but think, does Germany 1.7 really need another SPAA? Even if germany would get it, i dont think any new player would grind it, all they want to get faster to toptier
are you by any chance one of the people that also say the P40 should go to germany because it technically was only used by germany (with its italian crews)
That’s not true though.
Germany does not need a 3.3,and even if they did they still have domestic options
im not saying they do, im saying just because germany used something doesnt mean they should get it lol
Well these AA trucks have just a few photos, their origin is not clear, although iirc on these photos they had Wehrmacht numbers.
These photos, idk if they are more:
*3.0, but no, I agree they don’t really need it, and it wouldn’t be very thematic to the tree when German platforms exist instead.
My point is to say that adding it to Italian tree with Italian crew is simply false and an implication that the current operator rules can be overridden if need be (assuming its addition was deliberate and not an accident).
I am not, because P40 was designed and initially produced for Italian use, and it indeed saw that use later in its career, even if a majority (not all) was with the Germans. This AA truck was most likely a Kriegsmarine creation to protect its ports in Monaco, which tracks with the 1943 date.
Hey
This is an Italian truck base and details on it are incredibly sparce. It cant be confirmed for certain.
Due to this, as well as the fact that Germany has no shortage of SPAAs, Italy was a more fitting addition for this vehicle. Which can be unique for them.
Fair enough, but could I expect it to be moved or replaced in the future if it is proven to be German? It’s not a huge deal, but this is admittedly something I believe to be incorrect at the moment, which bugs the “muh historical accuracy” part of me.
It’s a German vehicle dont be silly it’ll never be in Germany just look at our amx 30 super
We don’t have any plans for this no. There are other Italian vehicles that were taken over or operated by Germany still in the Italian tree. Germany has its own options.
It was added with intention for Italy specifically.
Sorry for bothering but could you or anyone involved on bug reports take a look at my report on the Turms-T? My turms needs to some love :D
Is there any proof for it’s use in Italian service of any kind? So far there has been only major proof of it being German modification.
Hey. Sadly the sources are currently not valid. The first is an encyclopedia page, the second and third are magazines.
There is only one or two known photos of the vehicle and very little outside of that. So there is no “major proof” of it being German either.
Germany already has a substantial roster of rank I-III SPAAs in game, including some of the most popular. So this was an opportunity for a unique one for Italy.
Are these photos avaliable somewhere online since I haven’t seen these probably?
We have quite a lot of images of it’s service with the Kriegsmarine in Malta and much more. There is a lot of proof backing it’s service with Germany.
Feel free to make a suggestion for a separate vehicle for Germany then if you wish to see it there too and have evidence to support it. We have no plans to remove it from Italy however.
Sounds like a brit’s nightmare
I am pretty certain it’s the photos of this vehicle, from Monaco in 1943. And for others watching, you can see the “WM” prefix on the license plate that signifies Wehrmacht Marine.
It’s pretty much an unfortunate circumstance of a convenient vehicle that isn’t actually what it seems. Now that it’s in the game, I don’t expect anything to change unfortunately.
