried out.

Some documents mentioned that they did start already the preparations on one Tiger II to test it with the SLA engine, but war was over before.

Round and round we go😭
Can’t y’all just quote Gaijin’s words on adding shit to War Thunder

They would just bring up the whole “but muh unfinished ships” for the hundredth time.

But there’s the exception that, I thought, was stated (at least from Stona somewhere) for ship just having to be laid down

Yes, there is. However, they will just ignore that and say “but the ships were not finished so the 8.8cm panther must be added”

This has been attempted to hammer in multiple times, trust me.

These aforementioned ships were not completed; only their lower sections were laid down on the slipway. Yet, they were added to the game.

Why aren’t you objecting to this?

The guys managed to come up with something, even if it was just cobbled together from scraps.

Gaijin took all of that and developed a model out of it.

Just like they did with the ships currently in the game.

There’s no issue when it comes to ships, but when it comes to tanks, you suddenly turn into fire-breathing dragons [i.e., become incredibly difficult to please/demanding].

I will happily answer you, after you acknowledge my last two replies and admit that you were incorrect about the Panther II.

No topic-hopping please. You do this all the time when proven wrong, you endlessly rotate through the same list of grievances, and if you want to engage in further conversation with me, you will not be able to do that anymore. Instead, we are going to knock each item off the board once and for all.

So, Panther first. Once that’s acknowledged as a closed chapter I’ll happily answer your question about ships.

And that’s that. What was the point of all this unnecessary chatter?

Look, you’re perfectly fine with them outfitting an incomplete ship—still sitting on the slipway—and launching it into the water.

Yet, when it comes to a vehicle that has a completed hull and a turret that’s nearly finished, suddenly everyone starts splitting hairs and making excuses.

Gaijin produced a really well-made model; removing it was the wrong move.

In fact, failing to keep their word was the wrong move.

The solution is simple: the vehicles should be brought back.

A ship can not both be “only some basic blueprint with not idea what the final design will be” and also “being laid down” at the same time.

This has been you the whole time. Whenever you dont get an answer you like, you ignore it and jump to something else.

1 Like

Not true

They said they would remove fake tanks/planes and they have been doing just that. They have been keeping their word.

The tank encyclopedia link you posted disproved your point and confirmed my own. Is this true or not? Binary question.

I will happily address this after you tell me more about that Tank Encyclopedia link you sent without reading it.

False. As repeated several times in the tank encyclopedia article you linked, the new turret was never built and the guys working on it told the Allies that work had barely started before the war ended.

It is physically impossible and it’s bashing five unrelated projects together.

Once again. We can discuss ships after we conclude discussing that Tank Encyclopedia article.

Come on. Finish what you started.

Gaijin made a fabricated model that a random guy made up as the proyect never called for the 88mm gun, so it doesnt even raises to a paper vehicle, it is a by all means a FAKE vehicle. A panther 2 with a 75mm would could very much be added, as it would be an unfinished prototype and those can be added.

Since you are also using tank Encyclopedia as a source, this is what they say for the panther 2 with the 88 gun

So in conclusion it doesnt even raises up to the low bar of ships as even those still follows the existing design and proposal while the panther 2 as it is in game doesnt.

2 Likes

Guys, don’t wear yourselves out.

There’s no difference between the current ships and the Panther II.

Both are just half-finished projects.

The Daimler team basically said, “We were just getting started on the original turret design, but the war ended.”

all we were missing was a clown, and now one has joined our ranks.

Welcome.