Foreword
I migrated over to Warthunder from World of Tanks sometime around 2017, around the time of New E.R.A. update. Before then, when I was still playing WoT, there was aviable plug-in or overlay(?) that basically showed the SR1 rating of everyone in the match, aviable by simply bringing up the scoreboard, with corresponding color coded background of each players name for quick and easy overview.
Low-effort artistic recreation of how it looked:
Similar Statshark overlay for Warthunder?
One of the reasons I created this post was that I want to know whenever something similar already exists; and if not, how difficult would it be to create it and integrate it.
As to why I would want such overlay in Warthunder, I have my reasons, but they all boil down to wanting to know if the game Im loading into is lost beforehand and I can just horse around; or if I should actually try to play.
Statshark already has the necessary data gathered and processed in form of SR1 rating, so the real challenge, at least as I see it, would lie in:
A) getting said data from Statshark and if there are any possible legal obstacles of using Statsharks SR1 rating;
B) creating the overlay in the first place.
Sadly, I lack the necesary technical knowledge to create said overlay for myself. However, should there be demand from the playerbase for such overlay, I would be willing to learn the neccesary knowledge and skills in order to create it.
Would such overlay be in accordance with rules?
Even tho if there is demand from playerbase for such overlay and even if I would be willing to sink X hours in order to get it working, there is one more challenge, or rather question, that needs to be answered before any work can begin - and that is if such overlay would be in accordance with the game rules.
First, data itself. Profile data, or service record if you will, is already publicly available info as anyone can check anyones profile ingame easily. On top of that, replays are publicly aviable on the official Warthunder page and can be viewed by anyone. As such, I believe that simply processing said data and then displaying it does not break any rules; moreso that if it did, I do not believe Statshark could continue operating.
Second, modifying the game by adding the overlay. Here I will admit that I am assuming a lot of things as I did not have spare time to look into the matter properly. However, that being said, Warthunder already allows modding in some capacity. WT Live, official web page, allows users to upload and then download and install sound mods which modify the game files; caveat being that such mods cant give the user an unfair advantage in game, such as making enemy engine noises louder so that they could be more easily tracked.
Here lies the core issue and what is probably THE main reason I created this topic, to properly discuss whenever such overlay would give the player unfair advantage.
One of the arguments for such overlay not giving the user any unfair advantage is that it would not utilize any data that is not already accessible through the game itself; it would only further process said data and make it both quicker and easier to display. Any user can, theoretically and albeit quite painstakingly, check stats of every player that is in the match by either opening his profile in the game; or looking up his nametag on external website that is Statshark.
One of the arguments for such overlay actually giving the user an unfair advantage is that knowing beforehand how good team mates or enemies are would affect how player approaches his game. I can definitely see a situation where players with this overlay would focus and prioritize someone with good SR1 rating no matter the mode. For example, why would CAS drop its payload on someone with poor SR1 rating when they could take out the biggest threat their team faces in order to increase their chances of winning?
And so on and so forth.
Im nearly certain that there are many issues I overlooked or I glossed over, which is why I am putting myself in the line of fire and creating this topic.
As such, Id like to hear your thoughts and dont hesitate to comment below.