Iranian Grounds Force Tech Tree

The addition of these is very attractive

3 Likes

I know this is ground tech tree suggestion but Iran is getting/will be getting some Su35, Yak 130, and Mi28NM from Russia, last one is in the game, so Iran could get it.

12 Likes

That would be a good choice to expand the Iranian helicopter lineup at higher tier. Basically this would made Iranian heli tree having 3 top tier helicopters (this, Toophan II, and Shahed 285B), each with distinct loadouts to differentiate from one another.


I’m quite busy with real life stuff at the moment, but I will make sure to make a suggestion for the Iranian heli tree, as they have a very soild lineup of vehicle and weaponry to choose from.

6 Likes

Talking about that, maybe Iran could get a subtree too to fill gaps (specially in air)

Might be an unpopular opinion, but since there’s a debate whether to add a unified Korean tree;
Well, since Iran has used and still uses some NK weapons and platforms, how about adding NK subtree to bolster this Iranian tree (if Iran ever gets added independently)
(in turn, the separate South Korean subtree can be discussed somewhere else)

Discussing from Ground PoV, few examples of collaboration:

North Korea received one example of T-72 ‘Ural’ from Iran in the 1980s:

Iran ordered & received numerous Chonma-Ho during the late 1980s:

Iran ordered & received numerous 170mm Chuch’ep’o “M-1978’’ ''Koksan” during the late 1980s:

The North Korean 155mm SPG shown in 2018 has most similarities with Iranian Raad-2/2M 155mm SPG and is highly concluded to be created in collaboration with Iran.


more read:
The Mysterious Origins Of A New North Korean Howitzer | 21st Century Asian Arms Race

Can North Korea be added as a subtree in an independant Iranian Tech Tree? (discussing in regards to Ground TT for now)
  • Hmm … not a bad idea. North Korea can bolster the Iranian tech tree.
  • Nah … Unified Korea it is. Iran can be bolstered by some other nation if needed.
0 voters
3 Likes

The thing is, while Iran did have some ties and cooperation with North Korea, neither of them are reliant on one another and does not have any other deep or long-lasting historical or military connection. As Iran only used a few models of Korean weaponry, both North and South, I don’t think the idea of adding either of them as a sub-tree would be a good idea.

So I’d rather see North Korea receiving the same treatment like how Gaijin handled the Chinese tree and added as unified Korean tree instead.

Speaking of sub-tree, I have discussed with folk from the SEPAH Discord and they have proposed the idea of adding Syria as a sub-tree. The reason being that Syria is a long-time ally of Iran even before the 1979 revolution, and both supported each other in their respective conflicts and is known to cooperate during the war with ISIS.

While I don’t think there would be enough space for the ground tree, I think some Syrian ground vehicles could be added as an optional foldered vehicle in the ground tree, and/or bolstering the air lineup that Iran is somewhat lacking at the moment. Though I would like to hear from the folks on both side about this idea.

3 Likes

Maybe too much is read into country names or nations for tech trees. Doing so leads to worry or argument about historical ties and who buys what vehicles from whom etc.

If Gaijin did want to flood the market with a load of new tech trees, then It could go down the route of grouping the major existing trees under a different banner. Area codes for example (Not a great example admittedly).UK could be take the Commonweath tag. America could be generic not just North America but South as well, Sweden could become Baltic region with Denmark, Norway etc. Europe could be east or west, north central whatever.

Israel could fall under Middle East with all the Arabic sub trees attached, Turkey, Iran etc.
You are not reliant on history but geography, so it matters not if there are friendly ties or historical grievances. None of that would be any relevance any longer. Might allow Gaijin more wriggle room in the future.

War Thunder seems to have no concept of enemies in historical terms anymore, so it matters not if Iran and Israel fight side by side in the game or oppose each other.

It’s a vague, poorly formed idea admittedly but a possibility maybe?

1 Like

I kinda get your point, since the Hungarian sub-tree kinda muddles the whole “historical connection” requirements for a sub-tree quite a bit. Though imo I don’t think Gaijin would “simplify” the tech tree into the regional tree like you said, since that would definitely gonna anger a lot of people who may viewed that as a “genericalization” of their country into other countries’ tree.

There are several proposals and idea of a regional tree (like Benelux, Arab, or LATAM), but these regional proposal does have some historical backing into it that would justify the grouping.

Of course, the Chinese tree with CCP/KMT in one tree is a major exception of “two enemies in a single tree” taboo, but at least the two has their historical ties to the Chinese civil war, and this similar reasoning could be applied with DDR vehicles in German high tier as well. Iran and Israel, meanwhile, has little to no historical and military connection. Which means there are even less chance of them being grouped together simply because they are “in the same area”.

While I would prefer not to bring politics into the discussion, I think there are certain lines that I think Gaijin wouldn’t cross.

6 Likes

The bulk of North Korea’s vehicles are derived from Soviet or Chinese vehicles. Iran’s connections to North Korea, as you say, are limited to export between the countries as well as technical collaborations (The Raad-2 copy, supposedly provided an upgraded FCS for the later Ch’ŏnma variants, etc.)

