Cope.
I think there’s an inherent problem with the SPAA/CAS dynamic where top tier SPAA feels incredibly boring to play, and is not that rewarding (although personally I find great satisfaction in intercepting munitions)
The rewards should be improved for intercepting munitions. If you save half your team from dying you should be rewarded for it, right now the RP/SL amounts just feel too low (Of course the main benefit is that your team has been saved from a CAS run, potentially contributing to a win but still). I see a lot of AA players not bother with shooting down munitions, even when they clearly can see the bomb/missile on the radar.
Also it doesn’t help a lot of maps don’t have great spots for AA to set up, most of the time players end up stuck in the spawn because they’ll be shot as soon as they try to leave.
About MITL, I think one big issue is that MITL missiles (specifically the LMUR) loft so high up you can guide your missile onto targets you normally wouldn’t be able to see without flying super high up in your helicopter. Example would be on advance to the Rhine, normally helis are pretty limited there due to the buildings; with MITL you can loft the missile up and then find targets very easily.
Combat between vehicles too dissimilar in mobility fundamentally does not offer the dynamic relation between player positioning and outcome that is offered by combat between vehicles of more similar mobility. SPAA doesn’t move nearly as quickly as an air vehicle and they cannot move in 3 dimensions.
With less comparable mobility, a given period of movement from a vehicle will have a looser relation to vulnerability. With a larger gap in mobility, prior carelessness or caution in positioning will have less of an effect on said vehicle’s level of risk. The more mobile vehicle can be more careless without it affecting their level of risk to a vehicle that cannot move to take advantage of said carelessness. For the less mobile vehicle, with a larger gap in mobility, prior carelessness by the less mobile vehicle will have less effect on their exposure to risk. With a larger gap in mobility, combat outcomes are more uniform regardless of player skill.
With the game needing to present a minimum level of difficulty for careless players, a larger gap in mobility will make the game uniformly punishing for careless players and skilled players alike.
Combat between SPAA and air vehicles presents a fundamental problem. Player controlled vehicles cannot coexist when their vehicle types are too dissimilar in mobility. The solution is design around overtly preventing combat across different vehicle types.
This also explains why bombers and strike aircraft in Air RB remain unplayable unless they happen to be ignored by the enemy. Beyond a minimum level of player skill, vehicles of greater mobility trivialize careful positioning by a less mobile vehicle. Unless vehicles of greater mobility are made into fodder, vehicles of lesser mobility cannot participate in combat with said more mobile vehicles. Unless vehicles of lesser mobility are made into fodder, vehicles of greater mobility cannot participate in meaningful combat with less mobile vehicles. In either case, when both vehicles are controlled by players, a player from one side of the mobility gap will be made into fodder.
Close air support in ground and naval presents a fundamental issue where combat between vehicles so dissimilar in mobility cannot occur without a player from either side of the mobility gap being made into fodder.
Close air support cannot continue to exist as a part of ground without players in helicopters, fixed wing aircraft, or ground vehicles being made into fodder. In playing to the strengths of the game mode, player controlled combat air vehicles are best removed from the game mode entirely.
Close air support cannot continue to exist as a part of naval without players in aircraft or naval vehicles being made into fodder. In playing to the strengths of the game mode, player controlled combat air vehicles are best removed from the game mode entirely.
When a vehicle on the opposite side of the mobility gap is instead controlled by AI for PvE gameplay, said vehicle on opposite side of the mobility gap can be made into fodder without creating an unplayable experience for any player. In classic air battles, ground vehicles already present as fodder for air vehicles. With the inclusion of AI controlled combat air vehicles into ground and naval battles, combat aircraft can remain part of the game mode without making any player into fodder.
Including potent AI controlled combat aircraft will leave the issue unresolved for player controlled naval and ground vehicles. In classic air battles, ground vehicles are already made into fodder by directly diminishing their weapon potency. In classic air battles, war thunder already includes PvE strike aircraft that target ground vehicles. As an early solution, ground and naval battles can include PvE strike aircraft that are of a lower BR than the given BR of player controlled vehicles. Classic air battles are able to include more detail by presenting a variety of different vehicle types as fodder. In addition to the inclusion of PvE strike aircraft, ground and naval battles can include PvE fighters and PvE dive bombers. The game has yet to include PvE helicopters, so speaking about the idea here will only be counterproductive. With the inclusion of PvE aircraft, SPAA will be able to retain their role without making any player into fodder.
With nuclear escalation being centered around PvE gameplay, the eventual inclusion of helicopters will allow them to remain playable without making any player into fodder. They will remain playable even after they are no longer allowed to participate in classic ground battles.
The issue of combat between vehicles of dissimilar mobility is fundamental to the issue of SPAA in nuclear escalation and the issue of non fighters being unplayable in classic air battles. These issues all embody the same pattern. In a prior thread, I spoke about this in greater detail. Why is Nuclear Escalation so unenjoyable? - #25 by kevintloney; Why is Nuclear Escalation so unenjoyable? - #27 by kevintloney.
honeslty this just goes to show the biggest issue with cas imo
CAS just needs to takeoff, sling all their weapons, and can run carefree back to a protected airfield lined with SPAA and out of range and sight from enemy players
SPAA on the other hand:
you want ammo? welp, better hope you can hide your gigantic bus of an AA vehicle behind an allied tank, rush into a literal warzone with artillery, tanks, HE shells, missiles, autocannons, all in a vehicle with armor that can usually be .50 caled (if not coaxed), just so you can get to a capture point and ever so painfully slowly get back one missile every 30 second or so (the same amount of time it takes for a MI28 to rearm 8 free kills from behind a protected hill)
Conveniently forgetting about the ammo box and the 70 SP cost for a vehicle, which is capable of nullifying the usefulness of 900 SP CAS for most of the match.
