Responding to Feedback on the Planned Battle Rating Changes April 2025

3.0 for the Gabbiano, 3.3 fo Ghibli, these should be the right brs.

At least now it won’t face 5.0 DDs anymore ( it will still be malleted by 4.0-4.3 ships that are way better than it in every way), that’s a little win.

I’m extremely glad the VEXTRA gets its OFL 105 G2*. It’s finally reaching the performance of the gun seen on other wheeled tanks at the BR.
I do still believe that the 10.0 AMX40 is not coherent with other vehicles at the same BR, mainly in the face of the Leopard 2K. The leopard is better than the AMX in basically every regard (better armor, shell, 20mm roof mounted, mobility…) and yet sits at the same BR.
Either the AMX40 would need some of its reports actionned (armor, shell, assisted loading mechanism), or the vehicles that over perform the AMX40 should also go up in BR (following a decompression of high tier - 9.0 onwards)

13 Likes

how about 6 similar Tornado IDS on different ARB BR?
When fix?

image

Dont do it. This planes on balance in 11.0.

Made this action your kill China setup 11.0 but Japanes and USA stay strong becose they play with 11.3 tanks.

9 Likes

They are going up because they are good at the only thing they can do…and against players that try to fight energy retention

1 Like

LOL, just straight up removed the sim column, guess sim is not a real game mode. We need 12.3 and 13.3 brackets and BR adjustments to make them balanced.

Ah yes, the obvious comparison of light and medium tanks to a heavy tank…

I don’t agree with the change, but always comparing every single tank around 6.3-7.3 to a heavy tank is absolutely ridiculous.

The most common comparison i see is T44 to Tiger 2, when actually you should compare it to M26.

You know, actual medium tank at the same BR…

best choice is to give F-5T AGM-65D
leave others on 11.0

During last months it has been rare in 4.3 BR range ground RB not to see a Yak-9K and it’s common up to about 6.0. At best I counted 6 of them in a single battle. Full squads of them aren’t that rare either.

Too bad thunderskill is the only available statistics. For what’s it worth, there it stands as the most used piston engine aircraft by a large margin.

5 Likes

Why is the AMX going up!? at this point its becoming completely obsolete, its a subsonic plane with only GBUS!

5 Likes

I also have an issue with the BR of the Super Étendard at 11.0. In the same fashion, it’s comparatively much worse than say the MiG 27K at the same BR. The SEM using only 2 AS30L or GBUs is also completely outclassed by long range SAM (ADATS, ITO, Pantsir), and the maximum 2 magic 1 in air-air makes it completely irrelevant against any aircraft near or above 11.0 (its air RB BR is a good example).
I think 10.7 is the max BR it should go to, as it puts it at the very lowest at 9.7, where most nations feature at least MANPAD SAMs.
The Mirage 2000 D R1 at just one BR bracket above is significant’y better in every single metric : speed, maneuverability, air to air, air to ground, countermeasures…
And it’s not like it has a lineup at either BR. The plane is quite rarely used, and only with the current 10.7 leopard at best (but usually the now 10.0 AMX40 + VEXTRA lineup) and 11.0 will force the player to uptier their 9.7-10.7 to 11.0, where full uptiers against top of the line vehicles are common

9 Likes

It’s not obsolete but simply not the most effective. After all it has good weapons and decent pod, specially in simulator battles where ground striking are very important to end a match with the destruction of the enemy’s airfield.

seems like we have the issue of only good players being able to do well in certain vehicles so only good players play it which makes their stats look better then they actually are.

This post was flagged by the community and is temporarily hidden.

2 Likes

This post was flagged by the community and is temporarily hidden.

3 Likes

F/A-18A continue to terrorize anything within the 12.3-11.3 range. Great job gaijin. US mains babied as always. Brilliant.

4 Likes

I fully see how it is looking amazing in statistics. If you only spawn it in ideal weather conditions, with no friendly SAM and multiple close flying enemy aircraft clearly visibly to you it is amazing.
Issue is this is not what most or even just the average game looks like, so instead players don’t spawn it and are forced to rely on teammates or gather the points for a fighter. Statistics can’t show how many times a player decides to not spawn it, so it seems overpowered on paper.

My guess for why they stick with it, is that there is probably a rigid internal rule, that says if a vehicle is straying too far from the desired statistics value, they are not allowed to listen to opposite feedback anymore. That’s probably why this sounds like it’s written by someone not playing the game, because that’s probably who made this rule in the first place.

7 Likes

Gajin if u dont do it. I buy Khalid on fullprice.
If u do it, im going donate in EVE.

Made ur choice!

we might as well move it to 12.0 while were at it because we all know every french vehicle is op and needs to be nerfed

1 Like

image
P-47D-30s are the same plane but with airbrakes but they stay 5.0. Obviously Italy and China pilots are bit better on average than US but really We don’t have enough decompression for airbrake on a plane to add 0.3 br. Not even going to mention D-30 being 3.7 in air sim which is a crime against humanity.

9 Likes