North Korea suits a sub-tree in China much better, although if that wasn’t an option, honestly I think I would prefer it in an Iranian tree as opposed to a United Korean one.

1 Like

Looks like a very well made, full, and healthy tech tree! Definitely not the first new nation I’d want (gib Poland!) but this would still be a good addition!

1 Like

You are right in many ways as anybody who is part of this forum and certainly the old one would testify. I studied social and political history for my degree and it’s a rabbit hole Gaijin don’t want to venture down at all, and I think they know it.

The issue for Gaijin is that, presumably the more nations it involves the more money it can make. Getting bogged down in historical and political argument every time Gaijin want to introduce a new series of vehicles is counterproductive and expensive.

It would be a bold move to edge away from Nationalism but that is the way the world is moving in many ways.
I’m suggesting remaking the game into a series of renamed groups. Could be for example A1: North /South America.E1 France, Germany etc. E2: Poland, Slovakia maybe Ukraine with respect to the current issues etc. C1: UK, SA, AUS, Canada etc., SE1: China, Korea etc., ME1: Turkey, Israel, Syria etc.

No religion, race or politics/history. Just an open page for the addition of any new trees, sub trees or even single vehicles.

Gajin will lay down the rules as it sees fit, and we all have to suck it up so this would be the way and the player base would have to take it or leave it like any other aspect of the game.

War Thunder does seem to back itself into a corner at every opportunity and it takes a bold move to set the record straight sometimes.

1 Like

The have definitely painted themselves into a corner game design wise.

1 Like

For the OP we have an ongoing issue of how to implement new tech trees without causing an international incident.

Then we have Map gate.
The CAS debacle (or not)
The WW2 tanks in Cold war era episode
ODL
Spawn camping

And recently the poor quality of higher tier players now that many of the old timers quit in disgust business.

Apparently, they were unhappy about something. Can’t imagine what that might have been.

I don’t think north korea it’s a chance cause they will probably add (one day) both Koreas as independent tech

4 Likes

nice idea

1 Like

Which is exactly why maybe they shouldnt be added, or Iran just gets shafted for air and isnt the best air Tree to add. Its just forcing a circle through a quare hole, and further creating an alternate history/fake reality to force a tech tree to work. And one that isnt as unique as say the entire Russian fed or US tree or German Tree.

As with the Japanese F16AJ, imo its in the same grounded reality as the the F16IAI. But an important factor it seems people dont want to admit here, is that Japan is one of the very first tech trees, and is already in the game. People keep using Japan as an excuse when they make only semi-interesting new TT proposals, to why they should pad their tree with extremely off key additions, that never wouldve happened ever. Like iran using F18s and F16s is insanity to consider.

Japan is two things too

  1. An ally of the US

  2. A tree that gets exceptions. Just like the R2Y2 and Ho-Ri. The F16AJ is there to fill a void because japan made a huge jump in tech and their next gen fighters would dominate. Whos to say the F16aj wont get removed some day like the R2Y2 will also, both are temporary for now

On the topic of whether Iran would need something to fill the high-tier gap, I think it should be worth mentioning that Iran did try and upgrade their F-14 fleets on its own since the war with Iraq, with the earliest attempting being a conversion of the MIM-23 Hawk into an AAM called the Sedjil to fulfil the shortage. The missile would be used along since the AIM-54 Phoenix Iran has in the stockpile.

image
image
image
These images show the Sedjil missile (red fins) on the Iranian F-14. Note how it was mounted alongside the AIM-54 and other smaller AAMs.
image
image
Here is the Iranian modified F-4E with what appears to be either the Sedjil or the AIM-54 missile.


image
Comparison between the AIM-54A (above) and Sedjil (below).

In addition, Iran has also procured and developed various AAM on its own and modified their aircraft to be compatible with these weapons. Most notably modified the F-4E with Chinese-based avionics to allow it to launch the PL-7 missile, producing their own version of the AIM-9 called the Fatah (or Fatter), and reverse-engineered F-5 into the Azarakhsh, Saeqeh, and Kowsar to accept more advanced missile and avionics.

So, at least in my opinion, while Iran would be somewhat lacking in terms of different aircraft model, they can still offers a unique variant with assortment of missiles to “catch up” with more modern generation fighters that will eventually be introduced in the future.

Below are some images of assortments of missiles and other weaponry that I found. I can’t identify all of them so feel free to take a look.
image
image
image
image

9 Likes

See thats what im talkin’ about! Thats awesome! Id love to use the ‘funny’ Iranian modified missiles. Very cool information

2 Likes

Iranian T-72F
The cheaper alternative to the Karrar MBT. All Iranian T-72 is to be upgraded to this standard.
Upgrades incorporates a new welded turret and more ERA coverage.
Lacks muzzle reference system, RWS & soft-kill APS of Karrar.

7 Likes

Interesting.

So, I guess this is basically an upgrade kit for existing T-72 models rather than a fully rebuilt tank like the Karrar?

2 Likes