Changes to Bomber Survivability Feedback and Discussion

Youve been emotionally screeching for hours even calling me a “moron” and “piece of shit”, thats not someone keeping a level head thinking with logic, Once this bomber rework is implemented, it will trickle its way down to attackers, heavy fighters, and eventually fighters

1 Like

Plenty of people here with tons of trouble parsing information from even my little posts, id be surprised if they even read halfway through that wonderful and fleshed out post of yours

1 Like

Actually, I was planning to include the German Air Force’s reports and technical analyses from that era as well, but unfortunately, the archive website went under maintenance right while I was doing my research. I’ll be back with a much more detailed report soon, but still, it’s just going to get rejected by people who are simply afraid they won’t be able to get easy kills anymore.

1 Like

I am looking forward to reading it after work man, great job anyhow

1 Like

My wife has started getting angry lately because I haven’t been paying attention to her. I hope I’m not one of those B-17s shot down by 105mm flak rounds.

1 Like

its honestly kinda sad how far down its gone from the first dev server, one strafe from .50s is more than enough to light all 3 B29s in formation on fire. these arent even air belts, this is default.

4 Likes

If the B-17 was hit by Flak at bombing altitude (over 6,000 m), it necessarily had to be from heavy artillery, at least 88 mm. All those damage should correspond to that class of calibers.

From what can be seen on the B-17, you could blow away almost the entire rear half of the wing without it snapping off, since the rear spar is located nearly 2 meters behind the leading edge. Neither the shrapnel nor the blast wave seem to have a critical destructive effect on the spar, likely due to its truss design, which prevented pressure confinement (blast “passes through” without transferring all of its energy to the component).

image

4 Likes

I agree with what you’re saying; in fact, the German air force’s analysis of wrecks and captured aircraft between 1940 and 1945 shows that they pointed this out as well. Could you please share the links and sources of the photos you posted?

Here is Korean Air Lines 902 after crashing landing on a frozen lake in Karelia. It was hit by an R-60 in the left wing by an Su-15. It tore off the wingtip and destroyed one engine which sent debris into the fuselage that killed two passengers and caused rapid decompression. Accounts differ on the time it took the plane to land after being hit. The Soviets claim KAL 902 took 40 minutes to find an area to land, passengers claim it took an hour and 40 minutes.

3 Likes

Sure
https://catalog.archives.gov/id/204900080
https://catalog.archives.gov/id/204842217
https://catalog.archives.gov/id/204842240
https://catalog.archives.gov/id/204907973

1 Like

And this is a passenger plane.

2 Likes

Thx bro

1 Like

this actually brings up a great point too for all the people talking about how “unrealistic” it is for bombers to tank missiles, wasnt the B52 infamous for tanking multiple SAM hits over its lifetime and still flying perfectly fine

3 Likes

Exactly This is one of the points, but people don’t want to see it.

1 Like

I know there was the B-52 that survived an AGM-88 to the tail. I can’t find photos but apparently several B-52’s survived S-75 hits in Vietnam. 55-0074 apparently took three hits and returned to base.

4 Likes

B-But how is that even possible? A 30mm cannon should have taken it down in 3 shots (!) :(

1 Like

Suddenly my little image I made to calculate how much skin gets messed up for different fillers based on math equations for the strength of aircraft skin doesnt seem too far off lol

Didnt a cargo jet tank a manpad to its wingtip? And the wingtip didnt fall off, and its not even military

1 Like

Additionally, I would like to point out that the 5th image in the report I shared was taken after two B-17s collided on their way back from a mission and made an emergency landing; this further demonstrates the durability of this aircraft.

I agree. I think the structure of all aircraft needs to be improved. Bf 109 shooting down a Hurricane over Malta.

2 Likes