Exocet missile family - Discussion

Hello everyone

Seeing as new antiships missiles recently appeared in the files (YJ family) and since Exocet has been in the files for quite a while now, not to mention the addition of Rafale M, I decided to create this thread dedicated to Exocet (and potential successor) performances and history.

First things first, the names : Exocet missile family follows a simple pattern, like for example :

AM-39

  • The 2 first letter designates where it is launched and what it is launched at. There is 3 possibilities :
    • AM => Air-Mer (Air to sea) refers to the missiles launched from an aircraft
    • SM => Sous-marin-Mer (Submarine to sea) refers to missiles launched by submarines
    • MM => Mer-Mer (Sea to sea) refers to missiles launched from ships
  • The number initially was supposed to refer to the range (39 km), but it was found in testing that the missile could reach further than that depending on conditions. The variant MM-40 for example has far more than 40km of range, and this number now seem to designate a major version of the missile.

All Exocet missile use active radar homing + inertial navigation for guidance, with the later variants adding GPS to the mix.
Now let’s dive in the different versions of the missile :

Variants
  • AM-39 (latest : Block 2, Mod 2)
    image

    • Weight : 670kg
    • Length : 4.69m
    • Diameter : 350mm
    • Speed : High subsonic, Mach 0.93 often cited
    • Warhead : SAPHE with a total weight of 165 kg
    • Range given between 50 and 70km depending on launch parameters
    • This version saw no major refit to increase its range, but saw different modifications to improve its seeker resistance to jamming and countermeasures.
    • Source : https://www.mbda-systems.com/sites/mbda/files/2024-06/2018%20EXOCET%20AM39%20datasheet.pdf
  • SM-39
    image

    • Weight : 655kg
    • Length : 4.69m
    • Diameter : 350mm
    • Speed : High subsonic, Mach 0.93 often cited
    • Warhead : SAPHE with a total weight of 165 kg
    • Range limited to 40-50 km
    • This version, just like AM-39, saw no major refit to increase its range, but saw different modifications to improve its seeker resistance to jamming and countermeasures. The missile is fired via the torpedo tubes of the submarine using a torpedo shaped capsule. It is then jettisoned of said capsule once it reaches the surface, and begins its usual journey to its target. Targetting is either done using the perisocpe of the submarine carrying it, or using the passive sonar if completely submerged.
    • Source : https://www.mbda-systems.com/sites/mbda/files/2024-11/2024-exocet-sm39-datasheet.pdf
  • MM38
    image

    • Weight : 670kg
    • Length : 4.69m
    • Diameter : 350mm
    • Speed : High subsonic, Mach 0.93 often cited
    • Warhead : SAPHE with a total weight of 165 kg
    • Range limited to ~40 km
    • First variant of the Exocet for ship to ship uses and first variant in general
  • MM40 Block 3C
    image

Here are 3 mockups of the lastest missiles for each variants :

History

Exocet’s development started in the late 1960s, following the success of th AS-33 program which was later partly used for the AS-34 Kormoran program as well. Both Exocet and Kormoran were developped in parallel and share many features.

Exocet first entered service in the french navy in 1974 (in the form of MM38), followed by AM39 in 1979 and SM39 in 1985. The most well known variant to this day is the AM39

Falklands : the first use of the missile in active combat

On the 4th of may, 1982, while a british carrier group is patrolling south east of the coast of the falklands islands, 2 Argentinian Super Etandards equipped with 1 Exocet each engage HMS Sheffield, one of the type 42 destroyers forming the anti-air screen west of the 2 carriers HMS Invincible and HMS Hermes. 1 of the missiles will eventually hit HMS Sheffield, while the other will ditch into the sea, either losing lock or not having enough propellant. No evasive action was taken by HMS Sheffield during the engagement, and she will eventually sink about a week later due to flooding in the scar left by Exocet.

An interesting video on the subject :
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=48oEzRlEB0s

on the 25th of May, SS Atlantic Conveyor is also hit by 2 Exocet missiles and eventually sinks.

5 years later, during the Iran-Irak conflict, USS Stark was also engaged by either a modified Mirage F1 or a modified Dassault Falcon 50 carrying 2 exocets. Both missiles found their mark, as the US ship was not expecting hostile activity in this area at the time and did not take evasive actions in time.

Early variants of Exocet and more generally sea skimming missiles proved to be a threat to any navy during this time. Exocet experienced some upgrades to its seeker and to its propulsion (on the sea launched variants) and eventually became a widespread missile around the world, with 4000 missiles produced in total as of 2024.

Over time however, this missile would have to face more capable interception systems. New models of antiship missiles around the globe also started to appear, being faster and boasting a longer range.

In order to address this new environment, MBDA UK and MBDA France started working on a family of missiles at the request of their respective governments. The program, initially named FC/ASW in the UK and FMAN/FMC in France eventually became Stratus. This new family will be made up of 2 main missiles :

  • Stratus LO (Low Observable) : mainly developped by the UK, which put an emphasis on a stealth, and long range missile (probably around 1000km). This version is also the successor of Storm Shadow / SCALP cruise missile
  • Stratus RS (Rapid Strike) : mainly developped by France, which put an emphasis on a fast missile (mach 3), more similar to Soviet, indian or chinese type of antiship missiles. Stratus RS is also meant to carry different tasks : antiship, SEAD, and potentially anti AWACS, making it more capable than Exocet.

