Why is Israel getting F15IA Ra'am II? It doesn't even exist

compared to rafale?

you are not the real bowie_knife99

2 Likes

There is an imposter…

4 Likes

F-2A is not good at CAS lol

The F-14D(R), at least one that is capable of firing an aim-120, is a fake variant. It is a fake aircraft (no F-14 was produced with this capability), with fake hardware (avionics missing the required "soft"ware needed to guide or fire the aim-120) that was in every shape or form just as fake as the IA.

HIstorical evidence, is where the F-14D/D(R) is incompatible with the aim-120 because the program was canned. The whole “hypothetical F-14D(R) with aim-120s because some testbed aircraft had them” carried the same energy as the F-15IA being based off the F-15EX. But one is treated as acceptable, and the other was treated as fake.

What is serious, is people treating like US players are incapable of demanding fake, hypothetical additions, then gaslight other nations on it. People say the Chinese are the only ones guilty of this during the VT-4 drama, but in reality, US players throw their weight around just the same.

A serial F-14D using aim-120s is just as fake as the F-15IA. One could argue that it is more fake because the whole programmed was canned, while the IA production is still ongoing. I just find it stupid that people use the IA as the “muh paper aircraft” boogeyman, when it literally is not the first vehicle of its kind??

A common pointed out example is the Italian Eurofighter. Only ordered, currently not delivered. The whole aircraft is fake and is copied off the British testbed, not even serial, aesa euro specs.

Ok, since we recognize that the F-14D(R) with its historical loadout is not fake, you don’t need to repeat things I am already aware of regarding the F-14D and the AIM-120 program. We could just cut to the chase and get to the main points:

I understand that you feel that way. I am someone who doesn’t mind vehicles of all nations receiving hypothetical weapon additions based on technical feasibility or official but unrealized plans to make things interesting in War Thunder.

Personally, I am not against the AESA Typhoon, F-15IA, F-16AJ, etc. What I think about Gaijin and paper/fake vehicles is that they should make themselves transparent and consistent with their policy on paper vehicle additions following the removals of King Tiger (105), Flakpanzer Coelian, Panther II, R2Y2 series, and Ho-Ri.

Either the game could have paper/fake vehicles, or they should all be removed permanently from the game, even those players who owned those vehicles could lose theirs. I could say the same thing about technical feasibility: either all vehicles in the game can have technically feasible additions when necessary, or none should have them, even when technical feasibility is used as a gameplay concession. The latter is a kind of “too bad, suck it up” thing.

The issue is that Gaijin selectively decides what’s best for vehicles in ways that benefit one nation over others. This is a classic instance of selective realism, so I can see why people are upset with Gaijin’s decisions about which vehicles to add and which to leave out.

To make matters worse, there’s a rumor that Gaijin is considering running events featuring paper tanks such as the O-I, Löwe, etc., in the future. If that’s the case, what was the point of removals of vehicles in the past?

Now, maybe people would no longer scream and accuse each other of hypocrisy and favoritism if Gaijin made its policy much clearer and had its suggestion guidelines to reflect the decisions to add the AESA Typhoon, F-15IA, F-16AJ, and others. If that happens, we probably wouldn’t be having this conversation right now, but maybe I do still overestimate the forum users’ ability to keep a cool head.

5 Likes

Their policy on fake vehicles, to my understanding, that they are usually (not always) gap fillers. When alternatives are added into the game, these are then removed from their respective tech trees.

I’m pretty sure the current policy is the removal of those vehicles from being accessible, but players who have them continue to own them. I am unaware of an example where a vehicle is wholly removed from players themselves.

Agreed. Though I find expecting calm dialogue funny in the forums. Players in video games inherently always adopt an “us vs them” mindset. Their 14 missile SM2 spam vs our benevolent “technologically compatible” 16 missile spam, etc.

iirc there was the surbaisse at one point due to people cheating their way through it.
Or at least one other event vehicle where people got it in a way they shouldn’t have normally.

That’s it though

I’m probably getting stuff wrong but I thought the E-100 had some kinda removal going on.

image

1 Like

Hear hear. US exports almost all amazing aircraft, most TT’s have US hardware. US rarely gets their foreign bought stuff.

For example: where is the US T84 which it bought in 2003 from Ukraine? Soo many premiums are one of captures, here the US buys 4 of them and they do not appear in-game… ?

3 Likes

They say all this stuff about exports, but the US should be able to benefit from its own exports instead of having them handed out to nations that never used them

2 Likes

Please explain what lacking part of the tech tree requires a T84? It isn’t exactly that great of a tank you know…

It does not matter how good a tank is, it should have a matching BR. Theoretically (and I know that is not always the practise in this game) all vehicles are equally good at their BRs.

The T84 would be a faster Abrams while having modern optics. So a nice fast lower BR MBT for the TT. Sure, it can be put in as an event vehicle.

To be fair most of them are long ago barring the Hanomag.

You can always suggest some.

Because the US does not need them.

it would get them if it needed them, but currently USA has the best tank lineups at more tiers than any other nation
Right now the US is the last nation to need any new top tier tanks

1 Like

The F-16AJ was specifically outlined as an exception in order to fill a now non-existent gap. However it’s not accurate to the proposal and is instead just a repainted F-16A with mixed weapons.

At this point they should just remove it. Permanently. And fix the F-16A OCU.

O-I has been confirmed real

1 Like

And China needed the Ah-64E because…

Need does play a factor but also diversity as well. it is the same reason why we see a lot of copy paste American arty in different TT despite not being an actual need for it.

Is the T-84 needed? No

Would it give more diversity to the US TT? Yes

6 Likes

and China totally needed an Abrams, zero domestic designs that could’ve filed that spot, lol. your logic isn’t shared by gaijin.

There’s zero tanks better than abrams man.

What can I say

1 Like