Smin did answer us in the French tech tree discord :
Less than 40 reports have been directly refused and will need to be redone, the only reports of importance seem to be the missing spall liners on the VBCI and Vextra.
I also asked if reports regarding the rafale that were accepted and implemented would be reviewed, and Smin answered
For now, it’s in the devs/moderators hand. I personally don’t think (and hope) that no reports on the rafale would be reverted, although we still don’t know which reports actually contained false info (rafale, Leclerc, or something not even French ?).
But, for all the people that complain about the “bad very bad French reporters faking reports”, I guess we will now be able to see where all that stand, as we can be assured that all related reports have been or will now be thoroughly checked. I guess we will see if the rafale gets some changed in the near future if that’s the case.
Those are the reports refused without check from my understanding as they were written by that person and devs are taking no chance
The only reports of importance according to Smin are missing spall liners. From this, I personally infer the rest of the reports are about to 3D model changes or obscure mechanics that are not in game.
And as I said, we will see about all the rafales reports that were implemented as the devs are going through them again
The exact wording is that he would recommend remaking. This could quite easily mean that the rest of the reports could easily include reports for features in game which have been reviewed and are not valid.
I’m specifically saying not obscure mechanics, but say for example a report on the performance which was reviewed and deemed invalid and is therefore not “worth remaking”
I’ve been flying the Rafale in the Nuclear Escalation event, and now that the S-300 has been added, I’ve noticed something strange.
Every time I’ve been shot down by an S-300, my RWR never detected it. I wasn’t getting any radar warning at all before being hit.
So far, it’s happened twice. Once while the S-300 was in front of me, and once while it was behind me. In comparison, my RWR detects the Buk without any issues.
Is this a bug, or is the Rafale unable to detect the S-300’s radar and missilse at all?
You can read above dozen of comments from people that are generally critical of the reports and the discussions have largely remained respectful. You could also go to DM with @Macron-Spokesman if you have qualms with him, o r any mod to discuss what you believe was faked, if you don’t feel like trying to post something that follows the rules of the forum in this thread.
Especially since this thread is often very scrutinized so that it remains respectful (The real battlefield is in the dedicated thread)
Edit : well, that didn’t miss, did not even have time to reply
That’s fair, I haven’t touch the game above 10.0 for a few months now, and last I played nuke thunder it was with the Mig23’s terrible RWR.
But can’t a S300 lock be attributed to it shooting at another target as well ? for example at another player or even at some munitions that happen to be roughly in line with the radar and your RWR.
