Shenyang J-11, J-16, J-15, History, Performance & Discussion

As a player from HK, china i am disgusted that these planes are not here yet. Im a big J-10, J-15 and sukhoi fan, yet the newest chinese jet in wt is the JH-7A. Gaijin, can you pls add the J-10 and SU-27 pls

7 Likes

This seems to be the most common opinion. There are some sources that say MK2 uses PESA version of N001 radar (“panda”?) though, so I was really confused

Well at least it was not a C&P plane in the Taiwanse line lol. That and the JH-7A did help to solve the CAS problem. Looking forward to seeing J-10 or J11 in the winter update.

1 Like

The N001VEP radar is a Panda …
On the Venezuelan Su-30MK2B, a variant with a Slit (Planar) antenna is installed …
The J-16 is a clone of the Su-30MK2 with Chinese electronic equipment…so the plans and ways to modernize (if any) the Su-30MK2 in China are quite obvious…

Not exactly a clone, the airframe is a combination of Su-30 and J-11BS features with more use of composite materials to reduce weight. It also uses a more powerful Chinese engine.

How China made the J-16 fighter better than the Su-30 - Air Data News

2 Likes

This is more of an advertising article …
Some of the compared elements do not have much significance since they are connected with existing communication systems and radio-electronic equipment of the previous generation that continue to remain in service, as well as other weapons systems and missiles used …
The keel tips of the J-16 are made according to the technology
of the Komsomolsk-on-Amur plant, which China acquired together with a license on the Su-27SK…
The analogue of the J-16 in Russia is the Su-30SM \ Su-30SM2 engines with variable thrust vector…and not the nameless Su-30 as in the article on the website…
Su-30SME-Myanmar…

1 Like

Point is, the J-16 would still be better in most metrics. The AESA Radar in particular would be a big deal, and the fact that it was built to use Chinese missles

4 Likes

Does anyone know how good the RWR would be on the J-11? Would it be closer too western or Soviet RWR’s in prefromance?

1 Like

Since the Pearl of Peace, China’s fighter research and development has gradually approached the western standards. j11a is basically equivalent to su27sk, and the radar has been upgraded and improved in the later stage, and r77 can be carried. There is really no more information about rwr of j11b, but it will certainly not be weaker than KJ8602A.

2 Likes

Forgive me, but I’m not familiar with the KJ8602A, is that a good RWR?

Yes it is pretty decent. It is on the J-7E and J-8F.

5 Likes

Ahh, then your right that is a good RWR, thank you!

2 Likes

Firstly, we do not know the characteristics of the Chinese AFAR and the updated Bars radar (let me remind you that the Su-30SM has been in service since 2013 \ Su-35S since 2014)…Secondly, on the Su-30SM2, the Irbis radar with FAR as well as the Su-30SM2 received a communication and data exchange system from the Su-57: OSNOD (combined communication, data exchange, navigation and identification system) of the latest generation. In particular, it allows you to control unmanned aerial vehicles from the aircraft. Other on-board equipment has also been replaced. In particular, there is a new on-board computer, an on-board defense system…It is not yet known whether the P-37M was added or not, but it is quite likely…also on our R-77-1…
Of the Chinese missiles, only the PL-15 is of interest… the
PL-12 is…

Spoiler

According to the media, the PL-12 rocket is being created with the technical assistance of Russian specialists. In terms of aerodynamics, it is close to the American Sparrow UR and is equipped with a dual-mode solid-fuel engine of Chinese design. The diameter of the rocket body is 203 mm, the length is 3.85 m and the launch weight is 180 kg, which slightly exceeds the corresponding parameters of the UR R-77. The active radar homing head and fuse used on the UR PL-12 are of Russian design (according to some sources - Agate 9B1348). To increase the launch range of the rocket, it is possible to use a special hinged trajectory.


image

I guess you are talking the FIRST PL-12, which was more than one decade ago. Your sure know that there are not only one version of PL-12, right?
It is commonly believed that latest PL-12 (PL-12A?) is at least equivalent to AIM-120C-5 in range, and it is hard to believe by this time, China ARH missle doesn’t have a AESA seeker already as AESA technology is dirt cheap in China.

2 Likes

Also I should add that PESA radar does not compare with AESA radar, that’s why China did not copy the radar on Su-35 because they know their own radars are better.

2 Likes

When PLA received su35, it didn’t even believe that su35’ s radar was so bad. It was thought that Russia deliberately castrated its radar performance. Later, it was discovered that su35’ s radar was not as good as domestic radar.

10 Likes

The only characteristic of the su-35 is one engine, and other aspects are lagging behind the Chinese Flanker. At that time, China always thought that the Su-35 had been castrated, but then it was discovered that it was the Su-35 used by Russia. In the end, the Su-35 was sent to the second line, and the first line was the J-10C. J-16 J-20

7 Likes

not a fact, what 30SM2 get Irbis.

I know a lot of things that you don’t…And you are inattentively reading the PL-12A data in the screenshot …
if you are interested in American opinion… Ракеты класса «воздух-воздух» ВВС Китая. Заключение - ИнВоен Info (invoen.ru)
About the radar, who said it-the Chinese…An antenna is just an antenna…There are no radar characteristics…There are positive and negative points…
for the overall development… Истребители. Поколение Next: 2. ФАР, АФАР, ЦАР, РОФАР… (livejournal.com)