Helicopters MITL needs a rebalanced or Removed from the game

I rather fight 16 cheaters in tanks than a single helitrash sitting on helipad shoving lmurs up their own asses, because I still can kill the cheaters in tank, not even SPAA can kill the shithead sitting on helipad spamming MITL like a bot, even worse some defending this trash mechanic, I don’t even know what to say anymore, maybe they can’t get any kills fighting things that could actually shoot them back. Disgusting

5 Likes

Other heli, plane or scout uav can do it. Its piss easy to spawn and Im sure at least 1 or 2 players in your team should have heli/plane in their lineup.

1 Like

There are always people defending the most obscure ideas, like some paid actors.

1 Like

Me when i queue into grb to play ground (you will play air rb and like it.)

2 Likes

My experience as an heli enjoyer:

Personally, i think part of the problem is just the average SPAA player always play the same way: putting all vehicles one besides another on spawn rather than spreading them out and driving the radar truck into a better position, and one of the major issues of teams losing is that there are too many spaas and too few tanks (and often planes are also doing CAS rather than countering the helis)

MITL grants more safety to helis but at a lower kill per match ratio, however IRIS T and Sky Saber still hit the helis most of the time if they get careless and go up too much, or if the map is completely flat and allows radar pings even when landed on helipad, and these two appear to be ignoring mutipath on most occasions too. USE THEM if you want a change to kill helis, not things like Spyder or Nomads.
Still on the topic of spaas: Don’t bring missile-based SPAAs to shoot down enemies’s MITL missiles, you will run out of ammo quickly and die (except if you are a SMSV), bring HE-proxy SPAA, like Otomatic, the swedish things, and M247, and often even a Gepard can reliably protect it’s team.
Last night i saw an enemy Otomatic shoot down nearly all MITL incoming missiles, of 3 helicopters, for almost half of the match before it was finally killed by a KH38, it was busy fighting the helis, but it’s friendly SAM systems were also wasting precious ammo trying to also shoot down enemy missiles (which the Otomatic was already doing, and shooting them down before the missiles intercepted them), and so the long range sams were ignoring the planes.

As before, Laser Brimstones are the perfect counter to helis, but i’ve also encountered some interesting strategies to kill me: Glided bombs, a F15E or Grippen can easily dispatch a few GPS guided bombs to the closest Helipod and often get one or two kills of heli per run, with a cheaper loudout than bringing Brimstones, and unlike missiles, the heli doesn’t get a warning that there are bombs coming it’s way, specially since we get distracted a lot if a plane is flying around helipod or when guiding the MITL.

Being honest, i much prefered how Helis were before the MITL update, it was more fun and exciting to look around for targets while being careful with autocannons, HE proxies and enemy spaas, using terrain at your favor and all. I hope they remove the MITL or balance it, like making it’s reload much longer, like 1 minute base (30 seconds aced), to allow players that prefer normal heli gameplay to stay at a lower BR, and with an advantage of faster reload.

Sorry bad english :D

1 Like

If you want to guide the missile manually you should not be able to switch guidance to IR mode. Stops the rippling of these missiles that are not counterable.

Your English is good your take is bad.

No other weapon system in the game can be used like this, Russian LMURs setup and dominate the spawn they dominate SAM (Sky sabre wont hit all 6 missiles launched at it, Neither will IRIS-T they just die and they die because that heli can essentially reload the missiles while the previously launched ones are on their way to the target.

Laser brimstones are a good counter but to spawn a jet that carries them costs far more than the Helicopter does and then you need to avoid all the SAMs and Su-30s flying.

The way we reapair this mode is not allow the missile to switch guidance, you launch in MITL and then you die or stop guiding the missile does not change to IR mode. It should not be allowed to be used in a way where it will track in IR mode. Increase heli pad distance from the battlefield. Increase time heli reloads.

So far this mechanic is game breakinglly bad with MITL Helis able to just overpower SAMS

2 Likes

Agree with you said
I think ths 4 suggestion in th post is best change: ‘Make MITL work in the reverse order, instead of the last missile getting access to MITL, make it like a queue where the first missile is the one that gets the MITL, instead of working like a stack’

That’s an interesting idea in a way actually

1 Like

Question, how manueverable are the MITL missiles? Just curious if lofting up high where AA can shoot the missile down is the only effective way to use these.

In terms of theoretical maneuverability, all of the current MITL missiles have max G load <10. It doesn’t affect it too much due to the slow speed of the missiles, though. The real problem is that with the exception of the LMUR, they are way too slow and are therefore constrained by the slow airflow not providing enough drag for the control surfaces to create an adequate turn.

