Almost 2027 and Russia still doesnt have a top tier light tank / IFV

HSTVL is literally one of the best high-tier ish light tanks in the game.
France has a very good option with the Jaguar, Italy Centauro which both outperform what Russia has by a mile.

Britain/Israel/Germany are sad, would be instant better if they finaly fix Nato 30mm and ammo burnout.

1 Like

Only thing better on vt 5, is he vt shell… ( what is slow as f) and it’s not so tall.
Ok, 5s autoloader, but booker gets 5.3 on expert…

But overall that VT5 br is complete joke, 20mm autocannon on turret and bye bye ammo :D

They are not IFV as i already said. Centauro is a heavy tank destroyer, nearest to 2S38 as classification. Jaguar is an EBRC and HSTV-L is an HSTV, a prototype. Only the last one is a light tank but not IFV. Namer, Eitan, boxer, Type 24, are IFV. 2S25 is a light tank destroyer, so if you talk about light vehicles you should say Russia has a 10.0 light tank XD For this reason i said:

No one cares, they are classified as light tank ingame, therefore thats their role.

If you put it that way, then Great Britain’s highest BR tank destroyer is an 8.3. It’s 2027 and are we still stuck with nothing higher than 8.3? Meanwhile, Russia has an 11.7… Who gets priority?

Which just shows how non sensical the BMPTs classification as a missile TD is in the first place.

The difference is, that tank destroyers don’t fill a very important role.
You get an ammo crate, great.

Add tank destroyers for every nation, doesn’t make a difference.
Go ahead and make the BMPT a light tank and see what a shitshow that is going to be.

The scouting ability for reduced CAS points, plus the drone and this all combined in a good vehicle is indefinately more worth than an ammo crate.

1 Like

These responses are a classic case of tunnel vision, you only see what suits your own narrative. Who decided that tank destroyers don’t play a significant role, while reconnaissance vehicles or IFVs do? Who are you to make such a claim? I could just as easily argue the opposite… Russia lacks an IFV at a high battle rating, just as other nations lack certain things that Russia possesses.

I’d like to point out that many of the “classifications” in the game are incorrect, likely done just to balance deployment costs or simplify management. That doesn’t mean the vehicles themselves are missing; it’s just that, for Gaijin, it apparently seemed more appropriate to categorize the Centauro (a heavy tank destroyer) as a light tank, and the BMPT (a heavy support vehicle) as a tank destroyer.

I mean all of that is nonsense. Just played several maps where the bmpt sat behind cover and camped spawn exits.

Also, the xm246 and gepard both pop when you shoot their turret soooo… not a real comparison. The t58 is getting moved up and needs a reload nerf.

So thanks for quoting your satirical copy paste red herring fallacies.

You’re also engaging in whataboutism, tu quoque and false equivalence fallacies. All of which are intellectually dishonest.

Light tanks can reduce SP cost to spawn a plane by scouting. TDs at high-top tier are generally just worse but cheaper to spawn alternatives to MBTs.

Just spawning any of the 12.0+ Abrams also does the trick nowadays. Any self respecting 12.0+ Abrams player really should be snacking on BMPTs 80% of the time now.

Alright… But the point remains that, in YOUR view, this is a more important role. In my opinion, having a tank capable of holding out for 10 minutes under fire from 3 other tanks, or advancing alone against 2 or 3 IFVs and coming out as winner, is more important.

BMPTs are known to be noobfarmers as you described here. Try the same situation against experienced players in any MBT and the BMPT ends up like an easy snack.

Like I said, worse MBT that is cheaper to spawn. Good for hunting light tanks, gets smacked around by most MBTs if the players have 2 braincells that sometimes work together.

If I could choose the skill level of the players on my team, I’d say you’re right. Unfortunately, that’s not the case, so what then? Given the random nature of the players you end up with, which one has a greater impact? A BMPT can still perform well even in the hands of a low-skill player. An IFV, in the hands of a poor player, gets blown up in 4 seconds… It’s easy to conduct an analysis if you simply remove inconvenient factors from the equation or make unrealistic assumptions.

I still maintain that Russia lacks a top-tier IFV, though other nations also lack certain assets. It’s just a matter of prioritizing the right things.

Justifying this by saying “everyone has a Leopard” or “everyone has an M1” doesn’t seem like a valid argument to me, especially since this is a point often criticized by players of those very nations, who would prefer indigenous tanks rather than the typical “copy-paste” approach from Gaijin.

1 Like

An IFV in the hands of a poor player can still sit in the back of the map or behind a ridge and scout, meaning that said person will have an incredibly easy time getting into CAS no matter what.

BMPT has to roll the dice every time they push out, but given it’s limited weaponry compared to an MBT it’s odds are lower.

Light tanks have value no matter how bad the player is. As long as they know the binocs and scout keys you can get value out of them.

Oh I 100% agree with you about that being just lazy balancing from Gaijin, but unfortunately that is the balancing we are stuck with.

After those two statements it’s clear that you don’t play IFVs and have no idea what you’re talking about. “Hanging out at the back of the map” XD you’d better hope the map actually allows for that, that there aren’t direct lines of sight from spawn to spawn, or that you don’t get pushed all the way back to your spawn within two minutes. Sure, IFVs have those “legendary” indestructible drones they can use to scout for 40 minutes XD. Jump into one of my matches and try launching them; I’ll shoot them down in three seconds flat. The only players who leave drones in the air are the ones you’d call “bad.” Just to be clear: if you’re using a BMPT and there are drones in the air flying freely, the problem is you, not the IFVs. The BMPT was designed specifically to take out threats on the upper floors of buildings, as well as drones and helicopters, you’ve even got programmable ammunition, yet here you are, complaining about the BMPT. Move and countermove. If you let me do what I want, I’m not the problem.

Just think… for some strange, unknown reason, Israeli IFVs don’t have programmable ammunition, maybe Gandalf knows why. So, if you shoot down their drone, they can’t even take out the ones belonging to your own team.

My 12th most played tank is the CV9035NL with 566 games, which was an IFV last time I checked (and I perform better in my 35NL than you in most of your tanks lol). I also have 9/10 trees up to 12.7, I have played a lot of different IFVs.

Also seeing your overall performance makes this quoted little bit cute.

technically only Italy and sweden have a true top tier light tank everyone else has 1 rank under

1 Like

Do you feel fulfilled now? It seems you really don’t have much going on in your life, but to each their own. These statements of yours only create a greater contradiction with what you claimed earlier… perhaps you just got lucky in your matches… Who knows? That’s just my assumption, much like your own that IFVs have a bigger impact on the game than a vehicle classified as a tank destroyer (in-game), like the BMPT. In any case, I wouldn’t go around acting like a big shot while playing an IFV with 130mm of penetration and a 200-round-per-minute rate of fire at a 9.7 BR, it’s just a bit of fun, really… I personally take my 10.7 vehicles up against 12.7s. My stats might not be the highest, but I have a great time, and I enjoy the challenge ;) I don’t have to prove to anyone that I’ve got a bigger one and i’m not here to cry because i don’t have a 12.7 IFV.

I mean it’s my day off, so no shit I’m chilling on here a little bit between doing stuff.

If you want to tell someone that they have no idea what they are doing, better be prepared for a reply.

I usually don’t. It’s just a fun vehicle that I use to grind. It’s not even particulsrly good, just fun.

BMD-4, BMD-4M, BMD-4M2. The 2S25 is already one of the best glass-cannon traditional light tanks to begin with too, lol.