Changes to the Naval Enduring Confrontation Mode

Yep. its dumb af. But why change actual naval ec mechanics to make the rat race less punishing, give lower BR ships something to do that they arent completely outclassed against (and places where they can fight each other, even bots of their BR range would ACTUALLY be good for that, but battleships are not allowed to spawn at) and make getting bullied less punishing and bullying less rewarding? when you can just add bots lol

I think there needs to be a middle ground between a system that simply doesnt let the strongest ships spawn on repeat and that encourages some diversity in a lineup (while obviously getting rid of the blatant disbalances between teams)

and the new system that allows more players more easily to play that one ship they want to play and that doesnt force you to respawn a 5.0 destroyer over and over again once youve fallen too far behind to fight 8.7s.

Brackets are a good start to encourage that. But inside those brackets, some sort of sp system would help so the best players cant loopspawn only their best ships. together with a respawn timer, Even better a modified one like @Kweedko suggested. that puts a timer for this ship on the entire map. And that starts as soon as you died. Not the moment you spawn. In a 3 hour gamemode players should be able to play one other ship for the 10 minutes they have to wait until they can spawn their iowa/sojuz/whatever is the absolute best ship of that bracket again.

Hell, you could even establish brackets that start at, lets just pick something random (no actual thought put into if that would be a good cutoff, just an example) 7.0:
7.0 ships dont cost Spawnpoints. Then it slowly goes up till 8.7, which cost lets say 300 or 400 SP like in the old system (again, just an example for the next thing)
IF you spawn lower br ships than the minimal Free SP BR of 7.0
You get increased rewards of SL and RP for all actions
AND you get some amount of spawnpoints as soon as you played that ship for at least (random number) 5 minutes. So people could and would bring destroyers. there would be an incentive to do so. And lots of them can and would still be viable. It wouldnt be only battleships because lots of plaers still enjoy both playstyles even if you cant seriously harm a battleship in a 5.0 destroyer. But theres things you can do in a destroyer that you cant do in a battleship at all.

Those rewards for completing EC dynamic missions targets are pathetic, - one regular kill give you more reward than killing all AI ships in convoy, or capturing the port point, no wonder everyone just shooting each other, instead of completing missions and capturing port points. That’s not enough for the effort and risks, especially on low ranks, where escort ships and costal turrets pommel you hard but give almost no rewards.


image

Colour me not shocked the bug report team being useless, I honestly think that’s as bad as Grantaire’s bug report for the E50 type Frigate Le Brestois missing fire directors in regards to mods closing reports by their stupid standards.

Even stranger when the SS Goldenfels sink when all three compartments are blackened out.

And even some ports could not be captured properly, just cause shore batteries could not be targeted.


1 Like

Saw this bug and not once(
Some of them just covered by landscape, buildings of port infrastructure and so on…

Even capturing all ports not leading game over.

And respawns respawning you opposite direction out of combat targets.

Is anything working in EC?

1 Like

That sounds a little too arcadey for my taste, maybe something there you manually set the correction to shoot +/- x range and it’s just applies that correction to each range update, you still have to change the correction when the target changes it’s heading or speed, but removes the constant changes when it’s maintaining a consistent course/speed.

And another bug

16 vs 4 match - MM adding players over time to only one team. Replay

1 Like

What in the…ah actually im not surprised that stuff like this happens…

Why should it? the enemies still have spawns to recapture ports. Have you played naval ec before, in the old version? honest question… i think thats not a bug thats intended. that happened regularly on all maps.

Theres even specific spawns that pop up once all ports are captured, and a lot of them are very convenient to recapture. Its only annoying in matches and thats usually the case where you captured all ports, the enemy team is just 1 or 2 players and theres no missions popping up to finish the match and drain more tickets and some clueless dudes just start spamming at a unscouted carrier, thus not even making it possible to drain tickets by sinking the carrier. And theres no more ports to capture to finish the match. Then everyone is idling, waiting for some new missions to appear.

1 Like

I can agree that if you capture the whole points on map, the mission should end after 10min, this is kinda boring to have a whole lobby hold in hostage just because the last two players do not want to leave.

1 Like

Sure, they could implement that. Because that

situation is just annoying.

I just dont think that it is a bug. Could happen on basically any map. Maps where i had full caps happen: Dover Strait, Saipan, Port Moresby and malta.

TF theres a wiki article for naval ec that you will probably never find browsing on the wiki, only if you google it:

@Stona_WT @Smin1080p_WT
Have you seen the comments on this devblog and the post, and how much criticism you’ve received?

1 Like

Been playing the new Naval EC, and it’s just no fun, mind you I’ve never been able to play the original Naval EC because the times never aligned, but new Naval EC as far as I have played is just a gigantic superbowl fight between BB’s and that’s about it, sometimes, just sometimes, someone is crazy enough to spawn into a Cruiser, only to get obliterated by half the enemy team or yours, because well, everyone is in a BB.

Naval should be a combination of BB’s, CA’s, CL’s and DD’s working together, but the game just fails to do that, Naval continue’s to just fail. EC is great for grinding and getting to that next ship, but then, why is that the bar that is now set on what is acceptable quality from Gaijin?

