Naval AB - Torpedo kills on bots not counted

DEV-server - "Alpha Strike" Major Update General Discussion
1

Torpedo kills on AI ships do not count, despite being listed as valid targets on the challenge window.

Started a match with 2 Torp kills tallied on the challenge progress
Killed 3 AI ships with torpedoes
Killed 1 player ship with torpedoes

Ended match with 3 Torp kills tallied on the challenge progress.


https://warthunder.com/en/tournament/replay/179857343275987878

Victory in the [┚ Encounter] Black Sea Port mission!

Destruction of ground vehicles and fleets     8    26956 SL     781 RP    
    3:08     USS Somers     PT-71                  2243 SL    59 RP                        
    7:34     USS Moffett    IJN Sendai             1781 SL    32 + (Talismans)32 = 64 RP   
    12:51    USS Somers     T22 (AI)               612 SL     20 RP                        
    13:26    USS Moffett    Cargo ship (AI)        2520 SL    18 + (Talismans)18 = 36 RP   
    14:38    USS Moffett    Admiral Hipper (AI)    1451 SL    15 + (Talismans)15 = 30 RP   
    16:34    USS Moffett    IJN Yuudachi           2696 SL    58 + (Talismans)58 = 116 RP  
    16:51    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            8736 SL    138 + (Talismans)138 = 276 RP
    17:41    USS Moffett    USS Trenton            6917 SL    90 + (Talismans)90 = 180 RP  

Critical damage to the enemy                  1      378 SL       8 RP    
    17:00    USS Moffett    PB4Y-2     378 SL    4 + (Talismans)4 = 8 RP

Damage to the enemy                          74     5140 SL       4 RP    
    3:05     USS Somers     PT-71                  46 SL                            
    3:33     USS Somers     Spokoinyy              51 SL                            
    3:36     USS Somers     Spokoinyy              74 SL                            
    3:36     USS Somers     Spokoinyy              41 SL                            
    3:36     USS Somers     Spokoinyy              48 SL                            
    4:11     USS Somers     Spokoinyy              116 SL                           
    4:11     USS Somers     Spokoinyy              88 SL                            
    4:27     USS Somers     Spokoinyy              116 SL                           
    4:29     USS Somers     Spokoinyy              50 SL                            
    6:59     USS Moffett    IJN Sendai             50 SL                            
    7:13     USS Moffett    IJN Sendai             94 SL                            
    7:22     USS Moffett    IJN Sendai             2 SL                             
    7:22     USS Moffett    IJN Sendai             7 SL                             
    7:24     USS Somers     T22 (AI)               634 SL                           
    7:28     USS Moffett    IJN Sendai             31 SL                            
    7:31     USS Moffett    IJN Sendai             17 SL                            
    7:34     USS Moffett    IJN Sendai             41 SL                            
    7:34     USS Moffett    IJN Sendai             7 SL                             
    9:22     USS Moffett    Z32                    115 SL                           
    11:19    USS Moffett    IJN Yuudachi           19 SL                            
    11:24    USS Moffett    IJN Yuudachi           24 SL                            
    11:24    USS Moffett    IJN Yuudachi           230 SL                           
    11:33    USS Moffett    IJN Yuudachi           211 SL                           
    12:24    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            67 SL                            
    12:30    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            101 SL                           
    12:33    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            70 SL                            
    12:43    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            65 SL                            
    12:47    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            5 SL                             
    12:49    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            55 SL                            
    12:52    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            110 SL                           
    12:55    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            43 SL                            
    12:55    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            72 SL                            
    12:55    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            38 SL                            
    12:58    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            12 SL                            
    13:01    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            43 SL                            
    13:02    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            29 SL                            
    13:02    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            14 SL                            
    13:02    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            2 SL                             
    13:07    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            41 SL                            
    13:20    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            14 SL                            
    13:22    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            5 SL                             
    13:25    USS Moffett    Cargo ship (AI)        180 SL    1 + (Talismans)1 = 2 RP
    13:26    USS Moffett    Cargo ship (AI)        180 SL    1 + (Talismans)1 = 2 RP
    13:41    USS Moffett    Admiral Hipper (AI)    230 SL                           
    13:42    USS Moffett    Admiral Hipper (AI)    94 SL                            
    13:46    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            151 SL                           
    13:57    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            55 SL                            
    14:25    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            19 SL                            
    14:36    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            2 SL                             
    14:38    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            12 SL                            
    14:43    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            2 SL                             
    14:52    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            2 SL                             
    15:01    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            2 SL                             
    15:09    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            110 SL                           
    15:11    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            2 SL                             
    15:23    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            82 SL                            
    15:32    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            12 SL                            
    15:36    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            2 SL                             
    16:31    USS Moffett    IJN Yuudachi           106 SL                           
    16:31    USS Moffett    IJN Yuudachi           86 SL                            
    16:31    USS Moffett    IJN Yuudachi           137 SL                           
    16:34    USS Moffett    IJN Yuudachi           163 SL                           
    16:52    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            5 SL                             
    16:52    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            82 SL                            
    16:52    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            77 SL                            
    16:52    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            106 SL                           
    16:52    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            7 SL                             
    16:57    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            5 SL                             
    16:57    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            17 SL                            
    16:57    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            125 SL                           
    16:57    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            12 SL                            
    17:01    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            110 SL                           
    17:10    USS Moffett    USS Atlanta            19 SL                            
    17:41    USS Moffett    USS Trenton            48 SL                            

Awards                                        3     1300 SL               
    3:09     First strike!    250 SL 
    17:42    Ship Rescuer     50 SL  
    18:01    Rogue wave       1000 SL

Activity Time                                 2     3553 SL     204 RP    
    17:58    USS Moffett    2800 SL    80 + (Talismans)80 = 160 RP
    17:58    USS Somers     753 SL     44 RP                      

Time Played                                   2                3053 RP    
    USS Moffett    98%    13:06    1353 + (Talismans)1353 = 2706 RP
    USS Somers     84%    4:05     347 RP                          

Reward for winning                                 16824 SL               

Skill Bonus                                                    1018 RP    
    USS Moffett
    USS Somers 

Earned: 54151 SL, 5068 CRP
Activity: 95%
Damaged Vehicles: USS Moffett, USS Somers
Automatic repair of all vehicles: -2624 SL
Automatic purchasing of ammo and "Crew Replenishment": -1618 SL

Researched unit: 
USS Roanoke: 2026 RP

Session: 27efb4d0035f3a6
Total: 49909 SL, 5068 CRP, 2026 RP
2

Mhm the task requires 7 player vehicles - which excludes ai ships…

3

The task is vague.
At the top it does indeed say “Destroy 7 player vehicles…”, but at the bottom it says “Targets: Bots, Players”.

Usually it is the definitive requirements listed at the bottom that needs to be performed, rather than what the “flavor text” at the top is saying.

4

Bots and Ai ships are different. This may be the confusion.

Bots are player slots filled with Ai to play the role of a player position due to lack of players. Eg. IVAN

Ai is the environmental ships used by the map objectives. Cargo ships and their escorts. These usually spawn behind the players at the back of the map.

3 Likes
5

Ouch. that distinction makes sense, and I don’t like it.

2 Likes