In terms of practical maneuverability? Extremely poor. You cannot adjust the flight profile in the vertical direction at all. All MITL missiles are set to altitude hold, at 600-850m radio altitude, and dive when close to the target (typically <1km).
The guidance method of the MITL missiles HEAVILY constrains maneuverability. The largest problem is the FOV of the MITL seeker view. First of all, heli MITL missiles (with the exception of the LMUR, again…) have over 18x zoom, and therefore very narrow field of view (making it difficult to search for other targets). Secondly, the sensitivity of the mouse in the MITL seeker view is very low. It doesn’t matter what DPI you set your mouse to, it will be the exact same speed. Therefore, slewing to find targets is very slow, and involves incredibly large movements of the mouse. (I might post a video to demonstrate this later).
Lastly, the MITL seeker view is extremely buggy, to the point of insufferable frustration.

  1. Upon first switching to the seeker, you will often find the seeker pointing straight ahead (showing only the sky) instead of at the target.
  2. The seeker is extremely laggy, and will often take MUlTIPLE SECONDS to update the guidance when you switch the target.
  3. When switching the target, the seeker will often fail to center it in the view, instead over-slewing in the offset direction of the target you selected. You will then have to manually move it back on the target, or reset by switch out then back into the seeker view.
  4. The seeker will occasionally lock onto a different spot than the one you selected. Why? Don’t ask me, I don’t know how Gaijin can mess up something so simple.
  5. In GRB, MITL missiles’ seeker view will often not display teammates’ nametags at all! Depending on how close the actual host heli is to the battlefield, things may or not render in the MITL seeker view. This is why you see so many people TKing with MITL missiles. It forces you to manually guess if targets are friendly or enemy, which is something I shouldn’t have to do in RB.

In summary, it’s significantly frustrating to operate, and the issues heavily impact the function of the missile.

2 Likes

Got it. Wasn’t sure if they were maneuverable enough to utilize evasive movement or cover to avoid AA fire.

After playing nothing but Air RB for over half a year, I decided to come back and see how things were going in Ground RB. It’s insane that they’ve allowed something like this to happen.

I genuinely think there was some malicious intent behind the addition of MITL.
They knew it was broken as hell, and that’s exactly why they added it, the only thing that can counter it is a plane making a gun run, forcing players who have only the ground tech tree to either grind the air tree as well or become food for everyone else.

With that said, I’m going back to Air RB and never touching this get destroyed by CAS simulator again.

3 Likes

It’s just stupidity, I heard they don’t even play their own game bro

3 Likes

Theoretically, that capability would involve an entirely different system to the current implementation, such that the missile could be directly controlled, i.e. like a plane.
Currently, the only input of the MITL controls is the point of impact (target point), with all else determined automatically. Movement path or evasive maneuvers are not just impractical, but pretty much impossible. However, this is not attributable to any categorical limitations of the current guidance system as much as it is attributable to the poor implementation we have in-game.

Specifics of the problem.

Let’s say you want the missile to do a significant turn to the left or right. For example, making a 90° turn. I will explain the problem below, although it may be difficult to put it into words. Much of this is from my experience using KD-88s in Nuclear Escalation, although it generally applies to heli MITL missiles as well.

Currently, even if you, for example, select a target to the very left or right of the seeker’s gimbal limit, the missile will barely turn at all. Like, it’s not even the missile’s maneuverability being bad, it’s literally just an artificial limitation. The result is a turning radius of tens of kilometers, so it’s basically impossible to use to change the missile’s course in any significant manner. Not to mention the constant, massive mouse dragging movements you have to do to turn the seeker.

The only way you’ll actually get an MITL missile to turn as hard as it can is in the terminal phase. That means you will have to set the aim point on the ground, close to the missile’s location (In other words, downwards). That does get the missile to turn sharply. HOWEVER, doing this will also remove the altitude hold state permanently. You can’t get it back by setting the aim point back to a target far away. And when you select a point far away again, the missile will again turn at a glacial rate, and since the altitude hold is gone, it just continues on its downwards course, crashing into the ground.
Even if it was able to maneuver towards the aim point, the geometry makes it impossible to fly once the altitude hold is gone. Since you can’t lock onto the sky, you won’t be able to get the missile to climb, and it will crash into any elevated terrain.

Honestly at this point, they should rename ground RB to “air rb with helis and extra victims”

1 Like

Completely agree there is no need to come up with a mechanic in which there are no counters to it, hover behind cover without any aa being able to engage you is absolute bs and shall be removed effective immediately. We need this game to become skill based not technology based!!! Turning on thermal camera on a missile and then guiding it towards targets when no one can fire at you is pointless. Please remove mechanic.

1 Like

They really aren’t playing their game cus if they did a lot of the changes that happened would be undone.

The fact they added APS to all nations and they cannot intercept these weapons is just another oversight from Gaijin

MITL is the only thing I can fight your idiotic IRIS-T with in my AH-129D. So shut up, crybaby. Thanks :)

1 Like