How about FUN? Having the next ship take a while doesn’t really matter, if the gamemode is actually really fun to play, further more, while this may be more personal, I do wonder if other Naval fans reflect the same feelings, but to me in Naval, getting to the whole next BR bracket, isn’t the drug it is for me as it is in Air or Ground, I play specific vessels, because I like their history and find them cool, so to me personally, it’s even more paramount for the gamemode it self to be fun, and for the ship classes to have a role.

I feel like naval has always been a knee-jerk reaction of Gaijin to try and complete the whole “WAR” circle despite the fact that Naval combat just continues to elude them, because as it currently stands Naval is still just not really fun, because individual ship classes that aren’t BB’s just don’t get to shine in a way that makes them actually useful and worth using, because right now, firepower is the only thing that matters, and guess what, that’s a BB and either you spawn in one, or get lost.

And if you do happen to destroy a enemy BB, it doesn’t matter, because they get to take it out right away again, probably from the same base that they just came from 12km back, because the time for them to leave their spawn and to sail to you, and you to them to take them down probably took longer then the respawn timer, making that kill in general worthless, except for the Research and silver lions you got out of it.

It’s just frustrating, because I left Naval Arcade Battles and Naval Realistic Battle’s, and went to the new EC mode, just to find current EC to be precisely that but with extra steps. Sure the distance is longer, and there is the illusion of objectives, but it’s just Battleship brawls between two sides, and I like BB’s as much as the next person, but I also love my Cruisers, and I feel forced to play BB’s because otherwise I won’t be able to contribute.

It’s just all so frustrating.

1 Like

You don’t get war thunder. Sometimes you are the predator, sometimes you are the prey. Buying top tier BB will not give you skill of combat awareness, knowing of the maps and situations. In arcade some cruisers is very potent against BB just cause they have angry torpedoes and superior speed and maneuverability. And others is menace to each other and DDs due to amount of guns and Rate of fire. Planes also always an option to harass big boats.

Git good.

ps. NEC is still need improvements and adjustments. Like redesigning of some maps Denmark EC should be removed from MM until redesign

pps. Same for overall naval matchmaking. Naval matchmaking need some improvements

Yeah mate, the problem is, the thing you are saying, is not the thing I’m seeing, when playing EC. Both teams, are 100% BB’s and at best, you’ll have someone spawn a CL, CA, I have however, seen more DD’s and CA’s/CL’s in Regular Arcade and Realistic in comparison to EC, when I have been lead to believe from old EC players, that EC used to have more DD, CL and CA use, because you had to, in order to bring out a BB.

1 Like

In old EC were more diversity of ship types, not cause you forced to use DD, but cause it was a matchmaking where 5.0 to 8.7 are in the same queue and therefore land in the same match. Believe me it’s not fun fighting 5.7 cruiser against team of 8.7 BB after 20 mins in game.

And I’m not denying that, that doesn’t sound fun, but that is more at fault, to me at least to the game-mode essentially being a slug fest between ships, and for there to not really be anything to do for Cruisers and DD’s and them not really being special, The mode doesn’t promote their usage, they don’t really have much utility besides smokes and torps, which, with how wide and open EC maps are I find, are not that useful unless you catch a BB out. And maybe it’s world of warships instinct, but if I spot a Cruiser with torps in the distance, my first instinct is to usually instantly reposition, because I by default assume torps have been sent my way.

With submarines soonTM making their debut into warthunder Naval, I wonder what will change to accommodate that, or if they’ll just drop them into EC without much thought, and call it a day.

I just don’t think, with how Naval EC is thus far, it’s going reinvigorate Naval or support a healthy player-base, I have however seen some really good suggestions by players in this thread, that I would wish and hope the devs take a look at.

Eitherway, while current EC is disappointing to me, it’s no skin of my back, and if you find it fun as it is now, I’m not trying to detract from your experience. Time will tell whether or not Naval fizzles out again, or actually retains players overtime.

Old EC would disappoint you too. EC was never finished or good enough. What you see here in thread is small community of “old EC” lovers distressed by the changes.

Actually devs can just return “old EC”(with respawn points and imbalances) in weekend events for them to enjoy(but with good changes as arcade ones and respawn blocks) and problem will be slowed, it’s a small community so you don’t need a lot of server power for a couple of matches in 3 hour, but they will be pleased and praise the snail.

And on top of that add its missions for “custom battles” maps for ability to create events on those maps and test them.

images

It will be very disappointing to play submarines ( he will op against only this 2 class) only against battleships and cruisers; at low tiers, they will be extremely difficult to use because you’ll constantly run into destroyers that can easily kill you. In the old EC, submarines could have served as a good counter to those managing to secure a battleship. In this new version compounded by the addition of mindless bots that just make the 3-hour grind a total pain you don’t even get to see a variety of ship classes in play, as most would be rendered useless. I really hope they walk back some of these decisions; until that happens, I along with many other players won’t be playing them.
you can see how is better now respect past the ec. hahaha 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