St Chamond missing front armour

The St Chamond in the game is modeled as the later version with 11mm + 8.5mm spaced extra armour, but it isn’t given it - the model in the game is only given 11mm front plate.

You can see the gap between the original plate and the 8.5mm addition around the gun here:

image

The later model also had sloped roof panels instead of a flat roof - so grenades would roll off, and an elevated fixed cupola for the commander to see from:

image

compared to the earlier models:
image

Unsurprisingly there’s not a lot of original info about this tank available to an amateur seeker, so if anyone can find any suitable info to make an issue to get it fixed that would be great!

ETA: and I’ve managed to put this in entirely the wrong forum - if a forum mod would be so kind as to put it in the Ground Vehicles forum that would be good

17 Likes

Chamond rank 1 viable

1 Like

banana

The game itself is preventing you from suggesting it.

Screenshot_20250404_065447_Chrome

As mentioned in the document: “chars n° 62669 à 62800”, while the vehicle in-game is 62668.

Which makes no sense given the visual features of the tank

3 Likes

Which document? This one? - The firstborn of French tank building. Prototypes of the Schneider and Saint-Chamond tanks

It says from 62669 the SIDE armour was improved - nothing about the front armour.

This picture is labelled with a serial number 62572 - which seems to be several serials before the one you think is the beginning of such added armour:

A French soldier displays the damage sustained in the Belloy sector to Saint-Chamond no. 62572 “CH’TIO QUINQUIN” with the extra 8 mm of bolted-on armor. Source- “Pages 14-18”

image

this also says the angled roof started at 62551 - and the angled roof is associated with the improved armour.

I noticed it too. Was annoyed by how poorly its performing in the event so I went digging

2 Likes

this would be a huge buff because it would make it frontally protected from the armored car HE shells

French tax

You’d think War Thunder would be able to model and code properly after 10 years, but alas, here we are yet again.

2 Likes

This is needed to end the OP hell that the garford beute is.

also crazy how a literal ww1 tank will be better than 80% of rank 1 france

Apparently IRL it was still quite marginal - it could defeat the German 7.92mm AP rifle rounds (K-round), but who knows what effect it might have in game - it still totals only 19.5mm, spaced so less effective than a single plate

Garfords on both sides are annoying.

But Gaford-Beute don’t need to overpressure Chamond and the rest of the Entente tanks since 76mm HE can just penetrate through the current frontal armor of enemies and it creates another difference. right?

It would be great if St-Chamond also needed to overpressure to kill with HE.

Garfords should not be able to cross trenches!!

2 Likes

The garford is annoying as hell but its unfair that only one sides best tank is mostly invulnerable to the thing. I average 7-15 shells to keep an A7V down until it dies from range in a garford when it takes one single shot to kill a chamond

1 Like

‘Hippity hopitty, our magic truck need to pwn every western nation’s vehicle’

and with little kaiser-bias as garnish. XD
Of course, flanking works for them. just… Garford-Beute doesn’t need to face A7V and doesn’t need to flank and just can pen frontal armor of St-chamond. :/

Can’t wait to see Garford-beute fly and dogfight with SPAD
while Gaijin buffs Chamond even more, ‘only where it doesn’t need it’ but no armor improvement.

I really want to see, and I believe that historical frontal armor improvement is better than a ‘silly maximum speed buff’

1 Like

i mean all the vehicles are running x2 speed. and the MK4&5 male are running x0.2 cross country capability. Im quite annoyed that the worst tank of ww1 is the best ww1 tank in WT right now

1 Like

in game spaced armor like this tends to completely nullify HE and HESH

1 Like

Not a surprise when M44 just nails KV-1 and Churchill in WT. :/

Just two more days and no more Garford hellhole ever again.
as long as Both Mk.IV/V will be unusable because of 7km/h speed outside of the event

I think I might just try some matches with St. Chamond after the event ends.
‘If Gaijin implement the armor buff’

it is damn shame that our Mark V which is ‘best version of most iconic tank series in WW1’ is the ‘worst tank in WW1 of Gaijin’

Western Entente tanks really need some love. :/

2 Likes

would be nice if we saw non russian vehicles be done right

1 Like