The new American stealth helicopter Comanche should be in the normal tech tree, not premium

Frankly I’m surprised they added the FCR and gave it 114Bs, seems like such a useless piece of equipment if it does not even have Ks, I am aware that all the laser hellfires have the same guidance values so it does not matter regardless but that is besides the point.

Heck, we already have really REALLY powerful SAMs coming now, why not give us 114Ls on everything that can carry them, its not like they can outrange any of the top tier SAMs anymore either now.

IMO just make the premium FCRless but with Ks and the tech tree one get 114Ls and the FCR, it can even be foldered with the AH-64D if needed.

That’s a isolated case, yesterday my team was dominating using close air support. At least four planes in the air, we ended up losing despite the situation.

And I don’t get it “for free”, like researching at minimum five helicopters to get the Ka-52 and on top of that going the stock time, the RAH-66 Comanche as a premium is a huge benefit.

1 Like

Let’s remember that while all nations have current tanks, such as Germany’s Leopard 2A7 (2017) or russia with the t72bvm3 (2017) and the t90m (2019), The US continues with the Abrams SEP v2 (2012) when they could perfectly well add the sep v3 which is from 2017,On top of that, the vehicle they’re going to include in the event is only an amphibious M18 when they could have included something more interesting like the Sherman Crocodile.

Boy, do I have good news for you: You only have to spend 50€! And if you wait a little, it is yours for 25€!
Problem solved.

Tbh the RAH-66 does not really bring anything to the table the AH-64A premium does not bar the funni stealth, both equip the same exact weapons and have nearly identical sensor systems bar the FCR which does not really do anything for 114Bs.

This of course, does currently come at the cost of countermeasure systems, but that should change hopefully which would put it at the same BR as the premium apaches.

Given that situation, the KA-50 premium vs 52 or comanche vs AH-64D is a rather apt comparison overall.

I will still say the 50 and 52 have vastly superior ord due to the vikhir still being insane though.

Free. As I said, you can get the KA52 for free, and if you don’t want to waste your time, you can always buy the KA50. They give you the option to decide. In my case, it’s either you pay or you pay. There’s no other option.Also, I’m one of those people who doesn’t spend any money on games, making something of quality exclusive by paying is excessive, I understand that there are things like Tiger Ost,however, Comanche does not have a free version.

1 Like

Ka-50 is limited because of the optics zoom multipliers, everything else is fine, but my problem with the Ka-52 and any other SACLos and Beam-riding missiles platforms is how the missile itself behaves.

That’s why I said the Tiger HAD Block 2 is worse to fight against as it uses IR missile. I understand that IR ATGM don’t behave perfectly but due to the amount it can carry can counter by overwhelming a target.

1 Like

Thanks a lot, but are we crazy? How can we normalize spending €25 for a pixel helicopter? Or €70 for a tank? €70 is what a AAA game costs.

2 Likes

People asked for the free, aka. tech tree BMD-4M and we still here today. RAH-66 Comanche is unlikely to have a counterpart on the tech tree. Being premium doesn’t mean quality, the F-4EJ ADTW is a good example of this, and knowing some issues pointed by the community the stealth mechanic in the RAH-66 Comanche apparently doesn’t work properly.

2 Likes

Likewise, the Tiger is a German helicopter, but have you ever seen an American Apache change direction in battle? The most I’ve seen is two or three kills,They then end up being eradicated by a pantsir or flakrad

Never seen an AH-64 changing the fate of an battle bevause is widely known how bad SACLos and Beam-riding ATGMs is today. The Tiger HAD Block 2 is the French model of the Eurocopter.

1 Like

Indeed, still the versatility of the Vikhir is what is powerful about it, that and the direct flight path.

A 114 will seldom ever achieve the feats a well deployed Vikhir will.

If we had to pit a RAH-66 against a KA-50 right now, even if the RAH-66 got it’s countermeasures, I would put money on the KA-50 winning nearly every time. Now, if the RAH-66 had 114Ls this is a totally different situation and at that point, I see no issue for the KA-52 to acquire LMURs as well. A 114L vs LMUR fight to me is far more balanced than SALH 114 vs Vikhir though.

B doesnt have tandem charge

1 Like

Stealth doesn’t mean invisible. I’m tired of people saying that stealth mechanics are poorly done in War Thunder. I use the F117 in top tier without any problems, It’s as easy as using it at 6,000 meters high and only opening your bomb bay when you have a clear target. After releasing the bomb, you close it and become undetectable to radar again.The Comanche, for its part, is “almost” invisible on radar,However, it is not invisible to the eye, but it does not matter because it is capable of withstanding missiles, cannon fire, and heavy machine guns. It is the first true attack helicopter for the US and they have made it a premium.

1 Like

Yes and thats the only change the K has even though it received an entire digital autopilot upgrade among other things.

It gets more pen and thats about it when it should be far more.

Seriously, the fact that the only tangible difference from the A all the way to the K in WT being the warhead and thats it is very disappointing.

I don’t think Ka-52 needs more weapons despite my past comments, and regarding the Ka-50 it needs to be at close, which restrict the Vikhr to its maximum potential only to the Ka-52 due to the thermal imaging devices and better optic zoom values, even, the Mi-28MN has better optic values than the Ka-52, maybe I just wasted time researching the Ka-52.

EXACTLY!! That’s what I mean, they’ve finally added a good helicopter to the US, and those shameless bastards have made it premium!!!

1 Like

Heat signature specially, is one of the most common issues on stealth vehicles in-game.

Also missing everything it lacks, it’s a great helicopter, a tank in the air, it should be free

I’d say thats a good example of the give and take in the end, the 114B is still a largely inferior weapon to the Vikhir, however, most of the SALH armed 114 carriers do indeed have better optics, although some do actually get rather close to the KA-50’s x23 zoom, eg stuff like the G-Lynx only sports a max zoom of x12, or the AH-1W sporting x13.

In the realm of top tier vs premium helos as well, I have had little interest in grinding out the AH-64D over just using the premium AH-64As. The D brings functionally nothing to the table currently bar the FCR which provides no real benefit right now, its sadly a waste of my time. The RAH-66 does not really change that dynamic currently in the US tree, the lower tier helos already have all the bells and whistles higher tier helos have, the RAH-66 also fails to really do anything new bar stealth. I cant see someone with the Peten really being any worse off than a RAH-66 pilot, heck, the RAH-66 may be slightly worse due to it having a lower total payload comparatively.