A European tree is a slop idea, it’s already been discussed too.
no its not, by just taking the unique designs from Poland, Czechoslovakia and Yugoslavia you have a 100% unique TT
And one giant ussr tree with more vehicles than in some nations combined, with more press w to win stuff is such a good idea. What? Other nations also wanna see their vehicles in the game but there is not enough of them? Sorry, ussr player’s don’t care, they want more vehicle’s to them and only them
You will never achieve 100% uniqueness if I’m being honest
More nations≠more unique
It becomes a puddle of slop of nations that won’t fit in together
More nations = you have more options, you can pick most interesting vehicle’s and don’t just copy paste stuff to fill the gaps
I know, thats why an idea of Yugoslavia with Central/Eastern Europe for a “European TT” isnt a good one, i am just saying that this nations have enough domestic unique stuff to be TT on their own even if they have C&P stuff on them
The problem is that even these nations combined can’t fix copy and paste issues in certain areas, instead you get multiple nations competing for one spot where they all have unique vehicles
Name a few of this areas
Tadmats Czechoslovakia tree got really close when looking at ground (only 9 identical vehicles iirc out of 205). I do think if a conglomerate C/E Euro tree did happen, there might be enough vehicles to swap the 9 out (of course there’s a space issue).
Can’t really see any solutions for a unique aircraft tree though.
But I do agree with the 3 slot per line rule and 5 line limit there’s just far too much for ground to fit, even if copy paste was kept to an absolute minimum.
One of such, I believe, is rank VII – pretty much all EU-zone nations have modifications and modernisation of T-72s, and it is likely you will see gazillion modifications of it at rank VII, each fighting for their representation as the space for ground vehicles there is rather limited.
And then you have lower ranks, e.g. ranks III/IV/V of the possible Eastern-EU tech tree whereas major (or, maybe, rather visible) part of vehicles are either C&P or vehicles with tags “Made in Poland/Czechia”, like some of the T-34s which are ought to be backbones for the rank to be playbale. And because even the hypothetical PL/CZ/SK/UA/LV/LT/EST compilation cannot really squeeze out enough unique projects for the rank(s) to be both playable and unique, there is a great chance to face the cluttering at higher and scarcity at lower ranks.
On the topic of Eastern EU tree I'd like to see though
Meanwhile, I also believe that picking the unique models for higher ranks won’t make the hypothetical Eastern EU tree any worse. Folders exist, and you should not necessarily have 1 line = 1 nation.
We can also have a 5-line structure, one is T-34/64/80/84 line (maybe with some T-72s) and the other with T-54/55/62/72s and Leopard 2s. The other ones are: TDs, LTs and SPAA. Hell, even then we can regroup LTs and TDs if we are at it to have an extra line for support.
And then I think it’s not terrible to have a mediocre but unique lower tiers with more unique higher tier tanks in folders. After all, that would also ease the grind to them, and C&P might be there [in lower ranks] to make a bit more feasable line-ups for future.
Rank 2-3 medium tanks would be copy and paste of ones already in game, in higher ranks you get multiple T series modernisations competing for one spot.
Air would be worse, everyone used mig’s essentially, then we have all the attack aircraft competing for space.
Heli wouldn’t be that bad, since we were essentially the only ones with a domestic helicopter industry
I think it really depends on the vision of how TT should be compiled. The 2-line MBT structure might be a problem, but if we really pick the unique ones + do folders the higher ranks are pretty much possible.
The 3-line structure makes it a bit more cleaner, but then you have to think of what to put for the lower ranks of the third line to preceed higher ranks.
But we are talking about WT which is made by Gaijin, so C&P that will clutter the ranks is inevitable even with options existing
There are a ton of issues with this idea such as vehicles, Poland and Czechoslovakia both have well above amount of vehicles for ground and air to make up their own tech trees, issue comes when you want to combine two giant tech trees. Playerbase that makes up larger percentage of that played tech tree would be more favored (Poles) and more stuff would be added for that nation.
I think the problem is the fact that one can help other.
From a rather quick glance, Cz/Sk has more lower rank (I-IV) domestic options, while PL offers a bit more higher up. The same for air tree and heli tree.
So combining Cz/Sk with Pl is not exactly wrong, because most of the “required” C&P, like some Polish mid-rank air and ground – or Cz/Sk higher tier heli and some ground, can be omitted.
Also idk if discussion about the entirety of EU positioning in WT should take place in nation-specific thread, so I’ll drop this subject here
I agree that combined “West Slav” tech tree is great idea, issue is with implementation into game where bias would certainly be shown to one side meanwhile other nations would be buried. Take look at Finland and other subtree nations.
Honestly Ukraine as addition should be added as subtree under nation like Poland or Czechoslovakia, it’d be quit controversial to add Ukraine as subtree to USSR/Russia.
Quick link
I’m not very good with brs so would the aircraft that are unique to Ukraine help either tree or a combined tree?
I thought stuff like the Mirage 2000-5FU and Su-27P1M might be handy to bulk out the air trees.
Have you thought about adding the BTR-4? Perhaps folded with the BTR-3E1
True
https://community.gaijin.net/issues/p/warthunder/i/bZkrbgcdLKEg
Hey guys, join in the report for APU for Oplot