Is 3BM42's penetration enough for Swedish T 80 U?

I recently watched guides regarding this tank (T 80 U, BR 11.3) after reading replies under my previous topic, that this tank is going to be good. I noticed it often fights against TURMS-T and Obj.292, and Russia in general. Particularly those do not concern me much, either pretty weak premium or a destructor-2, though Obj.292’s T-80BV base is a part of concern, too.

What concerns me the most is Soviet T-90A and T-80U. Indeed, Soviet T-80U has a bit higher 11.7 BR thanks to having 3BM46, and 11.0 T-90A has awful mobility, but…
I’m not gonna talk much about protection, we all know T-72 series have better UFP ERA coverage than T-80. What I wanna talk about is that, thanks to Russian armor overperforming (see https://forum.warthunder.com/t/making-russian-tank-protection-more-realistic and notice how later in the text I say 233mm instead of T-80U’s 150mm steel and 70mm textolite, the latter being nearly useless against APFSDS IRL), T 80 U is not able to penetrate it’s direct Soviet counterpart T-80U frontally once it’s out of ERA, but vice versa can happen (233mm/68° is around 620mm frontal protection, with in-game 68° normalization I divide that by 1.24 and get around 503mm LOS. That can be effectively penetrated by T-80U’s 3BM46 (~530mm pen) and wonderfully by T-90A’s 3BM60 (~580mm pen). Meanwhile, on Swede, with ~450mm pen of your top shell, 3BM42, you will have to aim for T-80U’s and T-90A’s weakspots, which are indeed pretty massive like the LFP, but are much smaller than your entire UFP, which is the “butter” for 3BM46/60 “knives” (again, once they shot off your ERA).

I know that Gaijin cannot give Swedes 3BM46, as it’s a rare shell and never was exported, and cannot give 3BM60, as the old Soviet autoloader doesn’t fit it, though I heard of 3BM42-2, I don’t know if this one would be suitable.
Making the tank 11.0 and lower is absurd, as with K-5 ERA and 1250hp engine, it still is much better than T-80B, but I think it really needs a more powerful shell to be equal with Russian 11.0-11.7 tanks. 3BM42-2 sounds like the only working option. I do not consider giving a Swede an unique shell a problem, as there is a Leopard 2PL with DM43 shell, unique to this tank, squadron one too.

Of course, penetration isn’t a problem on high tier, even 300mm pen APFSDS is enough to reliably penetrate weakspots even of Strv122 and T-90M, I tried that myself with my 122-1, but Soviets still have major penetration advantage over the Swede, which can still enhance their battle experience greatly.

1 Like

Quick google search shows this was first seen at 2019 expo.

Safe to say its unlikely sweden T-80U will get it.

3BM42 is more then enough and No, it would not get any new shells… after all is a mind boggling how Sweeden got (in game) T-80U and Mi-28 in a first place, but that anothe topic.

2 Likes

I see. Still, T-90A and T-72B3 also technically shouldn’t have 3BM60 released in 2016, but gaijin has stopped making time-based use of shells for tanks (Swedish low tier using 1943…or 1947? APDS, ELC AMX 1961 using 1962 shell, etc)

It’s not mind boggling at all, hotstridsvagn-7 went through famous trials and is a great squadron tank option for Sweden.

Your pfp checks out about Mango complaint tbh

Difference is that these tanks are still in service with russia, so it isnt far stretch that older tank could recieve modern ammo as long as the gun was capable of firing it due to pressure concerns.

Swedish T 80 U was trialed between 1991 and 1994 and was not, in fact, accepted into service. Swedish T 80 U thus represents T-80U version from that concrete period of time, whereas russian T-90A and T-72B3 can represent any version between their DoI and today (as long as they are in service).

1 Like

true, though technically gaijin allows the use of projectiles from the future even to prototypes that didnt serve.
But I guess Rostrv will remain with a poopy shell (still great against all western tanks, but not enough against Russian threats, which it faces constantly)

got any specific examples?

the aforementioned ELC AMX bis 1961. Project was cancelled, but it uses 1962 shell nonetheless, instead of ENERGA mentioned throughout the documents

1 Like

id say difference here is that were talking about 1961 french vehicle getting 1962 french shell (and id say its likely the shell development ran concurently with the ELC AMX), which does not seem as that big of a stretch, when compared to 1994 sweden (trialed) vehicle possibly getting 2019 russian shell.

1 Like

Sorry but I dont get what my profile picture has to do with the subject?

3BM42 is perfectly fine for the T80 U, ive been attempting to not game end myself while playing the Elde 98 and when i die i play my T80 or my CV90120 since they are better than all the leos, the T80 has better bias and armor than the Leos do while being super fast. The gun is solid and sure 457mm pen isn’t great but its more than enough to kill everyone else.

what issues are you having with the mango round against russian/ussr mbts?

Aiming if i had to guess Mango is great, sure you need to be more accurate but it has very good spall and velocity and its on a very good platform. Maybe hes just not used to playing Soviet vehicles idk.

1 Like

I get about T-80 but how is CV90120 better than Strv? No armor vs. best armor on top tier. I know there is also “no armor best armor” but CV90120 has a powder barrel all over the rear

the fact that once the T 80 U is out of hull ERA, it can be penned by 3BM46/60, whereas 3BM42 is useless against itself and T-72B series/T-90A. It’s not a big problem but in case of a long range skirmish 530mm+ pen sabots come in handy.

Fast, fast reload, and 24x zoom and European province, you literally cant see me lol and im shooting at people from behind cover and i can see their faces clearly cause again 24x zoom

1 Like
  • swedish
  • Lmfao
    You already got the handholding by even getting that trialed tank, lest we also forget that sweden heli tree also technically doesn’t exist ( unique tree btw)
1 Like

Add Danish Fennec and thats all ill need from Sweden helis lol

1 Like

oh yea, the zoom looks lovely, it’s like top tier Pvkv2