The Great War Returns With New Obtainable Aircraft to Mark November 11th!

When will the Garford be nerfed in the great war event? its HE shell is too powerfull and ovepressuring everyone

2 Likes

What definition of subtree is used here? Is it just to say they don’t have a dedicated line, or does this mean that Romanian vehicles are not officially fixed to this techtree and could be added elsewhere but for the time being are here?

3 Likes

When you say it was added in its Soviet operated state, what do you mean by that? Just considering the Soviets didn’t modify the ship at all, they even retained the standard Romanian Camouflage.

7 Likes

I’m not gonna contest the soviets having a claim to the ship but it seems silly in my opinion to not include any of the Romanian service refits under the Romanian flag, especially when as apposed to the just over 1 year service Lyogiky served in the soviet navy, Mărășești served in the Romanian navy from 1920 to 1944 and from 1945 to 1961. It also stings when there was a new policy allowing multiple refits of the same vessel and so far it’s only application is for a premium battleship.

It’s honestly starting to look like Australia where it was a split tree despite literally everything Australian that wasn’t the M1A1 SA went to the UK until eventually the M1A1 SA arrived at the UK tree.

From what I’m aware it was identical to the latest Romanian configuration even down to the name until October 1944. Romania had multiple refits to chose from as a folder or premium option.

5 Likes

No? You can literally complete marks in one match if you play well enough. This isnt them being greedy, this is them being utterly incompetent and disconnected from reality.

1 Like

Its not a “sub tree”. We are aiming to simply move away from that term anyway. However Romania is much like Argentina for Germany. Neither are sub trees, they are simply the respective places where those vehicles are housed for now when they are added.

2 Likes

Modifying a vehicle isn’t a requirement for a nation to receive something. We have many lend-lease or forign export tanks unmodified and yet still in the trees of nations that used them.

By Soviet Operated state, it means the ship as operated by the Soviet Union. Which it was, thus can be added to their tree.

1 Like

Modifying the vehicle has never been a requirement. The vessel was operated by the Soviet Union, therefore it can be added.

1 Like

What would be that new term then, if one may ask?
Not to sound rude or similar, but if a sub-tree is 100% for only 1 nation (U.K-S.A or Italy-Hungary for example). But then you have Romania nearly all in Italy, why not make it a sub-tree already (they were even before Hungary)?

1 Like

Thanks for the answer. This is really good to know since there sadly isn’t any official way to tell what nation is placed where, and if they have a permanent (“subtree”) home or just a temporary one that’s still open to future decisions. So it’s really nice to get information like this.

While on the topic, is there some way you can check this for other nations too?

The overview by @THEPolishThunder in the Sub-Tree Discussion Thread is currently the baseline we have as players, so if any of it is inaccurate compared to what the devs intended that would be good to know.

I understand if this is too much time or just not something you’d have access to though, in that case I hope it could be possible to suggest some future overview about this, ideally in game or at least in the wiki to let players conveniently look this up so they know where to expect each nations vehicles they might look forward to in the future.


Maybe answer somewhere else so this isn’t derailed further… The subtree discussion seems ideal for it

3 Likes

What are you 2 talking about this is a thread about the ww1 event.

3 Likes

Huh? Bro lowkey not a single soul here cares about romanian sub-tree, we got the war to end all wars to fight 😭🙏

you mean gaijin want to leave sub tree system behind?

Wasn’t able to play it on Console PS4 it doesn’t load me into the battle

Its 100% both, but believe what you want to believe.

This is just about the subtree name, which is honestly understandable because it’s terrible for describing what it actually means.

“Subtree” was just how they described the initial South African ground vehicle line as (and even then it caused misunderstandings over what it would be), and the name stuck with the community and applied to any nation introduced within an existing techtree. But to describe “nation that permanently shares it’s home techtree with another”, it’s really not suited at all. Imagine hearing this as a casual player reading any news outside of the game itself for the first time, personally I think I’d just be confused.

1 Like

It was in service with the USSR for only a year! After that, it was returned to Romania!

I really admire how skillfully you twist everything to suit your own narrative: so, it was in service with the USSR, you say? Does that mean it wasn’t in service with Romania—the country that actually owned it? And what about the Ferdinand (also known as Letuchiy)—was that not in service with Romania? So, you’ve added a ship to the Soviet tech tree—a vessel that was operated by the USSR for a mere year—yet you didn’t include it in the tech tree of the country that built it and operated it for over five years? Well, why stop there? The Maus has been sitting in Kubinka for 65 years—why not add that to the Soviet tree, too? I mean, it was “operated” there, wasn’t it? Yes!
A captured trophy? Yes!

And why didn’t you add the Deyatelny—formerly the British HMS Churchill (L45)—to the Soviet tree? It wasn’t just operated by the USSR; it was actually lost in 1945 while flying the Soviet flag, after being torpedoed by a submarine! Surely a destroyer at a 3.3 BR wouldn’t have hurt the Soviet tree, right?

Or perhaps the Murmansk—or the Royal Sovereign (an R-class/ Revenge-class battleship)—weren’t operated by or in service with the British?

And what about the KV-1 with the cast turret—was that not in service with the USSR? Funny how I don’t see it in the tech tree of the country that built it and actually used it. But as a captured trophy for Sweden or Germany? That’s perfectly fine! Is this the same logic behind the WWI event, where everyone else gets one tank, but Germany gets three—two of which are captured trophies? I mean, it’s not as if Britain and France captured German tanks during WWI, right? And I suppose the USSR didn’t have any Mark V tanks either? Though the photo I sent you earlier would suggest otherwise.

Or was the Mark IV from the WWI event not British? Where is it in the British lineup—the country that manufactured it and officially had it in its inventory?

Hi! Could you please clarify what you mean by this? What about the term is inaccurate to your vision, and how should we refer to nations sharing a tree?

In particular, it seems like not all situations are equal, for example you have said that Hungary is in a different situation compared to Romania or Argentina, in common parlance this would have been understood as “Hungary is a sub tree and the other two are not for now”. But if the term sub tree is to be retired, how does one articulate that distinction?

As a big supporter of making TTs fully post national, I’m not opposed to any of these directions, but the communication around them could use some clarification in my humble opinion

2 Likes

To give you an idea: the ship was in service with the USSR for ONLY ONE YEAR! After that—get this—IT WAS RETURNED TO ROMANIA. It even kept its ROMANIAN camouflage, and was returned to ROMANIA in that very state, just one year after the Soviets had acquired it.

We have many aircraft in game with shorter service histories, or in fact, many with none at all. Lots of vehicles didn’t even enter operational service. So a long service life isn’t a requirement or deciding factor on what goes where.

If it was operated by a nation, it can be added to that nation.

Nothing is being twisted at all here, nor is there a “narrative”. I am explaining to you the facts.

I would recommend you tone down your constant aggression please. Coming at everyone on the attack and making false accusations is not going to make more answers flow to you.

Nobody claimed it was never in service at any stage with Romania. What has been said is the ship was in service during its lifetime with the USSR. Thus, is viable to be added to the USSR Naval tree. For which it was planned, selected and added for that very purpose in game.

This seems to just be going of in a fantastical direction of non equivalences now to the extreme. Its not a case of what sat where for the longest, nor is it a case that a vehicle must go to whomever it served the longest with.

As I already explained to you, you are entirely free to suggest a second separate ship to be added to the Italian tree here: Naval - War Thunder — official forum

Throwing non serious whataboutisms is not going to see the ship changed.

1 Like