The ammo box that lets you rearm once only and the fact that most top tier SAMs (besides SM-SV) get molested by competent pilots in any solid top tier CAS plane…
Also, MITL Mi-28NM is cheaper to spawn than Su-30SM2 with only A2A kit.
700 or so sp, which you can spawn in with a kill and a cap effectively.
Oh yeah, you can also first-spawn Helis with rockets too.
That’s fun
I also loose my iris T truck very often to tank snipes into the dish. To get any battlefield overview you need some kind of exposure. You can’t totally hide it behind a building or something similar. That means at least the dish is mostly free to shot at.
Imho these busses have no buisiness to be on the same battle maps with enemy tanks all around. Whats the point of getting killed again and again by tanks in an unarmed high value asset which is not supposed to be even close to frontlines IRL. Thats also why russian SPAAs are so crazy op inbalanced. The Pantsir thing is very small and has guns on top to defend itself. Easy to hide and far more mobile to quickly get into cover. Due to the size there is also alot viable cover on most maps. Unlike for the truck ones. Its just not fair gameplay between the factions. The smaller and the more flat the map, the more devastating are these tank on truck-SPAA kills.
Wish there would be a way to spawn outside the ground combat map, for unarmed truck like SPAAs at least.
The ammo box that lets you rearm once only
Which is fair, considering the missile count for these.
get molested by competent pilots in any solid top tier CAS plane
Dumb enough SAM players can get wrecked by competent pilots in biplanes or a SU-30 doing the jet equivalent of a T-pose, like how Meelix did. Doesn’t mean much.
700 or so sp, which you can spawn in with a kill and a cap effectively.
As opposed to spawning SAM’s even after uselessly dying two times.
Also, MITL Mi-28NM is cheaper to spawn than Su-30SM2 with only A2A kit.
Yeah, that needs a nerf.
Best way to rebalance this is to bump up the SP cost for helies with MITL to the level of jets (maybe do the same to stuff like JAGM too) as well as force them to reload farther away.
And an SP cost nerf for SAMs (should cost the same as light tanks) so that it doesn’t just go back to SAM spam.
Oh yeah, you can also first-spawn Helis with rockets too.
Are you seriously complaining about helies with unguided rockets?
Lmao.
Map design issue.
Gaijin should just make a little Pen for such SAMs, behind the tank spawn.
like other said, its is something incredibly boring to play, even if it gives me 10 eagles each time I spawn I would still choose not to spawn it because I play the game to have fun, not to suck it up doing things I hate doing. not to mention spawning it also detrimental to the team as they are 500 foot tall and their hitbox always exposed thanks to the superior map design. SLM offers three kills which is delicious
This is really / More matches LMUR 20+ kills also really
Use JAGM’s to deal with mi28nm if u can spawn apache, mi28 dircm is trash and cant jam missiles coming from front, slight left and right, and ppl doing mitl are npc targets just hovering above heli pad free kills, just temporary solution
incredibly boring to play,
Then dont. Plenty of NPC’s will take a SAM for you.
not to suck it up doing things I hate doing
Sir, this is War Thunder.
there was a time we used to eat other human, should we keep it that way?
You just want to bend over the other side, for your own fun.
What’s the difference in that?
I agree that the current balance of top tier helies is insane and should be nerfed ASAP.
But I’m also of the opinion that allowing 70 sp dummies to completely spam out any CAS efforts is also detrimental to the games design.
identify the root cause, then you’ll stopped seeing topics like “remove CAS from ground battles” or “nerf CAS please”, because we could have a gamemode where tankers can play tanks peacefully then they stop making noises to nerf CAS, tank mains and CAS mains wouldn’t even engage each other at the forum, then on the other side we have CAS mains/combined mains play combined arms so there is no need to increase sp required to spawn air units and nobody will have issues with SLMs that cost 500sp. In short, everybody can happily slinging their poops at each other, I mean we already have an example of perfectly-balanced-as-all-things-should-be, look at ground arcade players, do you see them complaint? nope
Forum dwellers will cry about anything.
Heck, stuff like “russian bias” posts keep appearing anyway, despite it being dumb BS.
because we could have a gamemode where tankers can play tanks
Yeah, and break the main modes as a result, due to playerbase segregation.
we already have an example of perfectly-balanced-as-all-things-should-be, look at ground arcade players
Well then play arcade?
You already have a practically tank only mode, in your own words.
It’s actually quite funny: for instance, aircraft can play matches consisting solely of other aircraft, whereas tanks are forced to deal with aircraft whether they like it or not. In fact, helicopters could be included in aircraft-focused matches giving them a PvP mode instead of that garbage PvE setup.
CAS in Ground Forces is highly problematic due to the imbalance it creates; often, there are enemy aircraft present but no SPAA units to counter them, while at other times, you might be in an SPAA vehicle, but no aircraft appear. A potential solution, in my view, would be to create significantly larger maps and set the team composition to 16 tanks, 6 SPAA units, 4 aircraft, and 4 helicopters. Players choosing SPAA would be restricted to that vehicle type, ensuring that 6 SPAA units are always present in the match—with each player having the option to deploy them up to three times.
So sitting ducks against mitl helis?
MITL needs to go, one of the lamest mechanic added since drone age.