These 2 missiles, while quite different in appearance, will share many internal components

Illustration : Stratus LO at the bottom and Stratus RS at the top:
714029b4d22a85b580f4d7472f3a4e3b31adcb93_2_1000x595

While the Stratus program is going on, it is still uncertain if these new missiles can fit in a Submarine. To tackle that issue, MBDA unveiled a new variant of the SM Exocet : SM40. Based on MM40 Block 3C, this missile is shortened compared to its surface launched counterpart because of limited space. Its range is therefore limited to 120km and not 250. It is only meant as a stop gap while more capable solutions are being developped, be it a new missile entirely or a derivation of Stratus.

Source : EXOCET SM40: a new game changer in the EXOCET family for mastery of the seas | MBDA

Source : MBDA unveils STRATUS for future cruise and anti-ship capabilities | MBDA

Videos

MM40 :
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8elfKsYXLW0
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KGijldcPUr4

SM39 :
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qax_aczbNVk

Additional documentation

Thank you to @Macron-Spokesman for sharing :

AM-39 Block 2 Mod 2 additional info from MBDA :

Coastal exocet :


MM38 related doc :


image

10 Likes

Aircraft missile changes:

  • AAM-4, AGM-84D, AIM-54A, AIM-54B, AIM-54C, AIM-54C+, AIM-120A, AIM-120B, AIM-120C-5, AIM-120C-7, AIM-120D, AS 34, ASM-1, Derby, Exocet, Fakour 90, Flz.Lwf. LL AIM-120 B, Flz.Lwf. LL AIM-120 C-5, Kh-31A, Kh-31AD, Kh-59MK, Kh-59MKE, MICA EM, PL-12, PL-12A, PL-15, R-77, R-77-1, R-Darter, RB 99, RVV-AE, RVV-SD, SD-10A, Sea Eagle, YJ-81, YJ-83K:
    • seeker warmup time: 0.5 → 0.3 s

Current dev version: 2.56.0.42
Current dev-stable version: 2.55.1.163
Current WiP live version: 2.55.1.162
Current regular live version: 2.55.1.162

Look who’s shown up again! I legit hope all french aircraft that can carry it will get it. This update.

2 Likes

Looking at the Exocet changes come and go in the files is like waiting for that mosquito to land on the wall at 4 AM

3 Likes

In case anyone missed the information :

1 Like

you forgot HMS Glamorgan was hit by a makeshift land-launched Argentine Exocet missile on June 12, 1982… did not sink it but accomplish the objective of stopping ships from getting too close to the coast to provide artillery fire.

1 Like

Hello guys, can anyone tell me if this document is acceptable for bug reports ? (aka has it been rightfully released?) It’s been sent on a few popular forums before

https://scribd.com/document/519107450/6-Missile-description

1 Like

I’m not sure if the document was rightfully released; however, I doubt you can use it as a source for a bug report regarding the exocet we have in game, given that it concerns the sea-to-sea version of the missile—specifically a Block 3 variant, as opposed to the Block 2 version we have in-game.

There is likely some informations that are correct, but it would be difficult to substantiate it using this document.

The warhead is what would be corrected using this document. The warhead is a common item shared by all Exocet variants, with a number of reliable secondary sources stating so

Well, in that case this document should be good to use

1 Like

Hey, this is a nice good document for future use for the Exocet Block 3.

1 Like

So I seen your recent report on the Exocet warhead. The report has some things wrong with it although you brought us a very nice source.

In the report, the source that says all exocets use the same warhead was a source made before the existence of the Exocet Block 3. If you can find a source stating that the Exocet Block 3 uses the same warhead as the Block 2, then that would be all good to go.

Otherwise the AM39 is actually said to have an explosive mass of less than 50kg PBX according to a primary source that can be found here: https://web.archive.org/web/20160506013359/http://www.eurenco.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/EURENCO_Explosives2_Division.pdf

Exocet missile overperforming in explosive mass // Gaijin.net // Issues

1 Like

Hello, thank you for commenting both here and on the report. I have responded to your comment over there.

in short, all sources give circumstantial evidence that the warhead on the Exocet was never changed. Furthermore the burden of proof would be for someone trying to say it has indeed changed.

With regard to your Eurenco document, it is very nice but the warhead size cannot be considered as reliable. For example it gives both heavyweight torpedos less than 100kg in explosive mass, when this is clearly impossible : contradicted by all secondary sources, and never has there been a modern HWT with such little explosive weight.

https://nationalinterest.org/blog/buzz/french-nuclear-attack-submarine-sunk-us-navy-aircraft-24215

https://lemarin.ouest-france.fr/defense/long-format-la-torpille-une-arme-plus-que-centenaire-toujours-autant-utilisee-par-les-marines-ec2bb87e-b93d-11ef-b8b6-a281cdb12686

Hey, my bad for taking a little while to respond. Warheads can remain the same weight while being changed. For example, the MICA NG is said to have a strengthened warhead according to a primary source, while still having the same warhead weight of the original MICA (12kg). Warheads typically contain other components such as wiring, fuzes, and etc. It is possible for explosive mass to increase while warhead weight remain the same. No sources explicitly state that the warhead remained the same between Exocet Block 2 and Block 3.

In the eyes of Gaijin, primary sources outweigh all secondary sources. Eurenco would override whatever other sources is used unless another primary source is used. BUT, in this case none of the secondary sources you used is contradictory to Eurenco, because warhead mass =/= explosive mass.

Take a look at the AS-30 warhead from the Mirage 3 manual, it is stated that there are 2 different available warheads available. One warhead is a semi armor-piercing warhead weighing 215kg with an explosive mass of 25kg and a general warhead of 229kg with an explosive mass of 73kg. You can see that explosive mass is significantly less than the warhead mass.

Spoiler

Translated


Non-Translated

Full page

Source cover

The Eurenco document explicitly talks about the explosive mass, while the sources you used talks about warhead mass. The earlier document from MBDA is explicit about Exocet Block 3’s explosive mass.

1 Like