Please Give Us Back the Original Panther II, Flakpanzer 341 "Coelian," and Tiger II 10.5cm KwK

Wrong. Everything is a tiger.
my-first-time-seeing-a-maus-in-game-v0-gar3pmv6vrtd1

1 Like

Everything is a Tiger if the focus is tactical fear. Everything is a Panther if you start from the stupid meme that it was tHe FiRsT mBt

If we get technical, the T-44-100 was arguably the first MBT.

It laid the basis for russian armored doctrine for decades, if not up to modern day. T-54 simply refined the idea further.

I would not consider that to be technical tbh.

MBT is an arbitrary definition, but it is primarily one of doctrine as you say. The T-44-100 was not really meant to replace heavy tanks as well as its T-44 predecessor (neither was the T-54 really). So long as the division of labour between heavy and medium tanks persists, it is hard to speak of MBTs, even discounting all the other things that for example NATO baked later on into their definition of MBT etc.

wow wtf is going on in this place

everybody knows theres nobody more german than a self proclaimed “Irz Düşmanı”

1 Like

Still astonished that he’s been allowed to keep that username.

Still more complete and real than the in-game Panther II ever was

1 Like

the hull is real and fun, too bad it never had a turret but there’s a Chinese heavy and swedish heavy that had the same fate so if they ever get added it will probably be readded, honestly it could serve as a German t44 with a 75mm turret (I just don’t think 88 would fit)

I have removed vehicles for the record

What a terrible attempt at a strawman, certain liberties ofc must be taken because it’s a video game but it’s definitely marketed and even calls itself “realistic combat”

The utter influx of modern artillery / apc vehicles to ww2 battle ratings completely destroying the armor meta even moreso not to mention just throwing immersion out the window.

Also like I said it’s a video game so certain liberties must be taken for the sake of gameplay, (I’d prefer more aspects from sim to be added to rb like gunners sight aiming, but that requires accurate tank sights as well), but irl there are recorded instances of tanks getting penetrated and still fighting, tank of tank combat without infantry isn’t unrealistic, it’s just dumb in warthunder because you’re on urban maps, the exact opposite of your designed environment (cod but tanks!)

As you yourself keep repeating, “certain liberties must be taken” and therefore this is no strawman. You are already agreeing that realism is negotiable. You just disagree with Gaijin on where the line should be drawn.

Because my realism standards are stricter than yours, I have never considered WT to be a realistic military game. If you removed all SPHs etc, the armoured combat you would be left with, would still be unrealistic, and profoundly so. Therefore I have never looked for WT to scratch that itch, other than with the fidelity of the visual models and specifications (and even there, a lot is abstracted).

WT is an arcade game that is really good at selling the illusion of realism.

The meta is still there and going strong. T14, KV-1 ZiS 5, Tiger II, T26E5, KV 220, these are some of the most meta vehicles in the mid tiers and they’re all heavies. And if you look at the popularity of the Jumbo in tournaments you can definitely add another to the list. Derp guns may have somewhat lessened the dominance of these heavies, but they have not replaced the meta at all.

If you’re in a Tiger II, the APHE of a T29 or an IS-2 will always be much more of a threat to you than the big HE of a vehicle that is the size of a barn, has no gun depression, and also has no armour.

What immersion?

Even in sim you can trivially bypass that through binocular shooting.

Accessibility is a big thing for an FP2 MMO. War Thunder’s entire success is built on it. Like I said before, arcade with illusion of realism.

Doesn’t change the fact that it is hardly the norm.

And that’s before we start getting into the fact that we can repair engines and gun breeches in the field…

Which are the ones the playerbase likes the most… and we’re back to the old formula.

You said it yourself, it’s marketing. A million shooter games mark themselves as realistic without having any connection with reality whatsoever.

WT has realism when it comes to internal modules, crew placement, broadly speaking specifications and visual models. In everything else, it’s an arcade shooter game. Their literal groundbreaking patent, mouse aiming, was specifically about making relatively complex air combat intuitive and accessible to people who’ve never touched a flight sim before.

SPHs are just fine where they are and almost always worse than the regular tanks they fight.

1 Like

This post was flagged by the community and is temporarily hidden.

The Real Panther 2 specifications from january 1943 (when they still were at its maximun expansion not on the verge of loosing a war ), the ones that actual german engineers came up with not the ones that you make up.
imagen_2026-11-18_172311296

I’d much rather a panther 2 with the 75mm, it should be tt too since there’s a 6.0-8.0 gap, German t44

You keep posting the same things over and over.

Can’t you see the connection between these projects?

Looking at your posts, one might think that work was done on the Panzer 38, Panzer IV, and Hetzer—but that’s not the case.

The tank hulls for the Panther II, Panther 88, and E-50 projects are all identical.

Keep in mind that this is a country that is losing the war.

They are exploring ideas for a wide range of projects—you need to take that into account.

After all, we aren’t talking about something like the Landkreuzer P. 1000 Ratte.

Realizing the shortcomings of the Panther, they moved toward the Panther II, then the “88mm Panther,” and eventually the E-50 project we know today. The hull they intended to use was the existing Panther II hull.

As for the turret, it’s the Daimler 88mm design.

The “10.5cm Tiger” is essentially the E-75.

All of these appear to be short-term, stopgap solutions born out of production shortages. While there were also some rather fantastical, long-barreled gun designs, remember that these people were being bombed day and night.

The game has done a good job, though the turret does look a bit out of place. A better solution would be to include the Daimler turret—from what I’ve read, that was the design direction they had settled on.

*I will not respond to your provocations.

It seems you have done the same thing to other members, along with a few others—and it appears you’ve been getting away with it.

I suppose differing opinions are not well-received here.

I also hope the administration looks into your accusations.

Do you acknowledge that the Tank Encyclopedia article you keep reposting says you are wrong and we are right?

Why are you discussing removed vehicles and sim battles on accounts that have just been created and have only played a handful of matches in arcade?

Why do you feel the need to violate TOS by creating secondary accounts?

Why do you assume everyone who disagrees with you is an evil manipulative liar and/or a developer in disguise?

Why do you not take a look at the statcards and service records of people disagreieng with you, before claiming them to be “Allied” mains?

Why do you pretend not to understand that the Panther II and the upgunned Panther F are two different projects, only the latter of which has ever reached a metal stage?

Why are you so unhealthily obsessed with ships, one of the least populated areas of the game?

Why did you choose the username @IrzDüşmanı and what does it mean in Turkish?

I am fully confident that you will answer every question with your characteristic thoroughness.

Apologies for replying so late. In steam, I had asked about it.