Move the FV4005 to 5.3 (realistic)

I’ve already opened a thread discussing the odd behavior of the FV4005’s 183 mm gun. Honestly, I find it extremely inaccurate that it has difficulty destroying vehicles like the Ferdinand, IS-2, or american T34 with a single shot. Therefore many, including myself, have raised the issue of HESH.
However, given that a fix for this bug (because it cannot be considered otherwise) is not planned, I would propose moving the FV4005 to 5.3 for the following reasons:

  1. Practically any vehicle can be one-shotted by the FV4005, making it consistent with its “glass cannon” nature. No stalinium-built IS-2s (unless you’re in a full uptier), unflappable Ferdinands, or adamantium-built T29s. Ofc, as I said, in reality the FV should be capable of destroying all these vehicles easily… but in the game, it isn’t.
  2. Bringing consistency to the UK 5.3 lineup. Honestly, this move would ruin one of my favorite lineups: 7.0, with Conway, Tortoise, Ratel 90, G6, and FV4005. That said, it would make perfectly sense. Great Britain has 7 vehicles with BRs of 6.3/6.7 (+1 premium): more than enough to guarantee a complete lineup for non-premium players. 5.3, on the other hand, is a completely different story. There are no 5.7 vehicles, and only three 5.3 vehicles (including one anti-aircraft). There are also no 5.0 vehicles. A player playing 5.3 would have a lineup consisting of the Challenger, Comet (both very similar tanks), and Bosvark, with the option of adding four 4.7 vehicles: the Firefly, Avenger, Concept III (all three with very similar stats to the Challenger and Comet), or the Churchill VII (completely unplayable on 5.3). To sum all up: the 5.3 lineup is limited and lacks variety. The FV4005 could help make the lineup more consistent.

I hope I’ve made a valid point. Have a good day everyone!

You could put it at 1.0 and it still wouldn’t really perform well

the centaur would be bad no matter where because gaijin wont model HESH right.

This isnt a vehicle problem but a gaijin problem.

Love hitting the targets hesh was effectively guaranteed to crack only to be given “hit”.

IS3 should create a fine pink mist of the turret crew hit by FV4005.

2 Likes

almost every tank in game should be a mechanical total loss from a single hit from a 4005. its not just the scabbing and spall but everything being jolted, smashed and picked up and dislodged too. even if a composite or ERA stops the armour giving out the overall superstructure isnt handling it too well

HESH is such a violent shell in the real world its just a joke how poor it is in game